Camarasaurids – Oxygen Isotopes Preserved in Fossilised Teeth Indicate Migration

The greatest mammal  land migration seen today might be the 1.5 million wildebeest (Connochaetus taruinus) or thereabouts, that seasonally migrate from the Masai Mara in Kenya to the Serengeti of Tanzania in search of fresh grazing.  However, additional evidence to support the long-held theory that dinosaurs also migrated has been found following an extensive study of sauropod teeth.

The sauropods, were plant-eating dinosaurs (saurischians), with small heads, long necks and long tails.  Their massive bodies were supported on immense trunk-like legs.  It had been postulated that these animals, some species of which were the largest terrestrial land animals known to science, did migrate in such of food.  These enormous creatures would soon deplete an area of vegetation and so they would have to move on in search of more food.

Sauropod Teeth

Now data from a study of camarasaurid teeth (a type of sauropod), suggests that some species may have migrated hundreds of miles in seasonal migrations.

Given their enormous appetites and water needs, their ability to survive in lowland flood plains affected by seasonal dry spells and drought has puzzled scientists, the only explanation offered was that these animals must have migrated to find more suitable feeding areas, when the lowland plains were subjected to the seasonal dry spell.

Now researchers have learned at least one sauropod species made regular journeys between lowland to highland habitats covering several hundred miles.

The evidence is in the teeth of Camarasaurus, a large sauropod which grew to a length of 20 metres and is a relative of the better-known brachiosaurids.

Fossilised Camarasaurus teeth, found in the U.S. states of Wyoming and Utah, contained a chemical record of the animals’ movements during the Late Jurassic period around 150 million years ago.

As different atomic versions of oxygen, or isotopes, occur in the surface water of lowland and highland regions, any isotopes found in the fossilised teeth of these dinosaurs would provide an indication of where these animals travelled to.

These differences remained imprinted in the oxygen from drinking water deposited in the Camarasaurus teeth.

An Illustration of a Typical Camarasaurid Dinosaur

The teeth tell a tale of dinosaur migrations.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

The model in the image above comes from the Safari Ltd range of prehistoric animal figures.

To view this range including Camarasaurus models (whilst stocks last): Camarasaurus Models and Sauropod Figures (Wild Dinos).

Comparing the oxygen isotopes to those in ancient soil, lake and wetland samples revealed a picture of the dinosaurs’ migration patterns.

The researchers, led by Dr Henry Fricke, from Colorado College, (United States) commented about the migrating dinosaurs in the scientific  journal Nature:

“Camarasaurus populations… must have directly occupied high-elevated regions for at least part of the year before returning to the basin where they died.”

Camarasaurus fossils are some of the more common (relatively) sauropod fossils found in the Upper Jurassic rocks of the famous Morrison Formation of the western United States.   An analysis of the isotopes of oxygen preserved within the fossilised remains of the teeth of these herbivores provides scientists with an understanding of their seasonal movements.

The team studied the ratio of oxygen isotopes in Camarasaurus teeth.  The oxygen comes from surrounding soil, lakes and wetlands and the isotope ratios are specific to a particular area.  The isotopes are laid down in the enamel as the tooth grows. The oldest enamel is at the tip and youngest at the base. So, the isotopes recorded in the enamel become a sort of time-line.  By comparing oxygen isotope ratios in the tooth enamel with those preserved in the animal’s surroundings, scientists can tell where the animal was living at particular times.

The team found, at seasonal points, the isotope ratios in the Camarasaurus teeth differed from those in its home habitat.  Instead, it corresponded to those from highlands nearly two hundred miles away.  This evidence suggests that these creatures did indeed migrate.

A spokesperson for Everything Dinosaur noted:

“This new study adds weight to the theory that certain types of dinosaurs migrated just as many mammals and birds do today.”

