All about dinosaurs, fossils and prehistoric animals by Everything Dinosaur team members.

Pictures of fossils, fossil hunting trips, fossil sites and photographs relating to fossil hunting and fossil finds.

29 03, 2022

When Did the Beetles Take Over the World?

By |2024-10-30T13:08:19+00:00March 29th, 2022|Categories: Adobe CS5, Animal News Stories, Dinosaur and Prehistoric Animal News Stories, Main Page, Palaeontological articles, Photos/Pictures of Fossils|1 Comment

Remarkably, one in four named animal species is a beetle. There are over 380,000 beetle species that have been scientifically described and perhaps several million more awaiting formal description. Members of the Order Coleoptera are distinguished from other insects as their front pair of wings are hardened into wing-cases (elytra) and they exploit a huge range of ecological niches and environments. However, their evolutionary origins remain uncertain and it is not known exactly when these six-legged animals became so numerous and specious.

Seventeen scientists including researchers from the University of Bristol have set about unravelling the evolutionary history of these amazing insects.

Permian beetle fossils and line drawings.

Examples of Permian beetles including fossilised wings and carapaces with (B and D) life reconstructions. Picture credit: NIGPAS.

Picture credit: NIGPAS

Mammoth Mathematical Models

A project to map the evolutionary history of arguably, the most successful and diverse animals of all time was a mammoth task. The researchers used a 68-gene character dataset that had been compiled previously which had sampled 129 out of the 193 recognised beetle families alive today and compared this to the beetle fossil record to provide a refined timescale of beetle evolution. A supercomputer at the University of Bristol’s Advanced Computing Research Centre slogged through the information for 18 months to produce the most comprehensive evolutionary tree of the Coleoptera ever created.

The mathematical models at the very heart of this research demonstrated that different beetle clades diversified independently, as various new ecological opportunities arose. There was no single, immense, all-encompassing divergence event.

One of the corresponding authors of the paper, published by Royal Society Open Science, Professor Chenyang Cai (University of Bristol) commented:

“There was not a single epoch of beetle radiation, their secret seems to lie in their remarkable flexibility. The refined timescale of beetle evolution will be an invaluable tool for investigating the evolutionary basis of the beetle’s success story”.

A beautifully preserved weevil fossil (Crato Formation).

Although beetle fossils are exceptionally rare, the research team used data from a total of 57 beetle fossils to help map the evolutionary development of the Coleoptera. The picture above shows the fossilised remains of a beetle from the Early Cretaceous of Brazil (Crato Formation). Picture credit: Museu Nacional.

Picture credit: Museu Nacional

Carboniferous Origins but the Evolution of Flowering Plants had Little Impact

The oldest beetle fossils date back to around 295 million years ago (Early Permian), molecular clock studies indicate an origin in the Late Carboniferous. The analysis revealed that all the modern beetle suborders had originated by the Late Palaeozoic with a Triassic-Jurassic origin of most of the extant families.

It had been thought that as flowering plants became the dominant terrestrial plants in a period referred to as the Cretaceous Terrestrial Revolution (KTR), so beetles diversified to take advantage of new ecological niches as the angiosperms evolved. However, this study concludes that the major beetle clades were present before the KTR. Nevertheless, some scarabaeoid and cucujiform clades underwent diversification during the Late Jurassic to Early Cretaceous, partly overlapping with the diversification of major angiosperms clades in the Early to mid-Cretaceous.

However, the previously postulated strong link between flowering plant evolution and the rapid expansion of the beetle suborder is refuted by this research.

Ancient weevil life reconstruction.

Newly published research concludes that the rise of the flowering plants did not result in a substantial expansion of the Coleoptera. Picture credit James McKay.

Picture credit: James McKay

Advances in Technology and Genetics

Professor Cai explained that this research into the Coleoptera would not have been possible without advances in computer technology and genetics. He stated:

“Reconstructing what happened in the last 300 million years is key to understanding what gave us the immense diversity beetles are known for today”.

Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the assistance of a media release from the University of Bristol in the compilation of this article.

The scientific paper “Integrated phylogenomics and fossil data illuminate the evolution of beetles” by Chenyang Cai, Erik Tihelka, Mattia Giacomelli, John F. Lawrence, Adam Ślipiński, Robin Kundrata, Shûhei Yamamoto, Margaret K. Thayer, Alfred F. Newton, Richard A. B. Leschen, Matthew L. Gimmel, Liang Lü, Michael S. Engel, Patrice Bouchard, Diying Huang, Davide Pisani and Philip C. J. Donoghue published in Royal Society Open Science.

The Everything Dinosaur website: Prehistoric Animal Models.

27 03, 2022

The Oldest Dinosauromorph from South America

By |2024-10-30T12:49:22+00:00March 27th, 2022|Categories: Adobe CS5, Dinosaur and Prehistoric Animal News Stories, Dinosaur Fans, Main Page, Palaeontological articles, Photos/Pictures of Fossils|0 Comments

The debate continues as to when the first dinosaurs evolved. Some of the oldest specimens described to date come from the famous Ischigualasto Formation located in north-western Argentina. These sediments are estimated to be around 232 million years old. It is thought that the first true dinosaurs evolved in the Southern Hemisphere and many palaeontologists favour a South American origin whilst others consider the evolutionary cradle of the Dinosauria was Africa: Dinosaurs Out of Africa?

To compound this debate, the fossil record of the ancestors of dinosaurs is particularly sparse. Some older Argentinian deposits have provided evidence of the precursors to the “true dinosaurs”, with some of these fossils estimated to be around 236 million years of age. However, scientists from the Universidade Federal de Santa Maria (Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil), have reported the discovery of a single fossilised thigh bone from Middle Triassic sediments in Brazil that predates all the Argentinian dinosauromorph fossils.

Dinosauromorph femur fossil from Brazil.

A skeletal drawing showing the placement of the right femur bone (shown in white) and a photograph of the actual fossil. Skeletal drawing by Maurício Silva Garcia, photography by Rodrigo Temp Müller. Note scale bar = 50 cm.

Picture credit: Maurício Silva Garcia/Rodrigo Temp Müller

The Dinodontosaurus Assemblage Zone

The fossilised thigh bone (right femur) measures 11 cm in length and it comes from Middle Triassic sediments (Pinheiros-Chiniquá Sequence) from the famous Dinodontosaurus Assemblage Zone, so named because as well as archosaur fossils, the sediments have yielded an abundance of fossil material associated with the dicynodont Dinodontosaurus. The femur has a morphology similar to the thigh bones of other dinosauromorphs, but it comes from much older stratum, estimated to be at least 237 million years old (Ladinian faunal stage of the Middle Triassic).

This newly described specimen establishes that the Dinosauromorpha (dinosaurs and their close ancestors), were present in South America earlier than previously recorded and extends the fossil record of South American dinosauromorphs into the Ladinian stage of the Triassic.

The thigh bone might be small and no genus has been erected based on this single fossil, but it does represent the oldest dinosauromorph fossil found in South America to date.

Fossils of South American dinosauromorphs compared.

