A team of international scientists writing in the academic publication “The Journal of South American Earth Sciences”, have reported the discovery of the first pterosaur fossils known from Uruguay. The fossil material representing a fragment of jaw with associated teeth, is believed to represent a new species of Ctenochasmatidae pterosaur. Ctenochasmatids are geographically widespread with fossils reported from the United States, China, southern Germany, Argentina and England. The fossils ascribed to this family of short-tailed pterosaurs have a large temporal range, from the Late Jurassic transitioning through to the Early Cretaceous.
Views of the Fragmentary Fossil Material (Rostrum)
The first pterosaur fossils from Uruguay.
Picture credit: The Journal of South American Earth Sciences
Buck-Toothed Pterosaur
The fossil comes from the Tacuarembó Formation, which is believed to represent deposits laid down as the early Atlantic Ocean opened up. The strata largely consists of sediments deposited in a terrestrial, near-shore environment. The orientation of the tooth sockets and the preserved tooth base suggests that the conical teeth were pointed out sideways and forwards. This may have been an adaptation for capturing slippery prey such as small fish. This family of small pterosaurs exhibit a variety of different shaped mandibles, although fragmentary, the researchers have identified that the fossil jaw widens towards the tip (anterior portion), the shape of the jaw and its size corresponds to jaws of known ctenochasmatids, specifically the subfamily Gnathosaurinae.
Different Jaw Types within the Ctenochasmatidae
Ctenochasmatid mandibles.
Picture credit: Wellnhofer, Howse et al from Witton
The picture shows mandible variation within the Ctenochasmatidae (A) Ctenochasma elegans seen from below, (B) Plataleorhynchus streptorophodon as viewed from below and (C), the skull of Gnathosaurus subulatus (viewed from underneath). The dentition and the shape of the mandibles suggest adaptations for catching and consuming different types of prey.
Dating the Geological Formation Thanks to a Shark
The Tacuarembó Formation has proved very difficult to date, as the fossils found in the strata were not that easy to compare to fossils found in other rocks. Despite, an abundance of bone fragments representing a range of creatures, including theropod dinosaurs, the Tacuarembó Formation lacked helpful biostratigraphic indicator fossils to assist with relative dating. This changed with the discovery of numerous teeth and a single dorsal spine which was assigned to the Hybodont shark Priohybodus arambourgui.
Fossils of this primitive shark are known from the Arabian Peninsula as well as Africa and the strata associated with these fossils has permitted more accurate dating to occur. Thanks to this shark, the authors of this new paper can state that the pterosaur fossil material comes from a fossiliferous horizon no older than the Late Jurassic. As such, the Uruguayan pterosaur remains represent the oldest ctenochasmatid found in South America known to science.
Saurornitholestes from the South-eastern United States
Whilst in the course of writing the fact sheets for all the new dromaeosaurid models that are due to arrive when the “Beasts of the Mesozoic” stock comes in, team members have come across some fascinating information relating to Saurornitholestes langstoni. This member of the Dromaeosauridae, which was similar to Velociraptor, was originally described in 1978 from fossil material found in southern Alberta. Dromaeosaurids such as Saurornitholestes, or at least related species, may have roamed the south-east of the United States as well as the western USA and Canada.
A Single Tooth from Alabama (Saurornitholestine dromaeosaurids)
The isolated dromaeosaurid teeth with very different sized denticles (anterior and posterior).
Picture credit: David R. Schwimmer
Isolated Dromaeosaurid Dinosaur Teeth
Isolated teeth have been found in North and South Carolina and assigned to the Saurornitholestes genus, or at least described as having come from Saurornitholestine dromaeosaurids. The picture above shows a tooth assigned to Saurornitholestes langstoni that was found in Greene County (Alabama), from exposures representing the Upper Cretaceous (Mooreville Formation). The tooth measures about 4.6 mm long and it shows the distinctive serrations (denticles) associated with the Saurornitholestes genus.
The denticles on the posterior (back) edge of the teeth are much more prominent and larger than those denticles found on the anterior (front) edge of the tooth. This extreme disparity is regarded as a unique feature of Saurornitholestine dromaeosaurids.
Saurornitholestes
During the Late Cretaceous, North America was split into two landmasses by the Western Interior Seaway. To the west was Laramidia and to the east, the far larger landmass of Appalachia, although much more is known about the Cretaceous biota of Laramidia.