A herd of huge Camarasaurus dinosaurs walking slowly across the lowland plain to the richer feeding grounds of the upland areas would have been a wonderful sight.   However, these plant-eaters probably did not migrate alone.  Just as many other plant-eating animals travel with the wildebeest in eastern Africa (zebra, buffalo, antelopes) in search of grazing it is likely that a number of other types of dinosaur migrated with the sauropods to find better feeding areas.

The Everything Dinosaur spokesperson added:

“If large numbers of plant-eaters migrate, then we see the formation of predator trails to, with the meat-eaters adapting their behaviour to cope with this seasonal fluctuation in prey animals.  It is likely that these behaviours were also adopted by the predatory dinosaurs in the region, animals such as the fearsome Allosaurus.”

This is not the first time that an analysis of isotopes found in dinosaur teeth has provided scientists with new information about prehistoric animals.    In June, we published information on the work carried out by another group of American researchers (California Institute of Technology) who had examined sauropod teeth found in Africa, in a bid to determine whether these animals were warm-blooded.

To read more about this research: American Researchers use Teeth to Find Evidence of Warm-Blooded Dinosaurs.

“Maximum Likelihood” Study Suggests Archaeopteryx is a Bird and Not a Dinosaur

Archaeopteryx (A. lithographica) is perhaps one of the most studied species known.  An amazing amount of research has been carried out on this creature, whose fossils are associated with lithographic limestone deposits in Germany.  A few weeks ago, we reported that a study carried out by a team of Chinese scientists, in the light of a new theropod dinosaur discovery, placed Archaeopteryx in the Dinosauria and not with the Aves (birds).   However, in a new study, this crow-sized, feathered creature has once again been defined as a primitive bird.

Archaeopteryx

The new research appearing this week in the scientific journal ” Biology Letters”  has been carried out  by evolutionary biologist, Dr Michael Lee of the University of Adelaide and the South Australian Museum and Dr Trevor Worthy of the University of New South Wales.  These Australian based scientists contradict the findings of the Chinese team, from the Chinese Academy of Sciences, that only a few weeks ago placed Archaeopteryx in the dinosaur family tree.

A Fossil Cast of Archaeopteryx on Display at a Museum

Archaeopteryx fossil cast. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.

Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur

The Chinese researchers compared the fossils of Archaeopteryx with those of a newly discovered non-avian, Chinese theropod dinosaur Xiaotingia zhengi.   This newly discovered, fast-running, meat-eater is believed to be closely related to Archaeopteryx, but it was a non-flying, feathered dinosaur.  This put into doubt the widely accepted scientific view that Archaeopteryx was one of the first birds to evolve.

To read more about this Chinese theropod and the implications for Archaeopteryx: Is Archaeopteryx about to be Knocked Off its Perch?

Commenting on the uproar and excitement caused when the first nearly complete fossil of Archaeopteryx was discovered 150 years ago, Dr Lee stated:

“It was immediately recognised as half bird-half reptile when it was first discovered.”

However, the discovery of X. zhengi led to the proposing of a  new, remodelled evolutionary tree that placed Archaeopteryx in a group with bird-like dinosaurs such as the dromaeosaurs.

Summing up the implications for A. lithographica as a result of the new phylogenetic analysis, Dr Lee stated:

“Archaeopteryx lost its exalted place in bird evolution.”

Extant Cycads may not be “Living Fossils”

Cycads are palm-like seed plants with massive stems which produce a crown of fern-like leaves.  These strange looking plants may be relatively short, but fossil data indicates that some extinct species may have grown to more than fifteen metres tall.   A new study indicates that those species alive today are not closely related to the cycads that were grazed by the dinosaurs and other Mesozoic herbivores.  It seems that extant cycads may have evolved from species that diversified to exploit changing world climates around 5-12 million years ago.

Cycads

That is the conclusion from a study led by Utah State University scientists, the term “living fossil” so often used when referring to organisms that resemble those preserved in the fossil record may not apply to the cycad family.