A skeletal drawing of the Brazilian dinosauromorph (femur shown in white) with a comparison of fossil specimen stratigraphy from Argentina and Brazil which demonstrates the thigh bone represents the oldest evidence of Dinosauromorpha described to date in South America. Picture credit: Müller and Garcia.

Picture credit: Müller and Garcia

An Ecosystem Dominated by Other Reptiles

Based on comparisons with more complete fossil specimens the femur came from an animal around a metre in length, most of which was accounted for by its long, thin tail if this dinosauromorph possessed a similar body plan. It lived in a diverse ecosystem dominated by other types of reptile. For example, the giant pseudosuchian Prestosuchus was probably the apex predator and at nearly 7 metres in length, this giant member of the crocodile-line of the Archosauria would have dwarfed all the dinosauromorphs in the ecosystem.

A life reconstruction of the Brazilian dinosauromorph

A life reconstruction of the Brazilian dinosauromorph based on the 11 cm long femur. This ancestor of the Dinosauria would have been dwarfed by other archosaurs in the ancient environment (Prestosuchus). Picture credit: Caetano Soares.

Picture credit: Caetano Soares

For an update on the research into South American dinosauromorphs: A New Silesaurid from South America.

Dinosauromorph compared to Prestosuchus

A scale drawing showing the relative sizes of the Brazilian dinosauromorph from the Pinheiros-Chiniquá Sequence compared to Prestosuchus chiniquensis. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

The scientific paper: “Oldest dinosauromorph from South America and the early radiation of dinosaur precursors in Gondwana” by Rodrigo T. Müller and Maurício S. Garcia published in Gondwana Research.

Visit the Everything Dinosaur website: Prehistoric Animal Models.

26 03, 2022

First Titanosaur Nesting Site from the Late Cretaceous of Brazil

By |2024-10-30T12:24:45+00:00March 26th, 2022|Categories: Adobe CS5, Dinosaur and Prehistoric Animal News Stories, Dinosaur Fans, Main Page, Palaeontological articles, Photos/Pictures of Fossils|0 Comments

Scientists have identified the first confirmed dinosaur nesting site in Brazil. The fossilised eggs found suggest a colonial titanosaur nesting site and indicate individuals returning periodically to the same location to breed.  A paper has been published in the journal “Scientific Reports”.

The fossils consisting of preserved clutches and isolated egg fragments were excavated from sandy deposits in an abandoned limestone quarry (Lafarge Quarry) at Ponte Alta District, Uberaba Municipality in Minas Gerais State (south-eastern Brazil). The fossils were recovered from the Serra da Galga Formation (Upper Cretaceous) and although no fossilised embryos were found at the site, the shape of the eggs strongly suggest that they were laid by titanosaurs.

Images of titanosaur eggs from Brazil

Images of selected titanosaurian eggs and egg-clutches collected from the Late Cretaceous Serra da Galga Formation (Bauru Group) at Ponto Alta nesting site, Uberaba Municipality, Minas Gerais State, Brazil. CPPLIP 1798, (a) the best-preserved recovered egg-clutch, bottom view. CPPLIP 1801, (b) isolated egg, with accompanying tomographic slice, showing thickness of the shell and its sedimentary fill. Specimen number CPPLIP 1799, (c) egg-clutch with accompanying tomographic slice, showing thickness of the shell, shells collapsed and its sedimentary fill. The specimen number CPPLIP 1800, (d and e) two eggs found associated. Specimen number CPPLIP 1804 (f) isolated partial egg. Note scale bars 5 cm. Picture credit: Fiorelli et al.

Picture credit: Fiorelli et al

Nesting in Colonies and Evidence of Breeding-site Fidelity

The Titanosauria were a highly successful clade of long-necked, long-tailed herbivores that were globally distributed during the Cretaceous and survived up until the very end of the Mesozoic. Some of the biggest terrestrial animals known to science are members of this clade, dinosaurs such as Patagotitan, Argentinosaurus and Notocolossus. All three of these titanosaurs lived millions of years before the Lafarge Quarry eggs were laid and they lived much further south (higher palaeolatitude).

Patagotitan scale drawing.

A scale drawing of the giant titanosaur Patagotitan mayorum commissioned by Everything Dinosaur. This huge dinosaur was estimated to have measured around 35 metres when its fossil bones were initially examined. When Patagotitan was formally named and scientifically described its body size and weight was reduced slightly. However, a reconstructed, life-size skeleton was built measuring 37.2 metres in length. Titanosaurs are amongst the largest terrestrial animals known to science. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

Numerous titanosaur nesting sites are known (Spain, Romania, France, India and most notably Argentina), writing in the academic journal “Scientific Reports”, the researchers report the first titanosaur nesting site from the Late Cretaceous of Brazil (Maastrichtian faunal stage). The fossil material consisting of several egg-clutches, partially preserved, isolated eggs and many eggshell fragments were found in two distinct levels, approximately two metres apart.

This discovery adds further support to the theory that these large herbivores nested in colonies and had preferred locations for their nesting sites, what is often referred to as breeding-site fidelity.

To read a related blog post about breeding-site fidelity (philopatry) identified in South American titanosaurs: Two New South American Titanosaurs Described.

Brazilian titanosaur nesting site

The titanosaur egg fossils were found in two distinct layers (L1 and L2) approximately two metres apart. This suggests that this area was a preferred nesting site for titanosaurs. This is the first confirmed dinosaur nesting area found in Brazil. The eggs attributed to titanosaurs also represent the most northerly titanosaurian nesting site known from South America. The discovery of nests located at different levels indicates that titanosaurs returned regularly to preferred nesting areas. Picture credit: Fiorelli et al.

Picture credit: Fiorelli et al

Which Titanosaur Species?

Isolated and fragmentary remains of titanosaur eggs had previously been reported from Brazil, but the Lafarge Quarry specimens provide unambiguous proof of titanosaur nesting in Brazil. As no embryos have been found in association with the fossilised eggs, it is not possible to comment on the specific genus involved.

However, the researchers state that between the Santonian to the Maastrichtian faunal stages of the Late Cretaceous (86 to 66 million years ago) only derived titanosaurs such as saltasaurids and colossosaurians are recorded from South America. It is likely that the fossils associated with the nesting site represent an unknown genus.

Patagotitan skeleton on display.

Sue from Everything Dinosaur poses in front of the colossal Patagotitan skeleton which is being exhibited at the Natural History Museum (London). Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

During the Late Cretaceous the Ponte Alta District would have been located at around 26 degrees south of the Equator, putting it on a similar palaeolatitude of titanosaur nesting sites found in India. Previously, South American titanosaur nesting sites have been recorded between 33 to 47 degrees south of the Equator. This latitudinal difference could also influence the distribution of species on the Gondwana continent. The palaeoclimatic variation and geological characteristics could result in a difference in nesting time between titanosaurs living at different latitudes.

How Did Titanosaurs Build Nests?

The Lafarge Quarry site indicates colonial nesting which also suggests that these herbivorous dinosaurs moved around in herds. It is likely that Ponte Alta District titanosaurs scooped out pits in the soft sand using their back legs and then laid their eggs in clutches, before burying them and perhaps covering the nest with vegetation to help incubation.