A far larger tooth, one that measures more than 20 mm in length was found in North Carolina. This tooth also showed the characteristic disparity in denticle size between the anterior and posterior carinae (the sharp edges of the teeth). This fossil find suggests that dromaeosaurids of different sizes roamed Appalachia during the Late Cretaceous.
The Beasts of the Mesozoic Saurornitholestes langstoni Figure
The Beasts of the Mesozoic Saurornitholestes langstoni “raptor” figure.
When it comes to the Saurornitholestes genus in particular, these types of characteristic teeth are known from numerous sites across North America and from rock formations that vary in age by millions of years. Either Saurornitholestes langstoni and Saurornitholestes sullivani, the two species currently assigned to this genus,were geographically and temporally widespread, or there are a lot more dromaeosaurid species, including quite large ones, if the North Carolina tooth is anything to go by, awaiting discovery.
Tiny Fossils Provide Clues to Earth’s Climate 500 Million Years Ago
A joint team of scientists from France and the UK, have plotted the temperature of our planet’s oceans over half a billion years ago using a combination of fossil data and computer-based climate models. Think of it as a sort of weather forecast from the Cambrian.
A Cambrian Climate Study
This newly published research suggests that the first hard-bodied animals diversified in warms seas, heated by a greenhouse world. The team’s findings help to expand our knowledge of the environment at the time of the Cambrian explosion, a period in Earth’s history that saw a huge increase in the number and type of marine animal forms.
Life in the Late Cambrian Period
Life in the Late Cambrian by Zdeněk Burian.
Picture credit: Zdeněk Burian
Writing in the academic journal “Science Advances”, the scientists, led by researchers from the University of Leicester, used climate models and the chemical analysis of tiny, shelly fossils preserved in limestone from Shropshire (central England), to calculate the sea temperature during a time of rapid diversity of animal life in the Palaeozoic.
From around 540 to 510 million years ago, the fossil record shows a marked change, as during this period of Earth’s history, virtually all of the animal phyla (including the Chordata – our phylum) appeared. The idea of a “Cambrian explosion” is a little misleading, the appearance of many new forms of complex animal life may have been gradual, but in terms of the fossil record, sites such as the famous Burgess Shale of British Columbia and Yunnan Province (southern China), have revealed extensive and varied marine ecosystems with large numbers of new types of animal being recorded in the strata.
Analysis of Some of the First Shelly Fossils
Scientists had thought that for much of the Cambrian, our planet was warmer that it is today with no polar ice caps present. A study of tiny 1 mm long fossils of some of the first animals to produce a hard, shelly exoskeleton has confirmed this hypothesis. Analysis of isotopes from the tiny shells in combination with the climate models show that at high latitudes (around 65 degrees south), sea temperatures were in excess of 20 degrees Celsius.
This might seem very warm, especially when you consider that this is an evaluation of sea temperatures at approximately 65 degrees south, today, travelling to that latitude would put you on the southernmost fringes of the Southern Ocean and close to Antarctica. However, the data generated is similar to more recent, better understood, greenhouse climates such as that of the Late Cretaceous.
Reflected Light Microscopy – Brachiopod Fossils Used in the Study
Reflected light microscope images of some of the brachiopod fossils (phosphatic microfossils), used in this study.
Picture credit: Leicester University
Analysing Isotopes
Co-author of the open access paper, PhD student Thomas Hearing (University of Leicester’s School of Geography, Geology and the Environment), explained:
“Because scientists cannot directly measure sea temperatures from half a billion years ago, they have to use proxy data, these are measurable quantities that respond in a predictable way to changing climate variables like temperature. In this study, we used oxygen isotope ratios, which is a commonly used palaeothermometer. We then used acid to extract fossils about 1 mm long from blocks of limestone from Shropshire, UK, dated to between 515 – 510 million years old. Careful examination of these tiny fossils revealed that some of them have exceptionally well-preserved shell chemistry which has not changed since they grew on the Cambrian sea floor.”
High Resolution Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM) Images of Brachiopod Fossils Used in the Study
Electron microscope images of some of the brachiopod fossils used in this study. Electron microscopy allows much higher resolution imaging of small structures than normal light microscopy.
