Safari Ltd introduced into their range of prehistoric animal models a tube (toob) of Cambrian lifeforms, a set of eight figures that represent different types of creature that existed more than 500 million years ago. This skilfully crafted and well-designed range of replicas has proved to be extremely useful for researchers as they study the enigmatic animals that existed during the Cambrian and the preceding geological age, the Ediacaran.
Sometimes it can be challenging for scientists to illustrate their fossil finds. Many fossil specimens can be difficult to make out to the untrained eye and a model of the animal placed in close proximity to the fossil, can help to demonstrate what sort of creature the fossil represents. A few days ago, Everything Dinosaur supplied a Safari Ltd Cambrian Toob to a researcher at Bristol University who wanted to use one of the models in this set for just such a purpose – to illustrate the ancient Cambrian arthropod Sidneyia.
The Cambrian Fossils Next to a Model of Sidneyia
Fossil arthropods preserved in a 520 million-year-old rock with a model of one of the creatures – Sidneyia.
The slab of rock (above) comes from northern Greenland, it contains a preserved impression of the Cambrian arthropod known as Sidneyia. At around six centimetres in length, the Wild Safari Prehistoric World Sidneyia replica provides a useful scale. The scientist explained to Everything Dinosaur that the rock comes from a locality called Sirius Passet and it was collected on a recent expedition to this remote part of the world during the summer.
The fossil site was discovered in 1984 by a field team from the Geological Survey of Greenland. Several thousand specimens have been collected over the years, the Sirius Passet locality is a Cambrian Lagerstätte, a very fossil rich area that preserves marine fauna from the, as yet, not formally defined “Stage 3” of the Cambrian geological period. The Sirius Passet biota is often compared to the biota associated with the Burgess Shale deposits of British Columbia, but the Greenland rocks are at least ten million years older and therefore more comparable in age to the Maotianshan shales from Chengjiang, from Yunnan Province in south-western China.
The Safari Ltd Cambrian Toob Models
Examples of the Cambrian biota.
Safari Ltd Cambrian Toob Contents
The eight colourful figures in the Safari Ltd Cambrian Toob represent a variety of different marine organisms, including the nektonic predator Anomalocaris, Vauxia (a sponge) and the bizarre worm-like creature Ottoia. Several arthropods are featured too, including Sanctacaris, Sidneyia, Naraoia and a Trilobite (Tricrepicephalus).
Sidneyia from the Safari Ltd Cambrian Toob
Details about the Cambrian arthropod Sidneyia. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.
Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur
Believed to have been a predator feeding on molluscs and other hard-shelled creatures, Sidneyia probably scuttled along the sea floor (benthic). It was named after Sidney Walcott, the eldest son of Charles Walcott, the American scientist who discovered the Burgess Shale deposits in 1909. The scientist who requested the Safari Ltd Cambrian Toob wrote to say that the rock slab contains three arthropods, a well-preserved Sidneyia, a well-preserved, undescribed arthropod that they were working on and another indeterminate arthropod.
A fossil bone, a partial femur, found in the 1950s and originally regarded as “dinosaur” bone has been reassessed and confirmed as coming from a bizarre marine mammal, a member of the Desmostylia Order, a group of mysterious animals that looked like a cross between a sea-going hippopotamus and a sealion with hooves. Writing in the open access journal of the Royal Society (Royal Society Open Science), the research team were able to track down the fossil site using the original hand-written note kept with the fossil in combination with interviews of relatives of construction workers who were involved in the original fossil find.
Views of the Fossil Femur – The “Dinosaur” Bone
Views of the Desmostylia femur with a taxonomic illustration in the form of a line drawing.
Picture credit: Kumiko Matsui et al./Royal Society
The picture above shows the fossil femur (top) with an accompanying line drawing (bottom). Cranial view (A), interior view (B), caudal view (C) with an exterior view (D). Note the scale bar is ten centimetres.
Scientists Turn into Detectives
Yuri Kimura, the Curator of Vertebrate Palaeontology at the National Museum of Nature and Science (Tokyo) and one of the co-authors of the scientific paper, found an old wooden box when exploring the archives of the University of Tsukuba last year. The box contained the proximal end of a right femur. The scientist then set about identifying the location of the fossil find. Yuri and the other collaborators on this project, a combination of anatomical assessment, taphonomy and detective work, learned that the fossil was discovered during construction of a debris flow barrier and that it was recognised as a “dinosaur” bone among the locals and displayed in a village hall until the town experienced a fire disaster in 1954.
During the research, one of the interviewees confirmed that the bone had been described as coming from a member of the Desmostylia, but if it had been examined by a scientist/palaeontologist, it had not been reported or the find officially documented.
A Skeletal Drawing of Paleoparadoxia (Desmostylia) Showing the Anatomical Position of the Bone
A skeleton of Paleoparadoxia showing the location of the fossil bone (in red).
Picture credit: Kumiko Matsui et al./Royal Society
Paleoparadoxia (Desmostylia)
Comparisons undertaken with other fossil specimens, led the research team to conclude that the right femur was from the Paleoparadoxia genus, a member of the Desmostylia, an extinct Order believed to be distantly related to Sea Cows.
This study provides an excellent example of historical and scientific information being extracted from long-forgotten and uncatalogued specimens so long as the original information is retained with the specimens.
A Life Reconstruction of Paleoparadoxia
A life reconstruction of the bizarre Miocene mammal Paleoparadoxia.
Picture credit: Kumiko Matsui et al./Royal Society
Fossil worm excites palaeontologists. Three-dimensionally preserved lobopodian from Herefordshire.