To read an article about the naming of Austroposeidon magnificus the largest dinosaur from Brazil described to date: Brazil’s Biggest Dinosaur.

The scientific paper: “First titanosaur dinosaur nesting site from the Late Cretaceous of Brazil” by Lucas E. Fiorelli, Agustín G. Martinelli, João Ismael da Silva, E. Martín Hechenleitner, Marcus Vinícius Theodoro Soares, Julian C. G. Silva Junior, José Carlos da Silva, Élbia Messias Roteli Borges, Luiz Carlos Borges Ribeiro, André Marconato, Giorgio Basilici and Thiago da Silva Marinho published in Scientific Reports.

The award-winning Everything Dinosaur website: Dinosaur Models.

22 03, 2022

Earliest Jaws in Evolutionary Trade-Off According to New Research

By |2024-10-30T10:02:57+00:00March 22nd, 2022|Categories: Adobe CS5, Dinosaur and Prehistoric Animal News Stories, Main Page, Palaeontological articles, Photos/Pictures of Fossils|0 Comments

Most vertebrates have jaws, specialised anatomical features for capturing and processing food. A newly published study suggests that the earliest jaws to evolve were caught in a trade-off between maximising their strength and their bite speed.

Dunkleosteus on display. A placoderm parent?

A spectacular Dunkleosteus exhibit. Dunkleosteus was one of 48 Placodermi genera whose jaws were examined in this study. Mathematical models of potential jaw shapes were compared against the actual fossil record. Jaw evolution has been constrained to shapes that have the highest possible speed and strength. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

The Evolution of Jaws in Vertebrates

Jawed vertebrates dominate modern ecosystems emphasising the importance of jaw development in the evolutionary history of the vertebrates. Over 99% of all living vertebrates have jaws and the very first jaws evolved in prehistoric fish over 400 million years ago. These jaws evolved from gill arches, anatomical structures in fish that support their gills.

How jaws developed has been well documented, for example, Everything Dinosaur has blogged about their evolution: Ancient Shark Provides Insight into Jaw Development, however, researchers led by scientists from the University of Bristol have explored this important topic using a mathematical model to examine the early evolution and radiation of jaw types.

Megamastax amblyodus Illustration

Megamastax terrorises a group of jawless fish. The sarcopterygian Megamastax from the Late Silurian, a large, predatory fish with a powerful jaw attacking a group of jawless fish. The evolution of jaws probably led to the demise of the Agnatha (jawless fish) with only the Hagfish (Myxini) and the Lamprey (Hyperoartia) as the only living examples of this once extremely specious Infraphylum.  Picture credit: Dr Brian Choo.

Picture credit: Dr Brian Choo

The Development of a Novel Mathematical Model to Explore Jaw Development

Writing in the academic publication “Science Advances”, the researchers collected data on the shapes of fossil jaws and developed a mathematical model to assess their characteristics. The mathematical model produced permitted the scientists to extrapolate an extensive range of theoretical jaw shapes that could have been explored by the first evolving jaws. These theoretical jaws were tested for their strength – the amount of force they could endure without breaking, and their speed – how efficiently they could be opened and closed.

Jaw speed and jaw strength are two traits that conflict with each other. For example, really strong, powerful jaws like those associated with the giant placoderm Dunkleosteus would probably have been quite slow to open and close. Increasing bite force usually means a decrease in jaw speed.

By comparing the fossil record with the theoretical jaw shapes predicted by the mathematical model, the researchers deduced that jaw evolution has been constrained to shapes that have the highest possible speed in relation to their strength. Specifically, the jaws of early members of the Gnathostomata (jawed vertebrates) in the dataset were extremely optimal, and some groups evolved away from this optimum over time. These results suggest that the evolution of biting was very quick.

Studying the Earliest Jaws Using Mathematics

Bristol University PhD student William Deakin, the lead author of the paper explained:

“Jaws are an extremely important feature to gnathostomes – or jaw-mouths. They are not only extremely widespread, but almost all creatures that have them, use them in the same way – to grab food and process it. That’s more than can be said for an arm or a foot or a tail, which can be used for all sorts of things. This makes jaws extremely useful to anyone studying the evolution of function. Very different jaws from very different animals can be tested in similar ways. Here we have shown that studies on a large variety of jaws, using theoretical morphology and adaptive landscapes to capture their variety in function, can help shed some light on evolutionary questions.”

Scale drawing of a Coelacanth. What is a Coelacanth?

A scale drawing of a ceolacanth (Latimeria). he research team analysed the jaw shape of 121 extinct gnathostome taxa ranging in age from the Late Silurian to the end of the Devonian. The largest group of fossil fish studied were members of the Sarcopterygii (57 examples studied). The Sarcopterygii are the lobe-finned fishes an example of which is the extant Coelacanth (Latimeria). Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

Co-author of the study Professor Philip Donoghue (University of Bristol), added:

“The earliest jawed vertebrates have jaws in all shapes and sizes, long thought to reflect adaptation to different functions. Our study shows that most of this variation was equally optimal for strength and speed, making for fearsome predators.”

Emily Rayfield, who like Professor Donoghue is also a Professor of Palaeobiology at Bristol University and co-author of the paper, praised the new, insightful mathematical model developed by William Deakin commenting:

“The new software that Will developed to analyse the evolution of jawed vertebrates, is unique. It allows us to map the design space of key anatomical innovations, like jaws, and determine their functional properties. We plan to use it to uncover many more of the secrets of evolutionary history.”

Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the assistance of a media release from the University of Bristol in the compilation of this article.

The scientific paper: “Increasing morphological disparity and decreasing optimality for jaw speed and strength during the radiation of jawed vertebrates” by William J. Deakin, Philip S. L. Anderson, Wendy Den Boer, Thomas J. Smith, Jennifer J. Hill, Martin Rücklin, Philip C. J. Donoghue and Emily J. Rayfield published in Science Advances.

Visit the Everything Dinosaur website: Everything Dinosaur.

20 03, 2022

Is Torosaurus a Valid Genus? Canadian Fossils Suggest it is

By |2024-10-29T07:52:49+00:00March 20th, 2022|Categories: Dinosaur and Prehistoric Animal News Stories, Dinosaur Fans, Main Page, Palaeontological articles, Photos/Pictures of Fossils|2 Comments

Palaeontologists have debated the validity of the Torosaurus genus for decades. Some scientists see this large chasmosaurine known from the Upper Cretaceous (Maastrichtian faunal stage) as a distinct taxon, whilst others consider the genus to be invalid, the fossil material representing old and mature examples of Triceratops.

Analysis of horned dinosaur fossil material from Canada lends support to the idea that Torosaurus is distinct from Triceratops and that it is a valid taxon. A microscopic study of bone composition indicates that the individual animal represented was still growing at the time of its death. This evidence challenges the idea that fossils attributed to Torosaurus are just the remains of very old, fully grown and very mature Triceratops.

Dinosaur drawing commissioned by Everything Dinosaur.