Identifying Chemical Signatures in Cambrian Fossils
Dr Tom Harvey (University of Leicester) added:
“Many marine animals incorporate chemical traces of seawater into their shells as they grow. That chemical signature is often lost over geological time, so it’s remarkable that we can identify it in such ancient fossils.”
Analyses of the oxygen isotopes of these fossils suggested very warm temperatures for high latitude seas (~65 °S), probably between 20 °C to 25 °C. To see if these were feasible sea temperatures, the researchers carried out climate model simulations for the Cambrian. The climate model scenarios suggest that the Earth’s climate was in a “typical” greenhouse state, with temperatures similar to more recent and better understood greenhouse intervals known from the Mesozoic and the Cenozoic eras. Ultimately, this study will help to expand our knowledge of the ecosystem that existed during the Cambrian.
The Highly Fossiliferous Comley Limestones (Shropshire, UK)
A thin section slice through the trilobite-rich Comley Limestones (Shropshire, UK).
The curves and white wavy lines in the photograph (above), are preserved exoskeletons of numerous trilobites.
Thomas Hearing concluded:
“We hope that this approach can be used by other researchers to build up a clearer picture of ancient climates where conventional climate proxy data are not available.”
The research was carried out as an international collaboration involving scientists from the University of Leicester (UK), British Geological Survey (BGS; UK), and CEREGE (France).
Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the help of Leicester University in the compilation of this article.
As a very young boy, I remember eagerly striving to complete my Brooke Bond “Prehistoric Animals” card collection. This was a set of fifty cards to collect, given away free with packets of tea. One of the cards featured a pair of toothed, prehistoric birds, a large, reddish coloured Hesperornis which was being mobbed by a couple of tern-like birds, this was my first introduction to Ichthyornis. Perhaps, the first time that I realised that birds (at least primitive, toothed birds), lived alongside dinosaurs.
How wonderful to read this week that Ichthyornis, thanks to a pieced together three-dimensional skull, may be providing palaeontologists with fresh insights into avian evolution. The Hesperornis/Ichthyornis picture card may have been burned into my conscience long ago, but it is refreshing to think that this ancient bird may represent a pivotal moment in the transition from dinosaurs to modern-day birds and its significance has only just come to light. A team of international scientists have published a paper proposing that Ichthyornis may have had one of the first, true bird-like beaks.
The Brooke Bond Picture Card
Hesperornis catching a fish, with Ichthyornis in close attention.
Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur/Brooke Bond
Toothy Bird with the Beginnings of a Beak
Writing in the journal “Nature”, researchers report on the analysis of beautifully preserved three-dimensional Ichthyornis (I. dispar) fossil skull that is providing new evidence on the evolution of the avian head and how the skull and beaks of birds evolved from their dinosaurian ancestors.
A Three-Dimensional Image of Ichthyornis Skull Material Indicates the Tip of the Premaxillary Formed the First Beak
A computer generated image showing the life position of the fossil bones in the three-dimensional Ichthyornis skull.
Picture credit: Yale Office of Public Affairs and Communications
Ichthyornis dispar
Known from fragmentary fossils from Kansas and named back in 1872 by Yale University’s Othniel Charles Marsh, it seems fitting that this new study into one of the first toothed birds described, has been led by scientists from Yale University. Working in conjunction with colleagues from the University of Kansas, Fort Hays State University, Alabama Museum of Natural History and the McWane Science Centre (Alabama), the team report on new specimens with three-dimensional cranial remains, including one example of a complete skull and two previously overlooked cranial elements that were part of the original Yale specimen examined by Marsh.
Using CT scans and sophisticated computer modelling, individual skull and jaw bones were scanned and reproduced in three-dimensions. This allowed a complete skull to be constructed revealing new details about the transition from dinosaur skull to a more modern bird skull.
The Transition from Dinosaur Skull to Bird Skull
Yale University palaeontologist and lead author of the study Bhart-Anjan Bhullar commented:
“Right under our noses this whole time was an amazing, transitional bird. It has a modern-looking brain along with a remarkably dinosaurian jaw muscle configuration.”