A team of international researchers including scientists from the Oxford University Natural History Museum, Imperial College London, Manchester and Leicester Universities and the Yale Peabody Museum of Natural History, have identified a new species of lobopodian, a bizarre segmented worm-like creature, in 430 million-year-old rocks in Herefordshire (England). Digital technology has been utilised to reconstruct a three-dimensional model of this exceptional fossil, an ancient ancestor of the modern, enigmatic Velvet worm.
The Research Team Produced Three-dimensional Images of the Fossil Lobopodian
Three-dimensional digital images of the fossil lobopodian from Herefordshire.
Picture credit: University of Leicester
Soft-bodied, Worm-like Creatures with Legs
Lead author of the study, Derek Siveter, (Professor Emeritus of Earth Sciences at Oxford University and Honorary Research Associate at Oxford University Museum of Natural History), commented:
“Lobopodians are extremely rare in the fossil record, except in the Cambrian Period. Worm-like creatures with legs, they are an ancestral marine relative of modern-day velvet worms, or onychophorans – predators that live in vegetation, mainly in southern latitudes.”
The Velvet Worm (Peripatus Genus)
Peripatus a genus within the Onychophora – creatures like this may have been the first to walk on land.
Picture credit: BBC
The Evolution of the Arthropods
Palaeontologists have puzzled for decades over the evolution of groups of modern animals such as the Arthropoda, the largest phylum of animals which includes the trilobites, insects, crustaceans, spiders, scorpions, mites and so forth. Studies of the exotic Ediacaran and Cambrian biota has helped scientists to better understand the evolutionary relationships between living groups of animals today and their ancient invertebrate ancestors, but many soft-bodied groups are severely underrepresented in the fossil record.
Thanahita distos
It is still extremely difficult to pin down which type of organism preserved within the remarkable Cambrian-aged Burgess Shale deposits for example, is an ancestor of modern groups of animals alive today. This newly described fossil specimen, named Thanahita distos represents an example of a member of the Lobopodia, an extremely ancient group of invertebrates that might be a basal member of the panarthropods – a clade that includes today’s arthropods, as well as Velvet Worms (Onychophora) and the Water Bears (tardigrades).
The Silurian-aged deposits in Herefordshire, consist of finely grained volcanic ash layers that settled on a seabed some 430 to 425 million years ago. These sediments have preserved in exquisite detail many of the marine organisms that roamed across the sea floor. Writing in the Royal Society Open Science journal, the researchers describe T. distos and note that it is the first lobopodian to be formally described from rocks from the Silurian and it is one of only eight known three-dimensionally preserved lobopodian or onychophoran fossil specimens known to science.
Professor Siveter explained how the team were able to build up a picture of the ancient sea creature:
“We have been able to digitally reconstruct the creature using a technique called physical-optical tomography. This involves taking images of the fossil at a fraction of a millimetre apart, then “stitching” together the images to form a “virtual fossil” that can be investigated on screen.”
Herefordshire Lagerstätte
The Herefordshire Lagerstätte has provided scientists with numerous exceptionally preserved invertebrate fossils. Everything Dinosaur has reported on several of these, very significant fossil discoveries on this blog, including one Herefordshire fossil which was named in honour of Sir David Attenborough:
Professor Siveter outlined how delicate creatures like Thanahita distos became preserved, he stated:
“Thanahita distos and the other animals that became fossilised here likely lived 100 to 200 metres down, possibly below the depth to which much light penetrates. We deduce this because we found no vestiges of photosynthetic algae, which are common in contemporaneous rocks laid down at shallower points on the seafloor to the east.“
Professor Siveter added:
“Some special circumstances allowed for their remarkable preservation. The first was the immediate precipitation of clay minerals around the dead organisms, which decayed over time, leaving empty spaces behind. The mineral calcite – a form of calcium carbonate – then filled these natural moulds, replicating the shape of the animals. Almost at the same time, hard concretions began to form, being cemented by calcite. Thanks to the early hardening of these Silurian time capsules in this way, the fossils were not squashed as the ash layer slowly compacted.”
Fossil Worm Related to the Enigmatic Hallucigenia
A phylogenetic analysis undertaken by the researchers placed T. distos, together with all the described Hallucigenia species, in a sister-clade to crown-group the panarthropods. Its placement in a redefined Hallucigeniidae, an iconic Cambrian clade, indicates the survival of these types of creatures into Silurian times.
The Newly Described Thanahita distos is Placed Within the Enigmatic Hallucigeniidae
Scientists have classified the newly described T. distos as a relative of the bizarre Cambrian Hallucigenia from the Burgess Shale of British Columbia.
Picture credit: Danielle Dufault
The professor stated:
“Some lobopodians lie in a position on the tree of life which foreshadows that of the terrestrial velvet worms, while others are precursors of the arthropods: the “king crabs”, spiders, crustaceans and related forms. Since its discovery, the Herefordshire Lagerstätte has yielded a diversity of arthropods that have contributed much to our understanding of the palaeobiology and early history of this very important invertebrate group. The lobopodian Thanahita distos belongs to an extended, panarthropod grouping.”
A Spectacular Herefordshire Specimen (Fossil Worm)
The discovery of the Herefordshire specimen and its subsequent phylogenetic analysis indicates that the lobopodian group, which is associated with Late Cambrian strata, persisted into the Silurian, thus demonstrating that these creatures survived for at least 100 million years.