An illustration of the Late Cretaceous chasmosaurine Torosaurus latus. Some palaeontologists have proposed that Torosaurus is simply a skeletally mature growth form of the contemporaneous Triceratops. New research studying partial ceratopsian frills and limb bones found in Canada suggests that Torosaurus is a valid taxon. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

Canadian Fossils Indicate that Torosaurus is a Valid Taxon

Writing in the Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society, researchers from the Canadian Museum of Nature, the Royal Saskatchewan Museum and Fibics Incorporated (Ontario), analysed two partial cranial frills attributed to Torosaurus. The first, EM P16.1 comes from Frenchman Formation exposures in Saskatchewan which represent uppermost Maastrichtian deposits. This fossil material was collected in 1947 along with two fragmentary thigh bones that were later damaged by floodwater when in storage, the limb bones provided the material for the osteohistological analysis to determine the age of dinosaur. The second specimen UALVP 1646, was found along the Red Deer River valley (Alberta) in 1964. It comes from higher parts of the Lower Scollard Formation. Both frill specimens are estimated to between 66 and 67 million years of age.

PNSO Torosaurus Aubrey and Dabei dinosaur models.

In horned dinosaurs, taxonomy is complicated by the fact that the cranial ornamentation that is often used to distinguish species changes radically with age. The long head shield of Torosaurus with its fenestrae was thought to represent the head crest of very old and mature Triceratops. New research using Canadian fossils refutes this theory and postulates that Torosaurus is a valid genus and the Canadian specimens mark the northernmost distribution of this ceratopsid.

The image (above) shows a replica of an adult Torosaurus with a juvenile.  These figures are from the PNSO range of prehistoric animal figures.

To view the PNSO model range: PNSO Models.

Identifying Torosaurus

Torosaurus has been distinguished from the contemporary Triceratops by the presence of two large holes (paired fenestrae) in the neck frill, which tends to be longer and wider, formed by the longer and tapering squamosal skull bones. In addition, Torosaurus is associated with an increased number of epiparietals (bony bumps and horns) on the margins of the neck shield.

Torosaurus Fossils (EM P16.1)

Parietosquomosal frill of Torosaurus latus (EM P16.1). Dorsal surface (A) which has been reconstructed using plaster and clay with interpretative drawing (B). Schematic transverse cross-section of squamosal near caudal edge based on a sketch by H. Jones. Schematic of frill showing paired fossae and channels on ventral surface of squamosals, based on sketch by H. Jones. Picture credit: Mallon et al.

Picture credit: Mallon et al

Osteohistological Sampling

A fragment of limb bone representing a portion of the left femur found in association with EM P16.1 was subjected to osteohistological analysis to determine the age of the dinosaur when it died. Small cross-sections of bone were cut and mounted onto epoxy resin. These were then carefully ground down to produce the extremely thin bone slices. Light microscopy and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) were then employed to reveal the bone structure at the cellular level.

Although the femur had been extensively repaired with plaster, enough of the bone structure remained for the research team to identify that this dinosaur was still growing when it died. They conclude that the fossil material comes from a late subadult or early adult individual and not an extremely old and mature animal. The scientists refute the hypothesis that Torosaurus represents very old examples of Triceratops.

Osteohistology of Torosaurus

T. latus limb bones found in association with EM P16.1. Photograph (A) shows the thin cross-section of prepared bone taken from a fragmentary femur, the red box area is shown in greater magnification (B). Haversian tissue (C), thin section of cortical bone of left femur, the red box is highly magnifed (D). The bone analysis indicates that this individual was stil growing at the time of death, leading the researchers to conclude that Torosaurus is a valid genus and not simply a very old specimen of a Triceratops. Picture credit: Mallon et al.

Picture credit: Mallon et al

Torosaurus and Triceratops Present in the Late Cretaceous of Canada

Based on this study, the researchers conclude that Torosaurus was present in Canada during the Late Cretaceous. Triceratops is also known from fossils found in Canada, both the currently recognised species Triceratops horridus and the geologically younger T. prorsus have been reported. If the frill fossils and limb bone fragments do represent Torosaurus then they mark the northernmost range of this taxon.

Torosaurus Fossils UALVP 1646

Parietal of Torosaurus latus (UALVP 1646). Dorsal surface (A); with (B) interpretive reconstruction of dorsal surface. The ventral surface is shown (C) and (D) interpretive reconstruction ventral surface. Photograph (E), detail of left parietal fenestra. Arrows in B and D indicate epiparietal loci. Picture credit: Mallon et al.

Picture credit: Mallon et al

Different Species of Torosaurus?

Intriguingly, much of the fossil material that was used in the original description of Torosaurus (Marsh 1891) was not precisely recorded. As a result, the stratigraphic distribution of the early collected Torosaurus fossils is unknown. Most of the recently collected Torosaurus latus fossils from the Hell Creek Formation comes from the lower half of the formation.

The majority of the Hell Creek Formation Torosaurus material was deposited earlier than the Torosaurus fossils from the geologically younger upper portion of the Scollard Formation and the Frenchman Formation of Canada which are approximately the same age as the uppermost parts of the Hell Creek Formation.

One Torosaurus specimen (MPM VP6841) is an exception it having been discovered in sediments associated with the upper part of the Hell Creek Formation. Specimen number MPM VP6841 compares closely to the Canadian specimen EM P16.1 and it has been proposed that these fossils may represent another Torosaurus species. The Hell Creek Formation was deposited over a period of at least 700,000 years (possibly as much as a million years).

Palaeontologists are aware that the Triceratops material associated with different stratigraphy represent different Triceratops species – T. horridus and the geologically younger T. prorsus plus another, as yet unnamed transitional form between the two.

Torosaurus Stratigraphy

The distribution of Torosaurus latus fossil material suggests that as with Triceratops the Hell Creek strata may contain more than one species. Picture credit: Mallon et al with additional annotation by Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Mallon et al with additional annotation by Everything Dinosaur

The researchers conclude that different species of Torosaurus would turn over in a similar manner as Triceratops within these uppermost Maastrichtian strata. There may be more species of Torosaurus identified in the future.

The scientific paper: “The record of Torosaurus (Ornithischia: Ceratopsidae) in Canada and its taxonomic implications” by Jordan C. Mallon, Robert B. Holmes, Emily L. Bamforth and Dirk Schumann published in the Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society.

The award-winning Everything Dinosaur website: Prehistoric Animal Models.

16 03, 2022

The Earliest Armoured Dinosaur found in Asia to Date

By |2024-10-28T13:52:04+00:00March 16th, 2022|Categories: Adobe CS5, Dinosaur and Prehistoric Animal News Stories, Dinosaur Fans, Main Page, Palaeontological articles, Photos/Pictures of Fossils|0 Comments

Scientists including Professor Paul Barrett of the London Natural History Museum have described a new species of basal armoured dinosaur from fossils found in China. The dinosaur named Yuxisaurus kopchicki, represents the first valid and undisputed member of the Thyreophora (armoured dinosaurs) to be described from fossils found in Lower Jurassic Asian strata.

Yuxisaurus life reconstruction

A life reconstruction of the newly described, Early Jurassic Chinese armoured dinosaur Yuxisaurus kopchicki. Picture credit: Yu Chen.