The evolutionary origins of cycads remains unclear, they are probably descended from pteridosperms (seed ferns) and their are fossils to indicate that these plants were around during the Permian Period, although they may actually have evolved earlier, in the Carboniferous.

A Model of a Cycad

A welcome addition to the CollectA model range, a replica of a cycad.

The picture (above) shows a replica of a cycad tree in the CollectA model range, to see this series that is available from Everything Dinosaur: CollectA Prehistoric Plants and Dinosaur Models.

Commenting on his research findings, Hardeep Rai, a post-doctoral research fellow with Utah State University’s department of Wildland Resources stated:

“The current form of cycads looks very much like cycads did when they were at their peak 150 million years ago in terms of the number of species and their coverage of the Earth.”

Modern Species

However, the research team concluded that of the three hundred or so known species alive today, these plants resulted from a fairly recent branching of the cycad family tree.

Discussing the research findings, Nathalie Nagalingum of the Royal Botanic Garden in Sydney, New South Wales said:

“Today’s species did not exist during the reign of the dinosaurs.  They evolved independently of dinosaurs only ten million years ago.  The recent radiation of cycads radically changes our view of these emblematic living fossils.”

It is very likely that the feeding activities of dinosaurs and other herbivores during the Late Palaeozoic and into the Mesozoic affected the evolution of plants, just as the grazing of mammals influences flora today.  However, this study suggests that those cycad species alive today are not directly related to more primitive cycad genera.

Gymnosperm Tree of Life Project

The study arose from the National Science Foundation-funded Gymnosperm Tree of Life project.  Co-authors of the research include Berkeley’s Charles Marshall and Tiago Quental and Damon Little of the New York Botanical Garden.

We at Everything Dinosaur, discussed the cycad family back in July when we produced an article commenting on the presence of cycads today.  We may have to re-write this piece in the light of this research.

To read more about cycads: Yes, we have Cycads Alive Today.

Cycads were most abundant during the Jurassic and Cretaceous, before the evolution of the flowering plants (Angiosperms) led to the decline of this type of flora.  Extant cycads are classed into eleven genera found in three families and certain types of cycad are popular plants with gardeners, although they are high maintenance in a chilly UK climate.

Prior to this new study, the fragmented distribution of modern cycads was thought to indicate that the modern species are the descendants of previously more widespread genera.  The fossil record shows that cycads were particularly widespread during the Mesozoic, even making up a significant proportion of the flora to be found in polar regions.   However, unlike their modern equivalents, these prehistoric polar cycads lost their leaves in winter and they had vine-like stems.

Although, cycads superficially resemble palms and have branching, pinnate, fern-like leaves they are not closely related to palm trees or indeed to ferns.

The research team used a method called molecular dating to analyse the DNA of about two hundred living cycad species.  Scientists calibrated these species’ genetic profiles against the fossil record and found they branched off from a common ancestor between five and twelve million years ago.

The concept of a molecular clock is that evolutionary change occurs at regular time intervals.  If it is assumed that the rate of genetic change (mutation) in the DNA of an organism does not change, i.e. the rate is relatively constant, the molecular genetic difference between two species can be measured and the time when they diversified from a common ancestor calculated.  Using this data, Hardeep Rai and his fellow researchers were able to calculate when these species of cycads in the study diverged from their common ancestor.

Rai said:

“The hypothesis that dinosaurs are responsible for the approximately 300 species of cycads we know today no longer fits.  Some worldwide event caused an explosion of evolutionary change.   The question is: What happened?”

The scientists have postulated that climate change triggered this burst of speciation with the help of specialised insect pollinator, weevils and beetles that underwent evolutionary change at the same time.

Around 12 million years ago, the world’s continents reached their current positions.  Instead of warm climates around the globe, temperate zones emerged at the higher latitudes and climates became seasonal.  Diversification seen in today’s cycads many have occurred in response to these environmental changes.