A Fossil of Hallucigenia Specimen from the Late Cambrian Rocks of British Columbia
A Hallucigenia specimen (Royal Ontario Museum) from the Late Cambrian deposits of British Columbia. The red arrow is highlighting a droplet-like structure, once thought to represent the head but now regarded as probable gut contents.
Picture credit: Royal Ontario Museum/Dr Jean Bernard Caron
The scientific paper: “A Three-dimensionally Preserved Lobopodian from the Herefordshire (Silurian) Lagerstätte, UK” by Derek J. Siveter, Derek E. G. Briggs, David J. Siveter, Mark D. Sutton and David Legg published by the Royal Society Open Science
Acheroraptor temertyorum – Most Dangerous Critter of Hell Creek
Was Acheroraptor temertyorum more dangerous to smaller dinosaurs than T. rex?
If you could travel back in time and visit western North America 66 million years ago, you might find yourself within the territory of a Tyrannosaurus rex. Not a very safe place to be you might think, you would probably be right, but the Hell Creek fauna contained another theropod dinosaur, one that was perhaps, more dangerous to a human visitor than a T. rex or for that matter the other apex predator known from the Hell Creek Formation – Dakotaraptor steini.
Named and scientifically described in 2013, the real man-eater of Hell Creek might have been Acheroraptor (A. temertyorum), at around three metres long and weighing as much as a German Shepherd dog, a pack of these ferocious hunters would probably have made short work of any human visitor to the Late Cretaceous who was unfortunate to encounter them.
A Scale Drawing of the Velociraptorine Dromaeosaurid Acheroraptor temertyorum
A scale drawing of Acheroraptor. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.
Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur
Acheroraptor temertyorum – “Underworld Plunderer”
Named after the River of Pain “Acheron” in the underworld from Greek myth, Acheroraptor was one of the very last of the non-avian theropod dinosaurs and it probably played a secondary predator role in the Hell Creek ecosystem. There were larger predators, the five-and-a-half-metre-long Dakotaraptor for example, that like Acheroraptor was one of the very last dromaeosaurids to evolve. However, packs of Dakotaraptors and the iconic Tyrannosaurus rex may not have considered a single person much of meal and may not have expanded a lot of energy in trying to catch them. To a pack of Acheroraptors, a human would have made a very satisfactory lunch, best to avoid Acheroraptor if you can.
Some of the Typical Dinosaurian Fauna of the Hell Creek Formation (Maastrichtian Faunal Stage of the Late Cretaceous)
Typical dinosaurs of the Hell Creek Formation. Although there were larger predators, to a person visiting Montana 66 million years ago, meeting a pack of Acheroraptors would have been extremely dangerous.Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.
Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur
Part of the Vertebrate Fossil Collection at the Royal Ontario Museum
The specific or trivial name “temertyorum” was selected to honour James and Louise Temerty in recognition for their outstanding support and contribution to the Royal Ontario Museum, which houses the jaw fragments that led to the scientific description of this dinosaur back in 2013.
Acheroraptor probably lived in packs and may have had a role similar to extant hyenas or jackals in present-day ecosystems. Palaeontologists had suspected that dromaeosaurids roamed Montana in very last years of the Cretaceous, numerous teeth with their diagnostic wide ridges (denticles) had been discovered, but the lack of fossilised bones prevented scientists from assigning a genus.
The Holotype Fossil Maxilla and Lower Jaw (Dentary) of Acheroraptor
The jaws of Acheroraptor.
Picture credit: Royal Ontario Museum
Acheroraptor More Closely Related to Asian Dromaeosaurids
Palaeontologists have concluded that Acheroraptor was more closely related to Asian dromaeosaurids such as Velociraptor (V. mongoliensis), than it was to other North American dromaeosaurids. Assigned to the Velociraptorinae subfamily of the Dromaeosauridae, the relatively long-snouted Acheroraptor provides supporting evidence to suggest the presence of a Late Cretaceous land bridge between Asia and North America.
A spokesperson from Everything Dinosaur explained:
“There is a considerable amount of evidence that supports the idea of the existence of a Cretaceous Beringian land bridge linking North America and Asia. This land bridge may not have been permanent but appeared at times when sea levels fell, permitting a faunal exchange between dinosaur-based ecosystems. The ancestors of Acheroraptor temertyorum probably migrated into North America.”
Beasts of the Mesozoic 1/6th Scale Acheroraptor temertyorum
There are lots of models of the Hell Creek Formation biota available, countless T. rex and Triceratops figures for instance, but it was the clever and talented David Silva of Creative Beast Studio who created a 1/6th scale replica of Acheroraptor within the amazing “Beasts of the Mesozoic” model range.
The “Beasts of the Mesozoic” Acheroraptor temertyorum Figure
The Beasts of the Mesozoic Acheroraptor model.
To view the beautiful Acheroraptor model and the rest of the figures in the “Beasts of the Mesozoic Raptor” range: Beasts of the Mesozoic “Raptors”.
Nichollssaura borealis – Shaking its Neck from Side to Side
The long-necked plesiosaurs (Plesiosauroidea), are characterised (unsurprisingly), by their long necks, which in the case of the elasmosaurids were taken to extremes with some Late Cretaceous species having necks around seven metres in length, comprising 76 cervical vertebrae, but how did a plesiosaur use their necks? What degree of movement did these long necks have? These are questions that have been debated by palaeontologists for nearly two hundred years.
New research, published this week by the Royal Society, sheds light on the flexibility and neck movement in one plesiosaur, the Early Cretaceous leptocleidid Nichollssaura borealis.