Picture credit: Yu Chen

The Rapid Geographic Spread of Early Armoured Dinosaurs

With an estimated body length of around three metres, Yuxisaurus might be small compared to some of the later and much more famous members of the Thyreophora clade such as Ankylosaurus and Stegosaurus, but confirmation of the presence of early armoured dinosaurs in China underlines the rapid geographic dispersal of these ornithischians. The first armoured dinosaurs are thought to have evolved around 200 million years ago (Hettangian faunal stage of the Early Jurassic). Yuxisaurus fossils consisting of vertebrae, skull bones, elements from the limbs, shoulder blades (scapulae) and 120 osteoderms (bony armour), were excavated from the upper portion of Fengjiahe Formation exposures, near Jiaojiadian village, Yimen County, Yuxi Prefecture, Yunnan Province (southwestern China).

Although the dating of the strata has proved problematical, it is likely that the fossils are somewhere between 192 and 182 million years old (late Sinemurian to early Toarcian stage of the Early Jurassic).

Variety Amongst Early Members of the Thyreophora

Although relatively small compared to later armoured dinosaurs, the limb bones suggest a robust, stout animal indicating that Yuxisaurus had a different body shape compared to other known early thyreophorans such as Scutellosaurus and Emausaurus. This suggests that early armoured dinosaurs had a diverse morphology and ecology and they spread rapidly establishing a wide geographical distribution and filling a variety of niches in Early Jurassic ecosystems.

Yuxisaurus skeletal drawing.

Skeletal reconstruction of Y. kopchicki showing main preserved elements from the holotype (highlighted in blue). Details of the skull bones (A), cervical vertebrae (B) and dorsal vertebrae (C). The left scapula is shown (D) and the right humerus (E) along with the distal portion of the left femur (F). Note scale bars equal 5 cm for A-C and 10 cm for D-F. Osteoderms have been omitted to show the skeleton. Picture credit: Xi Yao.

Picture credit: Xi Yao

The First Unambiguous Armoured Dinosaur from the Early Jurassic of Asia

First author of the scientific paper, Professor Paul Barrett (Natural History Museum, London), commented:

“Although we’ve had tantalising fragments of early armoured dinosaurs from Asia, this is the first time we’ve had enough material to recognise a new species from the region and investigate its evolutionary history. I hope it’s the first of many new dinosaurs from the localities being discovered by my colleagues in Yunnan.”

Senior author of the paper, Dr Shundong Bi, a professor at Indiana University of Pennsylvania, explained that the dinosaur had been named Yuxisaurus kopchicki in honour of the Yuxi Prefecture, whilst the trivial or species name was in recognition of the work of molecular biologist Dr John J. Kopchick and for his support and funding of a new Indiana University of Pennsylvania science complex which is due to open in autumn 2023.

Dr Shundong Bi stated, that despite its robust body:

“Yuxisaurus was possibly a facultative quadrupedal. It was primarily adapted for walking on four legs, but also able to walk on two legs.”

Where Did Armoured Dinosaurs Originate?

Until recently all the unambiguous Early Jurassic Thyreophora taxa were described from fossils found in North America (Scutellosaurus) or Europe (Emausaurus and Scelidosaurus). This led palaeontologists to conclude that armoured dinosaurs originated in Laurasia, however, new phylogenetic analyses (Butler et al 2020, Boyd 2015, Raven and Maidment 2017, Maidment et al 2020 and Baron et al 2017a) have proposed that Lesothosaurus from southern Africa and Laquintasaura from Venezuela might also represent early members of the Thyreophora. If Lesothosaurus and Laquintasaura are early armoured dinosaurs, then this suggests that this clade could have originated in Gondwana.

Yuxisaurus phylogeny

Phylogenetic assessments plotting the relationship of Yuxisaurus within the Thyreophora. Analysis (A) modified from Norman (2021) dataset which places Yuxisaurus as a sister taxon to Emausaurus which is known from the Early Jurassic (Toarcian) of Germany. Analysis (B) modified from Maidment et al (2020) places Yuxisaurus within the Thyreophora as an early-diverging branch between Emausaurus and Scelidosaurus which is known from the older sedimentary deposits from Charmouth on the Dorset coast. Picture credit: Yao et al.

Picture credit: Xi Yao et al

The phylogeny of early ornithischians remains disputed, it is hoped that further fossil finds will resolve this debate.

Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the assistance of a media release from the London Natural History Museum in the compilation of this article.

To read an article about the discovery of Laquintasaura: Laquintasaura What Does it All Mean?

The scientific paper: “A new early-branching armoured dinosaur from the Lower Jurassic of southwestern China” by Xi Yao, Paul M. Barrett, Lei Yang, Xing Xu and Shundong Bi preprint via bioRxiv before publication in eLife.

Visit the award-winning Everything Dinosaur website: Dinosaur Toys and Gifts.

13 03, 2022

Is Bashanosaurus the Oldest Stegosaur? A New Dinosaur Taxon

By |2024-10-27T22:05:57+00:00March 13th, 2022|Categories: Adobe CS5, Dinosaur and Prehistoric Animal News Stories, Dinosaur Fans, Main Page, Palaeontological articles, Photos/Pictures of Fossils|0 Comments

The trouble with being regarded as the biggest, longest, tallest or oldest when you are newly described species of dinosaur, is that sooner or later another fossil discovery will take this claim away from you. Back in 2019, team members wrote a blog post about the discovery of Adratiklit boulahfa from the Middle Jurassic of Morocco North Africa’s First Stegosaur. The fossils of this armoured dinosaur were estimated to be around 168 million years old (Bathonian faunal stage), making Adratiklit the oldest definitive stegosaur described.

Scientists including Dr Susannah Maidment a senior researcher at the London Natural History Museum, who co-authored the paper describing A. boulahfa, have announced the discovery of an even older stegosaur, this time from China. The new stegosaur named Bashanosaurus primitivus is at least one million years older than the Moroccan stegosaur.

The Fossils of Bashanosaurus

The fossils of Bashanosaurus herald from the Lower Member of the Shaximiao Formation and radiometric dating based on isotope decay analysis using zircon crystals (geochronological data), suggest that the deposits associated with the fossil bones are around 169 ± 0.68 million years of age.

Bashanosaurus life reconstruction.

A life reconstruction of the newly described Chinese stegosaur Bashanosaurus primitivus. Picture credit: Banana Art Studio.

Picture credit: Banana Art Studio

Did the Stegosauria Evolve in Asia?

The fossil record of early stegosaurs is highly fragmentary and the evolution of this iconic branch of the Thyreophora is poorly understood. The Stegosauria represents a major clade within the Ornithischia (bird-hipped dinosaurs). Fourteen genera of stegosaur have been described to date and they are both geographically and temporally widespread, known from all the major landmasses except for Australia and Antarctica.