Ichthyornis is part of the biota of the Western Interior Seaway, a shallow sea that split North America in two during the Late Cretaceous. It has been regarded as an early version of a tern or gull, but its size is unknown as the few fossils found represent individuals of different sizes, however, it probably had a wingspan of no more than sixty centimetres, making Ichthyornis slightly smaller than today’s Common Tern (Sterna hirundo), a bird which fills the same ecological niche as the Mesozoic Ichthyornis.
Using the Latest Research, a New Reconstruction of Ichthyornis dispar was Produced
A life reconstruction of Ichthyornis.
Picture credit: Yale Office of Public Affairs and Communications
Ichthyornis – The Evolution of a Beak
Having built a three-dimensional model of the skull and jaw bones, the researchers were able to note that the premaxillary bone in the upper jaw had become elongated and this, working in conjunction with a keratinous tip on the lower jaw formed the first “proto-beak”. Ichthyornis dispar shows scientists what the first type of bird beak looked like. This beak may have evolved as the function of the hands was increasingly limited as they were adapted to form a more effective wing.
The grasping hands of the maniraptoran dinosaurs were no longer able to grasp and manipulate objects so the jaws had to take on an additional function, secondary to their main function – dispatching and consuming prey.
The Beak of Ichthyornis
The beak of Ichthyornis evolving to replace grasping, functional hands and fingers.
Picture credit: Yale Office of Public Affairs and Communications
Although maniraptoran dinosaurs may not have been able to pronate their hands like us and they lacked an opposable thumb, as forelimbs and hands evolved into wings, so the jaws took over the function of the digits and manus.
Bhart-Anjan Bhullar stated:
“The first beak was a horn-covered pincer tip at the end of the jaw. The remainder of the jaw was filled with teeth. At its origin, the beak was a precision grasping mechanism that served as a surrogate hand as the hands transformed into wings.”
The research team conducted its analysis using CT-scan technology, combined with specimens from the Yale Peabody Museum of Natural History; the Sternberg Museum of Natural History in Hays, Kansas, the Alabama Museum of Natural History; the University of Kansas Biodiversity Institute and the Black Hills Institute of Geological Research (South Dakota).
Bird Beaks versus Bird-hipped Dinosaur Beaks
The modern bird beak is a unique organ amongst vertebrates, although notably most derived ornithischian (bird-hipped) dinosaurs possessed a beak, formed from the unique predentary bone in the lower jaw and a roughened, extension of the premaxilla (or the rostral in the case of ceratopsians), in the upper jaw, which allowed the attachment of a keratinous tip which in conjunction formed the beak-like structure – believed to be an adaptation to assist with cropping vegetation.
This study of Ichthyornis suggests that the first bird beak was not the long organ seen in modern birds, but a little pincer tip to grasp and manipulate objects.
A Chasmosaurine Ceratopsian with the Roughened Rostral and the Predentary Forming a Plant-cropping Beak
The PNSO Doyle the Triceratops model has an articulated jaw.
The picture (above) shows a ceratopsian figure from the PNSO model range.
Fresh Insight into the Evolution of Extant Bird Skulls
The scientists conclude that their study offers new insights into how modern birds’ skulls formed. Along with its transitional beak, Ichthyornis dispar had a brain similar to that seen in extant birds but a temporal region of the skull that was reminiscent of a dinosaur. This suggests that during the evolution of Aves, the brain transformed first, possibly to adapt to a volant (aerial) lifestyle, whilst the remainder of the skull retained the ancestral features associated with the Dinosauria.
Ichthyornis retained a large adductor chamber bounded at the top by substantial bony remnants of the ancestral reptilian upper temporal fenestra (hole in the skull). This combination of features indicates that important attributes of the avian brain and palate evolved before the reduction of jaw musculature and the full transformation of the beak.
The Beak of Ichthyornis Grasping a Mollusc
An illustration of an Ichthyornis holding a mollusc in its beak.
Picture credit: Michael Hanson/Bhart-Anjan Bhullar
I may never have completed my Brooke Bond card collection, but at least, thanks to this new Ichthyornis study, our understanding of the evolution of the beak in birds is more complete.
Evidence of Insect Mimicry and Camouflage in Burmese Amber
Researchers from the China Agricultural University, the Nanjing Institute of Geology and Palaeontology and the Chinese Academy of Sciences, have discovered a new species of Cretaceous lacewing preserved in 100-million-year-old Burmese amber (burmite). The scientists have identified two lacewing larvae that show adaptations for mimicking liverwort plants. Mimicry and camouflage is relatively commonplace in the natural world, but evidence of this within the fossil record is extremely rare.