The Fossilised Skeleton of a Jurassic Plesiosaur
The teeth of the plesiosaur were well adapted for catching fish. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.
Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur
Defining the Plesiosauria Clade
The Plesiosauria clade was very successful, originating in the Triassic and persisting until the very end of the Cretaceous. This clade is split into three distinct groups, although palaeontologists debate the phylogeny between the Plesiosauria clade members.
The Plesiosauroidea – the long-necked marine reptiles, epitomised by short tails, broad bodies, four flippers, a small head and an elongated neck.
Pliosauridae – the short-necked plesiosaurs, with large heads, broad bodies, four flippers and much shorter necks than the Plesiosauroidea.
The Rhomaleosauridae – a sort of half-way house between the other two, typically possessing longer necks and smaller heads relative to the Pliosauridae, but have shorter necks and larger heads when compared to members of the Plesiosauridae. Most known rhomaleosaurids are confined to the Early to Middle Jurassic of Europe, with most specimens assigned to this group having been found in England.
The Three Groups Within the Plesiosauria
The three groups that make up the Plesiosauroidea. The long-necked Plesiosauroidea, the short-necked Pliosauridae and the Rhomaleosauridae.Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.
Studying One Member of the Plesiosauroidea – Nichollssaura borealis
The researchers from the Royal Tyrrell Museum and the University of Calgary, focused their study upon one specimen, a member of the Plesiosauroidea called Nichollssaura borealis. This specimen was chosen as it represents a very nearly complete individual and the fossil is not distorted or crushed to any degree which might have comprised any research into neck flexibility.
There were two further, more practical reasons why N. borealis was selected. Firstly, the specimen is housed at the Royal Tyrrell Museum and since one of the researchers involved in the study was Donald Henderson, a curator at the museum, accessing the specimen was not a problem. In addition, with a total length of 2.6 metres Nichollssaura could squeeze into the medical CT scanner that was being used to create accurate three-dimensional images of the bones.
Once the specimen had been CT scanned, the subsequent three-dimensional models that were produced could be examined so as to conclude the range of movement afforded by the 24 bones in the neck of this plesiosaur (24 cervical vertebrae).
The Research Team Tested the Range of Neck Movement Using Three-Dimensional Models
Examining the range of motion of Nichollssaura.
Picture credit: Royal Society Open Science
Sideways Movement of the Neck
When the three dimensional models of the Nichollssaura borealis neck were examined the scientists discovered that the neck of this plesiosaur was indeed very mobile, but their results suggest a preference for lateral (sideways) movements of the neck in this species. This supports the idea that these marine reptiles fed in or along the seafloor, using their small heads and long necks to probe into the sediment to find invertebrates and fish.
Unfortunately, no gut contents indicating potential prey have been preserved in association with the single fossil specimen of Nichollssaura, however, other researchers have found prey gut contents in other plesiosaurids that supports the idea that these animals fed by disturbing and catching animals that live on the sea floor (epifaunal).
To test the validity of the three-dimensional computer models, the scientists studied the range of neck movement in a extant species of monitor lizard, Dumeril’s monitor, a species from south-east Asia (Varanus dumerilii). This species was chosen as it has a relatively long neck for a monitor lizard and a preserved specimen was available for study.
The researchers conclude that if this species of plesiosaurid (N. borealis) had a neck that was adapted to rapid sideways movements then this probably evolved in relation to feeding method and prey capture. Different types of Plesiosauroidea with their different neck lengths very likely had different ecological roles within the ecosystem. This study also demonstrates that three-dimensional modelling is an effective tool for assessing function morphology for structures where no good, living analogue for comparison exists.
Scientists have been measuring and mapping a set of dinosaur tracks found in a quarry in Dorset. The saucer-shaped tracks were made by a herd of long-necked sauropod dinosaurs that crossed a stretch of a tidal lagoon back in the Early Cretaceous. The quarry is located close to the village of Worth Matravers, around three-and-a half-miles east of the coastal town of Swanage, on the Isle of Purbeck.
A View (Dorsal) of a Dinosaur Footprint (Sauropoda)
Dorsal view of one of the dinosaur footprints (Sauropoda).
Picture credit: Bournemouth University
Giant Dinosaur Tracks
The group of large dinosaurs were walking slowly in a herd, leaving a series of parallel trackways. They have been described as “giant saucer-shaped depressions just a few millimetres deep”, according to geologist Matthew Bennett from Bournemouth University who has been called in to study and map the fossilised tracks.
The quarry is the property of Lewis Quarries, one of a number in the area that provide valuable limestone blocks for the construction industry.
An Aerial View of the Dinosaur Tracks
An aerial view of the Dorset dinosaur footprint site.
Picture credit: Bournemouth University
Early Cretaceous Dinosaur Tracks
The footprints were made between 139 and 145 million years ago (Early Cretaceous), the tracks were infilled by lime rich muds, creating trace fossils.
David Moodie, a spokesperson for Lewis Quarries explained:
“It became apparent that we had come across something of historical interest, so working closely with the National Trust and Professor Matthew Bennett of Bournemouth University, we were able to move forward in the best way without stopping progress in the quarry itself.”
National Trust Lead Ranger Jonathan Kershaw added:
“The group of dinosaurs that made these tracks may be the same ones whose footprints can still be seen in situ just nearby at Keates Quarry just off the Priest’s Way bridleway. It’s exciting to think that giant sauropods once roamed where today there are dry stone walls, skylarks and nesting seabirds.”