In 2016, a new dinosaur quarry was opened in Yunyang County, Chongqinq Municipality in southwestern China. Stegosaur fossil material was identified on the western side of the quarry. The disarticulated material preserved within the sandstone consisted of a dorsal vertebra, two tail bones (caudal vertebrae), a right scapula, a right coracoid and elements from the hind legs. Three pieces of dermal armour were also discovered at this location (one plate and two spines) along with fragments of rib bones. These fossils (CLGPR V00006-1) are regarded as the holotype of B. primitivus.

Potentially Three Bashanosaurus Specimens

More stegosaur fossils were found at the site approximately fifty metres away from the holotype material (CLGPR V00006-2). They consist of five dorsal vertebrae, a right tibia, a right fibula some ribs and a single piece of dermal armour (one plate). In addition, a single dorsal vertebra (CLGPR V00006-3) was found on the eastern part of the site some one hundred and twenty metres away from the holotype material.

Whilst the researchers have confidently assigned these fossils to the Stegosauria and specifically to Bashanosaurus primitivus, three individual stegosaurs are represented by the bones.

Bashanosaurus fossils.

Photograph (A) with interpretative line drawing showing the position of the B. primitivus holotype fossil material (CLGPR V00006-1) on the western side of the wall of dinosaur fossils. Photograph (B) with interpretative line drawing showing the second location with B. primitivus fossil material ((CLGPR V00006-2) towards the middle of the wall of dinosaur fossils. Picture credit: Hui et al.

Picture credit: Hui et al

It is not known whether the fossil bones represent a juvenile or a fully-grown animal. However, based on these bones, the researchers estimate that the largest stegosaur from the quarry was about 2.8 metres in length.

Unique Anatomical Traits

The scientists who include researchers from the Chongqing Bureau of Geological and Mineral Resource Exploration and Development in China and London’s Natural History Museum identified several unique anatomical traits that led to the erection of a new genus. Bashanosaurus possesses anatomical characteristics associated with basal thyreophorans as well as more derived features associated with early stegosaurs. For example, it has a smaller and less developed shoulder blade, the bony projection of the thighbone (fourth trochanter) is positioned below the middle of the shaft and the bases of the armour plates curve outwards and are thicker than the plates on the backs of later stegosaurs.

The genus name is derived from “Bashan” in reference to the ancient name for the area of Chongqing in China where the dinosaur was found. The species moniker is derived from the Latin for “first” – primitivus.

Lead author of the research team, Dr Dai Hui from the Chongqing Bureau of Geological and Mineral Resource Exploration and Development commented:

“All these features are clues to the stegosaurs’ place on the dinosaur family tree. Bashanosaurus can be distinguished from other Middle Jurassic stegosaurs, and clearly represents a new species.”

Phylogenetic Analysis

Phylogenetic analysis shows that Bashanosaurus primitivus is the earliest-diverging stegosaur, along with Chungkingosaurus (C. jiangbeiensis), which is thought to be closely related, although Chungkingosaurus lived much later than Bashanosaurus. Chungkingosaurus fossils are known from the Upper Member of the Shaximiao Formation.

The discovery of Bashanosaurus will help researchers to learn more about the evolution of stegosaurs and supports the theory that this type of armoured dinosaur first appeared in Asia. Although there have been some exciting fossil discoveries helping to improve understanding with regards to the evolution of armoured dinosaurs (Thyreophora), there are still numerous gaps in the fossil record which makes mapping the evolutionary development of these iconic dinosaurs extremely difficult.

For example, Everything Dinosaur recently wrote an article about the discovery of the basal thyreophoran Yuxisaurus kopchicki, whose fossils also come from China. Scientists from the London Natural History Museum also contributed to the scientific paper on Yuxisaurus: The Earliest Armoured Dinosaur Found to Date.

Everything Dinosaur has inserted Yuxisaurus kopchicki within the phylogenetic assessment of Bashanosaurus to help put these recent fossil discoveries into context (see below).

Bashanosaurus phylogeny and comparison with the recently described Yuxisaurus.

A phylogenetic analysis showing the placement of B. primitivus within the Stegosauria. It is believed to be around one million years older than the recently described Adratiklit boulahfa (Maidment et al) from the Middle Jurassic of Morocco. The earliest armoured dinosaur from Asia known to date (Yuxisaurus kopchicki) from Yunnan Province, China (Yao et al) has been incorporated into the image by Everything Dinosaur to show the approximate phylogenetic and temporal placement of Y. kopchicki when compared to B. primitivus. Picture credit: Hui et al with additional annotation by Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Hui et al with additional annotation by Everything Dinosaur

The Stegosauria Clade Originated in Asia?

Commenting on the phylogenetic assessment Dr Hui stated:

“What’s more, our analysis of the family tree indicates that it [B. primitivus] is one of the earliest-diverging stegosaurs along with the Chongqing Lizard (Chungkingosaurus) and Huayangosaurus. These were all unearthed from the Middle to Late Jurassic Shaximiao Formation in China, suggesting that stegosaurs might have originated in Asia”

Chungkinogsaurus illustrated.

An illustration of the Chinese Stegosaur Chungkingosaurus. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

The picture (above) shows a drawing of a model from the PNSO model range.

To view this range of prehistoric animal figures: PNSO Age of Dinosaurs Figures.

Co-author of the scientific paper published in the Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, Dr Susannah Maidment of the London Natural History Museum and an expert in ornithischian dinosaurs added:

“The discovery of this stegosaur from the Middle Jurassic of China adds to an increasing body of evidence that the group evolved in the early Middle Jurassic, or perhaps even in the Early Jurassic, and as such represent some of the earliest known bird-hipped dinosaurs. China seems to have been a hotspot for stegosaur diversity, with numerous species now known from the Middle Jurassic right the way through until the end of the Early Cretaceous period.”

Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the assistance of a media release from the Taylor & Francis Group in the compilation of this article.

The scientific paper: “New Stegosaurs from the Middle Jurassic Lower Member of the Shaximiao Formation of Chongqing, China” by Dai Hui, Li Ning, Susannah C. R. Maidment, Wei Guangbiao, Zhou Yuxuan, Hu Xufeng, Ma Qingyu, Wang Xunqian, Hu Haiqian and Peng Guangzhao published in the Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology.

Visit the Everything Dinosaur website: Everything Dinosaur.

4 03, 2022

Sauropods Walked Like Hippos According to New Study

By |2024-10-27T11:02:43+00:00March 4th, 2022|Categories: Adobe CS5, Dinosaur and Prehistoric Animal News Stories, Dinosaur Fans, Main Page, Palaeontological articles, Photos/Pictures of Fossils|0 Comments

Researchers from Liverpool John Moores University have developed a new and innovative approach to interpreting sauropod trackways enabling them to calculate their gaits (the order in which the animal moved its four limbs to progress). Jens Lallensack and his colleague Peter Falkingham discovered that the placement of tracks relative to each other in a sauropod trackway changes in a consistent way when the animal changes its velocity (either speeding up or slowing down). Using this technique, subsequently verified by analysing the gaits of living animals such as dogs, horses, a camel and an elephant, the scientists have concluded that sauropods walked more like hippos than elephants.

Sauropod Tracks (Brontopodus plagnensis).

A picture of the sauropod trackway (Plagne, France). Picture credit: P. Dumas/Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique.

Picture credit: P. Dumas/Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique.

Quadruped Locomotion

Four-footed animals (quadrupeds), may use different gaits such as trots, walks, and pace gaits. In a trot, one diagonal limb pair (e.g. hind right and front left) moves together, followed by the other limb pair. Many mammals use trots at faster gaits, but reptiles also use trots at slow speeds. In a pace gait, in contrast, the limbs on one side of the body (e.g. hind right and fore right) move together in a similar way as the locomotion of a camel.

In-between these extremes is the single foot gait, in which the time lag between fore and hind feet is equal – a good example of this type of locomotion is the movement of horses.

The movements of living animals can be observed, direct observation of extinct animals such as huge, long-necked, long-tailed sauropod dinosaurs is not possible, but data can be obtained by careful study of their fossilised prints and trackways.

Dinosaur tracks

Trace fossils such as these dinosaur tracks can provide palaeontologists with data on dinosaur locomotion, velocity and gaits. Picture credit: Liverpool John Moores University.

Picture credit: Liverpool John Moores University

Examining Sauropod Tracksites

Liverpool John Moores University researchers Jens Lallensack and Peter Falkingham identified that the placement of an animal’s feet changes in a predictable and consistent way when the animal’s velocity changes. If a trackway is long enough and shows variation in stride length (indicating a change of speed), it is possible to calculate gaits and to gain an insight into how extinct animals moved.

Their predictions were confirmed in an analysis of the gaits of different types of living animal, including elephants, thanks to the help from locomotion expert Professor John Hutchinson (Royal Veterinary College, London), who provided elephant locomotion data. These new analytical methods were used to plot the limb movements along three sauropod trackways from the Lower Cretaceous De Queen Formation (Arkansas, USA). Although it is not possible to identify specific sauropod species (ichnospecies) from the De Queen Formation (Albian fauna stage) tracks, these trace fossils represent large, sauropod trackmakers (median average hind foot length 70-85 cm and maximum stride length 3.42 metres).

Commenting on the outcome of their findings, reported in the journal “Current Biology”, Dr Falkingham stated:

“Many researchers assumed that sauropods walked like elephants, with which they share many similarities, but that doesn’t appear to be the case.”

Dinosaur Trackway

Researchers have found a way to identify the gait of sauropods by studying their tracks. Picture credit: Liverpool John Moores University.

Picture credit: Liverpool John Moores University

Sauropod Dinosaurs Compared to Elephants

As elephants are the largest living terrestrial animals alive today, it had been suggested that their locomotion was an appropriate analogy for the movement of sauropod dinosaurs. Elephants use a gait intermediate between the pace gait and the singlefoot, i.e. the two limbs on the same body side tend to swing together. The gait analysis, in the current study by contrast, revealed that sauropods instead employed a gait intermediate between the singlefoot and a trot: the opposite-side limbs tend to swing together.

Based on this data, sauropod dinosaurs had a similar gait to hippos.

To Sway or Not to Sway

If sauropods moved very differently compared to the largest land animals alive today, this suggests that these two types of animal with large body sizes evolved different solutions to locomotion. Sauropods, even the titanosaurs known for their narrower trackways when compared to other types of sauropod such as diplodocids and dicraeosaurids, have a much broader stance than elephants. Elephants place one foot almost directly in front of another producing surprisingly narrow tracks for such large animals. Sauropod trackways, in contrast, are much broader. Their particular gait allowed sauropods to have at least one foot on the ground on both the left and right sides of the body at all times, preventing swaying from side to side.

Patagotitan skeleton on display at the London Natural History Museum.

The enormous body of the titanosaur dwarfs visitors. Patagotitan mayorum skeletal reconstruction. Titanosaurs are known for their narrower tracks when compared to other types of sauropod but as many were much bigger than elephants, elephants do not make a good analogy for describing the gaits of titanosaurs or of sauropods generally. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the assistance of a media release from Liverpool John Moores University in the compilation of this article.

Lead author of the scientific paper Dr Jens Lallensack added:

“Sauropods chose a gait that maximised stability but still allowed for efficient walking”.

The scientific paper: “A new method to calculate limb phase from trackways reveals gaits of sauropod dinosaurs” by Jens N. Lallensack, Peter L. Falkingham published in Current Biology.

The Everything Dinosaur website: Dinosaur Toys.

1 03, 2022

Are There Three Tyrannosaurus Species? New Research Asks the Question

By |2024-10-27T10:42:02+00:00March 1st, 2022|Categories: Adobe CS5, Dinosaur and Prehistoric Animal News Stories, Dinosaur Fans, Main Page, Palaeontological articles, Photos/Pictures of Fossils|0 Comments

So, the scientific paper is out and theropod feathers are about to be ruffled. The iconic Tyrannosaurus rex might not be just one species, but actually three. That is the conclusion reached by researchers Gregory S. Paul, Scott Persons and Jay Van Raalte – all highly respected scientists, but already other academics have challenged their findings.

Writing in the academic journal “Evolutionary Biology”, two new Tyrannosaurus species are proposed, a geologically older, robust form newly named Tyrannosaurus imperator that was followed by two further species the already named Tyrannosaurus rex, also a robust tyrannosaur and a contemporaneous gracile form which has been named Tyrannosaurus regina.

Titus the T.rex exhibit. A T. rex skeleton on display.

The spectacular Titus the T. rex exhibit at Wollaton Hall. PIcture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

The Tyrannosaurus Controversy

The fearsome, apex predator Tyrannosaurus rex might be synonymous with the famous Hell Creek Formation, but Tyrannosaurus fossils have also been found in many other Upper Cretaceous deposits (Maastrichtian stage). For example, T. rex fossils or at least indeterminate Tyrannosaurus material is associated with nine other North American geological formations.

T. rex fossils have been found in exposures of the Scollard Formation of south-western Alberta the Frenchman Formation of southern Saskatchewan and south-eastern Alberta. This suggests that this large theropod roamed northern areas of Laramidia. Tyrannosaurus fossils from the Laramie Formation exposures in Colorado have been assigned to Tyrannosaurus rex. T. rex fossil material has been reported from much further south, from the Javelina Formation of Texas.

With only one species of Tyrannosaurus (T. rex), the fossil evidence as classified so far indicates that the “tyrant lizard king” had a huge geographical distribution, virtually the entire ancient landmass of Laramidia.

Furthermore, these deposits represent vast amounts of geological time. The Hell Creek Formation is believed to have been formed over two million years and as scientists have now concluded that other iconic taxa such as Triceratops evolved over this time period into new species, then surely T. rex would have been subject to the same evolutionary pressures.

"Scotty" the Tyrannosaurus rex.

A reconstruction of the skeleton of “Scotty” the T. rex. The fossils come from the Frenchman Formation of Saskatchewan (Canada) and one of the authors of the scientific paper published in the journal the Anatomical Record was Scott Persons who is a co-author of the new paper describing three Tyrannosaurus taxa. Picture credit: Amanda Kelley.

Picture credit: Amanda Kelley.