An Illustration of the Sauropods Crossing the Shallow Lagoon
Sauropod illustration – sauropods crossing a shallow lagoon.
Picture credit: Bournemouth University
In 2015, Everything Dinosaur reported on the discovery of a series of sauropod footprints and tracks on the Isle of Skye. These tracks were made in similar circumstances as the Purbeck limestone prints, a group of sauropods crossed a shallow lagoon, however, the Isle of Skye prints are around thirty million years older and date from the Middle Jurassic.
Using a process of photogrammetry and special freeware developed at Bournemouth University called DigTrace, Professor Bennett carefully documented the tracks in three dimensions. The DigTrace technology was developed with a government grant and help from the Home Office and National Crime Agency. Its principle aim is to forensically examine footprints and other tracks related to crime scenes, however, it is ideal for plotting the movements of extinct dinosaurs too.
Professor Bennett commented:
“This technology is now being used by the police to help track criminals via their footprints, but we can also use it to record and preserve rare footprints like these. The beauty of capturing the tracks in 3D is that they can be analysed digitally and even printed in the future, no need to hold up the quarrying for long.”
Drawing Up a Conservation Plan for the Dinosaur Tracks
With the co-operation of Lewis Quarries and in collaboration with the National Trust and researchers at Bournemouth University, a conservation plan is being prepared. It is hoped that the tracks will be lifted from their setting and put on public display once all the appropriate scientific steps (pardon the pun), have been taken.
The trackway surface is also exposed in nearby Keates Quarry where the National Trust maintains a small conservation area of similar tracks.
Professor Bennett concluded:
“What is remarkable, is that the tracks at both adjacent quarries were probably made by the same animals moving along the coast. The dip of the beds, folded when the European Alps were pushed up, means that the tracks are closer to the ground in Keates Quarry and can be preserved but are much deeper at Lewis Quarries where in situ preservation is not possible.”
The Dig Site at the Dorset Quarry
The sauropod trackway site (Purbeck limestone).
Picture credit: Bournemouth University
Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the assistance of the media centre at Bournemouth University for the compilation of this article.
Our skeleton is very special, the evolution of a rigid internal skeleton (bones), was an extremely significant development in the history of life on Earth. However, how hard, internal skeletons evolved has been the subject of much debate amongst palaeontologists. However, thanks to research undertaken by scientists at Manchester and Bristol Universities in collaboration with the technicians at a synchrotron light source based in Switzerland, we might have a better understanding of how we came to be.
The Origins of Our Skeleton
All living vertebrates have skeletons built from four different tissue types: bone and cartilage (the main tissues that human skeletons are made from), and dentine and enamel (the tissues from which our teeth are constructed). These tissues are unique because they become mineralised as they develop, giving the skeleton strength and rigidity.
Primitive fish were the first to develop a mineralised skeleton and one group of early fishes, the heterostracans, has attracted a lot of interest from scientists as they try to work out the evolutionary processes that took place. The heterostracans, were a group of heavily armoured, jawless fishes that evolved during the Early Silurian. These fish, which are mostly associated with marine and estuarine deposits, had two plates, one on the top of the body and one underneath, they served to help protect the animal from attack and might have had a secondary function to help keep the body stiffened. These fish also had large scales on their bodies too.
A “Swimming Table Tennis Paddle” – A Life Restoration of Drepanaspis – An Early Devonian Heterostracan
A life reconstruction of Drepanaspis a typical heterostracan fish.
The Primitive Bone-like Tissue Aspidin
Earlier research had identified that the surface scales and broad plates of these primitive fishes had enamel-like tops over a core of dentine, essentially the same material that forms our teeth. Supporting these structures was a layer of sponge-like material called aspidin. Aspidin is bone in its earliest mineralised form. It is thought that the very first basal, internal skeleton provided an anchor to support the armour that was on the outside of the body. In this new study, the scientists used synchrotron X-ray tomographic microscopy to reveal the nature of aspidin.
Lead author of the paper, published in the journal “Nature Ecology & Evolution”, Dr Joseph Keating (Manchester University), explained:
“Heterostracan skeletons are made of a really strange tissue called “aspidin”. It is crisscrossed by tiny tubes and does not closely resemble any of the tissues found in vertebrates today. For 160 years, scientists have wondered if aspidin is a transitional stage in the evolution of mineralised tissues.”
Errivaspis – A Member of the Heterostraci from the Early Devonian
Errivaspis – anterior portion of fossil, from the Early Devonian.
Picture credit: Keating et al
Ruling Out Other Theories
Scientists had been aware of the spongy nature of aspidin. However, they were unable to work out what might have filled the pores and spaces in the material, using traditional methods of study. Knowing what filled these unmineralised spaces would provide the information needed to help demonstrate the role that aspidin played in the evolution of back-boned animals.
Four theories regarding what filled these spaces had been put forward:
The spaces housed cells, like the osteoblasts and osteocytes that are found in living bones.
The spaces were filled with fibres made from proteins such as collagen.
The spaces were filled with dentine.
The spaces were filled with a mixture of dentine and bone.
The team showed that these “gaps” in the aspidin represented the location of bundles of collagen (2). These “gaps” housed the same sort of protein that is found in our skin and bones (in fact collagen is the most abundant type of protein found in our bodies).
Aspidin is the Earliest Evidence of Bone in the Fossil Record
These findings enabled Dr Keating to rule out all but one theory for the tissue’s identity, proving that aspidin is the earliest evidence of bone in the fossil record.
Co-author of the study, Professor Phil Donoghue (University of Bristol), who has done much to reveal the true anatomical nature of the heterostracans, stated:
“These findings change our view on the evolution of the skeleton. Aspidin was once thought to be the precursor of vertebrate mineralised tissues. We show that it is, in fact, a type of bone, and that all these tissues must have evolved millions of years earlier.”
The team suggest that the collagen bundles form a scaffold which permits minerals to be deposited. Aspidin is acellular dermal bone, so one question is answered but it gives rise to a host of others. For example, if all the skeletal tissue types associated with vertebrates were present in the heterostracans, then these structures and materials must have evolved earlier than expected.
The scientific paper: “The Nature of Aspidin and the Evolutionary Origin of Bone” by J. Keating, C. Marquart and P. Donoghue published in Nature Ecology & Evolution.
Lingwulong shenqi – The Dinosaur That’s Not Supposed to be There
Dinosaurs, so often regarded in the past as epitomising animals that were too slow and stupid to survive, are demonstrating that they were one of the most successful groups of terrestrial vertebrates to have evolved. A newly described, long-necked dinosaur from the Middle Jurassic of northern China suggests that sauropods dispersed and diversified much earlier than palaeontologists had previously thought. The new dinosaur has been named Lingwulong shenqi and it is the earliest known diplodocoid.
A Life Reconstruction of the Newly Described Lingwulong shenqi
A life reconstruction of Lingwulong shenqi, the earliest known diplodocoid.
Picture credit: Zhang Zongda
Subgroups of Sauropods with Restricted Geographical Ranges
Although the sauropods dominated terrestrial faunas for much of the Mesozoic and their fossils are globally distributed, scientists had been aware that several subgroups demonstrated restricted geographical ranges. For example, the sauropod superfamily Diplodocoidea, which is part of a huge clade of long-necked dinosaurs called the Neosauropoda, was believed to have never existed in eastern Asia. This permitted a unique range of long-necked dinosaurs to evolve and thrive in this part of the world, the Mamenchisauridae. In essence, the isolation of eastern Asia permitted to evolution of the region’s very own endemic range of dinosaurs.
Lingwulong shenqi – The Implications for Dinosaur Distribution
The Neosauropoda consists of two distinct groups of sauropod, firstly there is the Diplodocoidea, this includes some of the most famous dinosaurs of all, animals such as Brontosaurus, Apatosaurus, Diplodocus and Amargasaurus. The second type of sauropod within the Neosauropoda are the Macronaria, which consists of equally famous dinosaurs such as Brachiosaurus and Camarasaurus. It had been thought that once eastern Asia became isolated, the neosauropods were unable to spread to this part of the world.
Their absence had been explained by the break-up of the super-continent Pangaea. A seaway was formed cutting off and isolating this part of Asia during the Jurassic. In the case of the Diplodocoidea, these types of long-necked dinosaur evolved and dispersed but they never reached northern China. By the time sea levels had changed and land connections were once again formed linking northern China to other land masses in the Early Cretaceous, the diplodocoids were in decline and their numbers and geographic range had been greatly reduced since their Late Jurassic heyday.
The discovery of Lingwulong shenqi changes all this. Diplodocoids were present in eastern Asia, so they must have evolved and diversified into this region earlier than previously thought, or land bridges may have existed linking this part of Asia to the rest of Pangaea for longer.
Mapping the Distribution of the Diplodocoidea
An epicontinental sea formed during the Jurassic which isolated northern Asia from Europe. This restricted the spread of certain types of dinosaur. Diplodocoid dinosaurs had already evolved and spread before northern Asia was cut off.
Picture credit: Nature Communications with additional annotation by Everything Dinosaur
Co-author of the open access paper published in “Nature Communications”, Dr Philip Mannion (Imperial College London), explained the significance of this dinosaur discovery:
“Not only is it [Lingwulong] the oldest member [of the Diplodocoidea], but it’s the first ever from Asia. For a long time it was thought that neosauropods didn’t get into Asia during the Jurassic. This suggests that firstly [neosauropods] got in before any kind of barrier came up, but increasingly the geological evidence suggests maybe this barrier was quite ephemeral”
The Formation of the Russian Platform Sea and the Turgai Sea
Tectonic forces led to the formation of an epicontinental seaway during the Middle to Late Jurassic and this isolated northern Asia from the rest of Pangaea. The fossils of Lingwulong come from the Yanan Formation in the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region of China, the strata are estimated to be around 175 to 168 million years old (late Toarcian to Bajocian faunal stages). The discovery of Lingwulong indicates that many advanced kinds of sauropod originated at least 15 million years earlier than previously realised. The Diplodocoidea achieved a global distribution whilst Pangaea was still a single, coherent landmass.
A Reconstruction of the Skeleton of L. shenqi and Examples of Some of the Fossil Bones
A skeletal reconstruction of Lingwulong shenqi and examples of fossil bones. In the skeleton drawing, the bones in white represent fossils associated with this taxon.
Picture credit: Nature Communications
Lingwulong shenqi – “Lingwu’s Amazing Dragon”
The dinosaur has been named after Lingwu, the region in which the fossils were found and the Mandarin Chinese “long” which means dragon. The trivial name – shenqi, comes from the Mandarin for “amazing”, reflecting the unexpected discovery of this type of dinosaur in the Middle Jurassic of China. Excavations originally commenced in 2005 led to the discovery of between 7 and 10 individuals, including two specimens with associated skull material. The fossils represent a range of animal sizes, representing juveniles as well as adults.