Analysis of Limb Bones (Femora)

A total of thirty-seven fossil specimens were studied by the researchers. Two-thirds of these had femora (thigh bones) associated with them and the scientists found differences in the thickness and robustness of these bones, that were unlikely a result of individual variation within a single species. In the sample studied, Gregory S. Paul and his colleagues found greater variation in femur robustness in the T. rex thigh bone material than in the whole of the other tyrannosaurid femora material known from the preceding ten million years.

The team discounted size variations based on maturity, ontogeny (growth pattern) and the age of the Tyrannosaurus when it died. Robust forms and more gracile forms of T. rex have been known for some years. Some palaeontologists have speculated that the smaller, more slender bones of some T. rex specimens compared to the more robust femora of other specimens might be explained as differences in the sexes.

If robust forms represent females, and gracile forms males, then it would be expected that the fossil record would show roughly even numbers of these bone types. However, the research team point out an uneven ratio of robust bones to gracile bones and as such they discount the differences as sexual variation.

In addition, the team report that gracile bones are only found in higher layers of sediment. These bones are geologically much younger than other more robust T. rex bones associated with lower layers.

Tyrannosaurus rex cast skeleton on display

Which Tyrannosaurus species? A cast of the T. rex specimen known as “Stan” (BHI 3033), but researchers propose that there were actually three species of Tyrannosaurus present in the Late Cretaceous of North America. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

Differences in Tooth Count

The scientists also commented on differences in tooth counts associated with Tyrannosaurus lower jaws (the dentary). Tyrannosaurus imperator (the earliest Tyrannosaurus species) had two small incisors in each dentary. Whilst the later species (T. regina and T. rex) had only one small incisor in each dentary.

Titus the T. rex Skull and Jaws. Dinosaur extinction.

The research team identified differences in the number of small incisor-like teeth in the lower jaw which they concluded was further evidence of the T. rex fossil material actually representing a trio of Tyrannosaurus species. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

The researchers concede that they cannot rule out other explanations for their findings. Several palaeontologists have challenged the paper, stating that the variations seen in the fossils could be explained by factors such as individual variation amongst individuals of a single species. Like many dinosaurs, Tyrannosaurus rex changed radically as it grew and matured, this aspect of dinosaur taxonomy is going to be debated for a considerable time to come.

For fans of dinosaur models, does this mean that collectors will have to reassess their Tyrannosaurus rex models?

Three Tyrannosaurus species proposed.

Which Tyrannosaurus species are you? A newly published scientific paper proposes three Tyrannosaurus species. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

The scientific paper: “The Tyrant Lizard King, Queen and Emperor: Multiple Lines of Morphological and Stratigraphic Evidence Support Subtle Evolution and Probable Speciation Within the North American Genus Tyrannosaurus” by Gregory S. Paul, W. Scott Persons IV and Jay Van Raalte published in Evolutionary Biology.

Visit the award-winning Everything Dinosaur website: Everything Dinosaur.

27 02, 2022

A New Book is Published – A Time Traveller’s Guide to Fossil Hunting on the West Dorset Coast

By |2024-10-26T16:20:30+01:00February 27th, 2022|Categories: Adobe CS5, Book Reviews, Dinosaur Fans, Geology, Photos/Pictures of Fossils|0 Comments

When visiting Lyme Regis and other parts of the Jurassic Coast we are often aghast at the huge numbers of fossil hunters to be seen on the beach. We tend to avoid the late summer months as this beautiful part of the Dorset coast will have been virtually picked clean of all the fossil material. The tide might continue to wash out the remains of creatures from an Early Jurassic sea, but the enthusiastic holidaymakers and tourists soon make short work of whatever has been deposited on the beach.

Sitting on some large rock, comfortably away from the dangerous cliffs, with a flask of tea and a local pastie to sustain us, we are often approached by beachcombers curious to ask our advice or to receive assistance in identifying their finds. Diligently and politely, we offer what assistance we can, but amongst the hubbub we often think what it would have been like to have explored the foreshore in earlier times, before this stunning coastline became a haven for tourists.

Thanks to a new, delightful book by Steve Snowball and Craig Chivers, we have the opportunity to do so.

Front cover of "Jurassic Fossils of the West Dorset Coast"

A time traveller’s guide to fossil hunting on the west Dorset coast. A fantastic collector’s guide written in the form of an Edwardian diary with wonderful illustrations and photographs. Written by renowned fossil hunters and preparators Steve Snowball and Craig Chivers and available from Siri Scientific Press. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

“Jurassic Fossils of the West Dorset Coast – A Time Traveller’s Journal”

The fourth collaboration between devoted fossil hunters Steve Snowball and Craig Chivers takes the form of an Edwardian diary. Imagine finding on the beach at Charmouth an old journal that catalogues the visit of two Edwardian gentlemen to the west Dorset coast at the beginning of the 20th Century. Starting at Seatown and Golden Cap, the two explorers record the geology, the fossil discoveries and the Dorset landscape over a period of eight days, culminating with a trip to Pinhay Bay where the strata records the boundary between the Triassic and the Jurassic.

"Jurassic Fossils of the West Dorset Coast" contents

Photographs of fossil finds plus lots of helpful notes – a time traveller’s guide to the west Dorset coast. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

The Everything Dinosaur website: Everything Dinosaur.

Illustrations by Andreas Kurpisz

Produced by Siri Scientific Press and with illustrations by Berlin-based artist Andreas Kurpisz, this is a novel and quirky guide to fossil hunting on the west Dorset coast. There is a copious amount of helpful information provided on each location, with notes and lots of photographs of fossils associated with the site. Talented artist Andreas Kurpisz provides colourful illustrations depicting prehistoric scenes – there are even one or two dinosaurs featured.

At around 160 pages long, this is a most informative guide, we particularly enjoyed examining the biostratigraphical maps provided and the accompanying images of strata – all helpfully labelled. Priced as we write at £19.99 plus postage and available from the Siri Scientific Press website this is a welcome and imaginative addition to the plethora of fossil hunting guidebooks that address the amazing geology of the Dorset coast.

"Jurassic Fossils of the West Dorset Coast"

Written in the form of an Edwardian gentleman’s journal, the book is packed with helpful information, fossil hunting tips and wonderful photographs of fossil discoveries. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

Bringing the Past to Life

“Jurassic Fossils of the West Dorset Coast – A Time Traveller’s Journal” helps to bring the past to life and provides an echo of a time when the beaches around Lyme Regis were less busy and undoubtedly more productive. However, armed with this guide your chances of finding an incredibly special fossil are greatly enhanced.

The book concludes with our courageous Edwardian explorers coming across evidence of another visitor to the “Jurassic Coast”, this time from the 21st century. The gentlemen have been left notes on how to prepare ammonites for display from a kind-hearted collector from our own time. This device permits the authors to segue into a section of the book that provides helpful tips and advice on modern tools such as air scribes that will assist collectors with fossil preparation.

Visit Siri Scientific Press and use the search word “Jurassic” to find the books about Dorset written by Steve Snowball and Craig Chivers including the excellent “Jurassic Fossils of the West Dorset Coast – A Time Traveller’s Journal”: Siri Scientific Website.

Go to Top