With so much fossil material to study, the researchers were able to assign this new genus to a specific place within the broad Superfamily of the Diplodocoidea. They conclude that Lingwulong is a basal member of the Dicraeosauridae.
The Dicraeosauridae includes species such as Suuwassea from the Late Jurassic of Montana, Brachytrachelopan from the Late Jurassic of Argentina and Amargasaurus from the Early Cretaceous of Argentina.
The Position of Lingwulong shenqi Within the Neosauropoda
Plotting the taxonomic position of Lingwulong within the Diplodocoidea.
Picture credit: Nature Communications
The Bigger Picture
The idea that the eastern parts of Asia were cut off from other landmasses during the Jurassic has been put forward to explain the substantial differences between the Jurassic (and sometimes Early Cretaceous), terrestrial biotas between this part of the world and the rest of Pangaea. It is likely that a seaway formed to the west of the Ural Mountains (the Russian Platform Sea), this seaway in conjunction with an ingress of water from the north (the Turgai Sea), isolated the land to the northeast.
This isolation has been used to explain the evolution of a number of new types of prehistoric animal in eastern Asia, such as:
Mamenchisaurid sauropods
Oviraptorosaurs
Therizinosaurs
Marginocephalians
In addition, this sea barrier has been used to explain the absence of many groups that were present elsewhere in Pangaea during the Jurassic, such as:
Diplodocoid sauropods (now debunked by Lingwulong)
Early titanosauriform sauropods
Dromaeosaurids
Nodosaurids
The lineage leading to the iguanodontian ornithopods
The scientific paper: “A New Middle Jurassic Diplodocoid Suggests an Earlier Dispersal and Diversification of Sauropod Dinosaurs” by Xing Xu, Paul Upchurch, Philip D. Mannion, Paul M. Barrett, Omar R. Regalado-Fernandez, Jinyou Mo, Jinfu Ma and Hongan Liu, published in Nature Communications.
Akainacephalus johnsoni – One of the Oldest “Swingers” from North America
On Thursday of last week, a scientific paper was published in the on-line open access journal PeerJ, that described the discovery of a new species of armoured dinosaur from Utah. The armoured dinosaur was named Akainacephalus johnsoni, the genus name is derived from the Greek meaning “spiky” or “thorn”, a reference to the large number of bony scales (caputegulae) located on the top and sides of the skull. The species name honours Randy Johnson, a volunteer preparator at the Natural History Museum of Utah, who skilfully and patiently prepared the skull and lower jaws of this newly described ornithischian.
Akainacephalus johnsoni
A Close-up View of the Bony and Scaly Head of Akainacephalus
A close up of the ornate head of Akainacephalus johnsoni.
Picture credit: Andrey Atuchin (Denver Museum of Nature and Science)
Secondary Functions of the Dermal Armour
This was one very heavily armoured ankylosaurid, with a face described by many media outlets as “ugly” or being one that only a “mother could love”. The fossilised skull, which is nearly complete reveals an extensive amount of armour and ornamentation. For example, the snout is particularly bony, covered in large osteoderms and above each eye there is a substantial horn. Although this armour would have served as protection against attack, the degree of ornamentation in Akainacephalus was quite remarkable, it is likely that these osteoderms, the various lumps and bumps on the dinosaur’s body and head, served a number of functions.
Suggested functions for the extensive ornamentation of A. johnsoni
Anti-glare and anti-dazzle for the eyes. If you look at the close-up view of the head of Akainacephalus in the illustration (above), the eye is shaded. The various projections along the broad snout could have obscured the animal’s vision, but the eye would have been shaded from direct sunlight, a positive advantage in the Late Cretaceous of Utah.
Sexual selection – the greater the ornamentation the more imposing the individual. Just as with peacocks and their impressive tails, deer and their antlers, the greater the number of bumps and lumps could have been a sign of the animal’s fitness to mate. It might be one very ugly looking dinosaur to us, but beauty is in the eye of the beholder, the lumpier the Akainacephalus the greater the appeal of that individual.
In a similar vein to the point made above, the ornamentation could have played a role in display, intimidating rivals as part of ritualistic intraspecific combat or helping to put off the unwanted attentions of any large theropod that had decided to try and make a meal of this four-metre-long armoured dinosaur.
Thermoregulation – the dermal armour of crocodilians serves a number of functions, one of which is to help to regulate the animal’s body temperature. The wide gut of ankylosaurids gave them a large surface area for the sun to beat down onto. By pumping blood into the osteoderms the animal could cool down, helping to maintain its body temperature.
Armoured Dinosaur Mixed Up with Lots of Other Fossils
The Fossil Remains of Akainacephalus and two Skeletal Reconstructions
The skeletal remains of Akainacephalus with two line drawings (dorsal and lateral views). Known fossil bones are highlighted in orange.
Picture credit: PeerJ
The first fossils were found in 2008, in a quarry which contained a mixed assemblage of vertebrate remains. Finds at the site, known as the Horse Mountain Gryposaur quarry, include a nearly complete skull of the hadrosaurid Gryposaurus, turtle fossil remains (Arvinachelys goldeni), a skull and postcranial remains of a new taxon of alligatoroid and a poorly preserved partial skull of a small theropod.
Akainacephalus Wanders Past Ancient Crocodilians
The Akainacephalus drawing shows some of the fauna associated with the dig site – crocodiles and a small freshwater turtle (right) – Arvinachelys goldeni.
Picture credit: Andrey Atuchin (Denver Museum of Nature and Science)
The Amazing Kaiparowits Formation
The fossils were excavated from sediments associated with the Kaiparowits Formation, which provides a unique perspective on the biota of south/central Laramidia during the Campanian faunal stage of the Late Cretaceous. This thick succession of sandstones and mudstones was deposited at an unusually rapid rate within a time frame of less than two million years, making it one of the most rapidly deposited terrestrial formations in the world. Akainacephalus dates from 76.2 to 75.9 million years ago, as such it is one of the oldest ankylosaurids known from North America.
It is also the first documented example of ankylosaurid skull and postcranial bones from the Kaiparowits Formation. Although, some of the fossil bones are in a better condition than others, the fossils, including that amazing tail club are remarkably complete.
Views of the Caudal Vertebrae and the Tail Club of A. johnsoni
Akainacephalus caudal bones and tail club.
Picture credit: PeerJ
Dinosaur Immigrants from Asia
Those lumps and bumps on the skull (cranial ornamentation), are reminiscent of an armoured dinosaur from New Mexico (Nodocephalosaurus kirtlandensis), the researchers postulate that these dinosaurs might be closely related. However, it is worth noting that Nodocephalosaurus is around three million years younger than Akainacephalus. Both Nodocephalosaurus and Akainacephalus are also similar to Asian ankylosaurids such as Saichania chulsanensis, Pinacosaurus grangeri, and the spectacularly horned Minotaurasaurus ramachandrani. The discovery of Akainacephalus adds support to the idea that ankylosaurids migrated across an ancient land bridge from Asia into North America prior to 76 million years ago.
The addition of this new ankylosaurid taxon from southern Utah provides further information on ankylosaurid diversity and supports the theory regarding there being regional variations in dinosaur biota across Laramidia during the later stages of the Cretaceous.
Indicating that Ankylosaurids Migrated from Asia into North America (Akainacephalus johnsoni)
Akainacephalus illustrated.
Picture credit: Andrey Atuchin (Denver Museum of Nature and Science)
A team of international researchers including scientists from the University of Alberta, Midwestern University and the Chinese Academy of Sciences have published a paper describing the remarkable discovery of the preserved remains of a baby snake entombed in amber from Myanmar (Burma). The snake has been named Xiaophis myanmarensis.
Amber deposits from northern Myanmar are providing scientists with some amazing insights into life in a forest some 100 million years or so ago. Other amber nodules, known as burmite have revealed the preserved remains of baby birds, a dinosaur tail, frogs and an astonishing range of invertebrates and plant material. The amber is proving to be a treasure trove for palaeontologists helping them to map the biota of a Cretaceous environment.
The Polished Amber Nodule Revealing the Fossilised Remains of a Baby Snake
The preserved remains of a baby snake preserved in amber from Myanmar.
Picture credit: Ming Bai (Chinese Academy of Sciences)
Xiaophis myanmarensis – Dawn Snake of Myanmar
The baby snake measures around eight centimetres in length. The fossil reveals that the vertebrae are not yet fully formed and this indicates that the snake was very young when it got trapped in the sticky tree resin. The snake has been named Xiaophis myanmarensis, which means “dawn snake of Myanmar”.
The international research team, led by Dr Lida Xing (China University of Geosciences, Beijing and the Chinese Academy of Sciences) and Professor Mike Caldwell (University of Alberta), have described this discovery as a remarkable fossil find.
A Life Restoration of Xiaophis myanmarensis
An illustration of Xiaophis myanmarensis (dawn snake of Myanmar).
Picture credit: Cheung Chung Tat
Not One Fossil Snake but Two
Although the baby snake is missing its skull, ninety-seven vertebrae have been preserved along with associated fossil ribs. The tiny reptile’s bones were analysed using a synchrotron to bombard the specimen with X-rays and plot the result. The back bone is remarkably similar to those found in neonatal snakes today. This suggests that the vertebrae of snakes have remained largely unchanged for 100 million years.
A second amber fossil was discovered, which preserves a piece of the shed skin of another, much larger snake. It is unclear whether these two fossils represent the juvenile and adult of the same species.
The Skeleton of the Baby Snake As Modelled from the Synchrotron Data
The skeleton of the baby snake Xiaophis myanmarensis.
Picture credit: Ming Bai (Chinese Academy of Sciences)
Xiaophis myanmarensis – A Remarkable Fossil
The discovery of this remarkable fossil, along with the piece of shed snake skin helps palaeontologists to build a picture of the evolution of snakes and how they spread following the break-up of the super-continents during the latter stages of the Mesozoic.
Dr Palci (Flinders University) and a co-author of the scientific paper published in the journal “Science Advances” commented:
“At 100 million years old, it dates back to the age of the dinosaurs, well before snakes started to differentiate into modern groups. This Asian fossil helps shed light on how primitive snakes dispersed from the southern to the northern continents. Although found in the Northern Hemisphere, it strongly resembles South American snakes that lived at the time.”
An Illustration of the Second Snake Specimen (Life Reconstruction)
The preserved skin of a second prehistoric snake has been found in amber from Myanmar.
Picture credit: Yi Liu
During the Jurassic, the region that we now know as Myanmar was joined to Antarctica, Australia, Africa and South America, forming the giant, southern super-continent of Gondwana. As the Mesozoic progressed so this landmass began to split apart, Myanmar separated from Gondwana and drifted north, eventually colliding with Asia.
This is the first baby snake fossil from the Mesozoic ever found and it, along with other remarkable specimens preserved in amber from Myanmar (burmite), are providing scientists with a unique window into the Late Cretaceous world.