Two views (Dorsal and Ventral) of a Preserved Lacewing Larva Camouflaged to Look Like a Liverwort
New green lacewing larva Phyllochrysa huangi in (A) dorsal view and (B) ventral view.
Picture credit: the Nanjing Institute of Geology and Palaeontology
Lacewings and Liverworts
Lacewings are insects which are characterised by their very fine, reticulated wings. They are globally widespread and something like 2,000 living species have been described to date.
As larvae and adults, they are voracious hunters and are popular with farmers and growers as they eat lots of pests, such as aphids. Fossils of these delicate insects are rare but specimens are known that date from the Jurassic. Liverworts are much older, they lack a vascular system and true roots tending to grow very close to the ground. Liverworts are thought to be similar to the very first land plants that evolved in the Silurian geological period.
Despite liverworts having existed since the Palaeozoic, mimicry between insects and liverworts is extremely rare in both modern and fossil ecosystems. This discovery, reported in the academic journal “Current Biology” represents the first record of liverwort mimicry by fossil insects and brings to light an evolutionary novelty, both in terms of morphological specialisation as well as plant-insect interaction.
Lacewing Larvae and Liverworts Preserved in Amber
New green lacewing larva and potential model plants from Burmese amber. (B, E, G are larvae, the others are liverworts)
Picture credit: the Nanjing Institute of Geology and Palaeontology
Camouflaged to Look Like Liverworts
The larvae have broad flanges on their abdomen and thorax that resemble the fleshy, ribbon-like fronds of liverworts. The insect which has been named Phyllochrysa huangi, is the only known species of lacewing with distinctive foliate lobes on the larval body. These newly described insects are the first evidence of direct mimicry in lacewing larvae. This camouflage may have helped the vulnerable larvae to avoid detection by predators, or they might have used this body bauplan to help ambush potential prey.
Two Phyllochrysa huangi Larvae Hide Out Amongst the Liverworts
A life reconstruction of two Phyllochrysa huangi hiding amongst liverworts. The larvae are highlighted by red arrows.
Picture credit: Yang Dinghua
The researchers conclude that these fossils preserved in amber demonstrate a hitherto unknown life-history strategy amongst these types of insect, a strategy that apparently evolved from a camouflaging ancestor but did not persist into modern times with this lineage.
A Hot and Humid Cretaceous Jungle
The amber from Burma (Myanmar) has provided palaeontologists with an astonishing insight into life in a Cretaceous tropical rainforest. Numerous types of invertebrate have been named, including damselflies, spiders and blood-sucking ticks that may have fed on the blood of dinosaurs. The remains of larger creatures have been found preserved in amber too, including the feathered tail of a dinosaur and a baby enantiornithine bird.
The globally widespread extant liverworts consist of over 9,000 named species. Although, like the lacewings, their fossil record is very poor, it seems likely that they began to become much more diverse during the Cretaceous as the rapidly evolving angiosperm trees provided new habitats for them. Just like their modern counterparts, Cretaceous liverworts grew on the leaves and bark of trees as well as on other plant surfaces. It is logical to assume that the camouflaged lacewing larvae also probably lived on trees which were densely covered by liverworts, with the lacewing’s liverwort mimicry aiding their survival.
Ancient Cetaceans – Frankfurt Natural History Museum
There are some very impressive prehistoric whale exhibits in the ancient whales gallery at the Frankfurt Natural History Museum (Frankfurt, Germany). The Frankfurt Museum, also known as the Senckenberg Museum, houses one of the largest natural history collections in the whole of western Europe. The extensive galleries highlight biodiversity and tell the story of the evolution of life on Earth. One of the highlights of the entire collection is the substantial cetacean gallery that includes a number of mounted exhibits of ancient prehistoric whales.
The Ancient Whales Gallery (Senckenberg Museum)
The magnificent ancient whales gallery at the Frankfurt Natural History Museum (Germany). Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.
Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur
Basilosaurus on Display at the Senckenberg Museum
A team member from Everything Dinosaur spotted a glass case that contained the fossil skull and jaws of the Late Eocene whale Basilosaurus, fossils of which are known from New Zealand, North Africa, the United States and Europe. This early toothed whale was an apex predator, reaching lengths in excess of twenty metres and perhaps weighing more than 10,000 kilograms.
Basilosaurus was popularised after it appeared in the BBC television series “Walking with Beasts”, a sequel to the famous “Walking with Dinosaurs” television series that was first aired in 1999. Episode two of “Walking with Beasts” entitled “Whale Killer” told the story of a pregnant Basilosaurus and her search for enough food to sustain herself and her unborn calf as the world entered a period of climate change that would lead to a significant extinction event.
An Illustration of Basilosaurus
An illustration of Basilosaurus. A Basilosaurus scale drawing.Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.
Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur
The Basilosaurus Prehistoric Animal Figure
The image (above) shows the PNSO scientific art Basilosaurus figure. This spectacular model has earned praise from dinosaur fans and model collectors.
Miocene Fossil Treasure Trove at Californian Dam Site
Construction workers building a new dam on the Calaveras reservoir in California have uncovered a treasure trove of more than 1,500 fossils that depict marine life in the Miocene Epoch. The fossils include numerous whale skulls, around twenty in total, University of California Berkeley scientists supervising the preservation of the 20 to 15 million-year-old specimens are confident that the material found to date represents at least one new species of Baleen whale.
Miocene Fossil Treasure Trove
The large Calaveras reservoir lies to the north-east of the city of San Jose in the “Golden State”, the original dam was constructed in 1925, but concerns over the risk of earthquakes has led to the commencement of a second dam several hundred metres downstream. The first fossils were found in 2013 and brought to the attention of the University.
The fossilised remains include whales, sharks, such as Megalodon teeth, ancient seals, other vertebrates and a wealth of invertebrate fossils including gastropods, bivalves and crustaceans. In addition, the distinctive fossil teeth of a Desmostylus have been found. The Desmostylians are an extinct Order of hippo-like, prehistoric mammals that are distantly related to today’s sea cows.
Part of the Skull of an Ancient Baleen Whale from the Calaveras Reservoir Site
Fossil skull and jaw material representing a type of baleen whale from the dam site.
Picture Credit: University of California Berkeley/Sara Yogi
A Miocene Coastal Palaeofauna
The discovery of preserved palm fronds and pine cones in the marine sediments suggest that the coastline was close by. Desmostylus is believed to have favoured freshwater or estuarine environments, the Desmostylus fossil teeth found at the construction site adds further weight to the idea that the strata were laid down in shallow water close to land.
Commenting on the significance of the fossils, Cristina Robins, a senior scientist at the Museum of Palaeontology (University of California, Berkeley) and the person responsible for cataloguing all the fossil finds stated:
“Fossils are found all the time in the Bay Area, but the concentration of unique and varied specimens is what makes this special.”
Numerous Invertebrate Fossils Have Been Found
Examples of shell fossils from the Calaveras Dam site.
Picture Credit: University of California Berkeley/Sara Yogi
Providing Public Access to an Important Fossil Collection
University of California Berkeley laboratory staff are being assisted by graduate and undergraduate students. The work of cleaning, identifying and labelling all the fossils is quite laborious, but eventually, the scientists hope to make all the fossil material digitally available via the University’s website.
A spokesperson from Everything Dinosaur commented:
“It is very likely that a number of new species might be identified from this fossil deposit. This collection is helping palaeontologists to piece together an ancient environment, a lush tropical coastal ecosystem dominated by large, prehistoric mammals with an exotic marine fauna consisting of several different types of cetacean, some of which may have the prey of the giant shark Megalodon”.
So Many Fossils Have Been Found that an Entire Research Laboratory has been Taken Over
The extensive fossil collection from the Calaveras Dam site.
Picture Credit: University of California Berkeley/Sara Yogi
Ironically, the word “Calaveras” is Spanish for skulls, considering the amount of whale skull material found at the site, this is a very appropriate name for the dam and the reservoir.
Research led by American Museum of Natural History scientists has provided a fresh perspective on a shark that might have been the “Jaws” of the Carboniferous. The Carboniferous shark, Carcharopsis wortheni was first scientifically described in the mid-19th century and was previously known only from its characteristic serrated teeth and fragments of jaw. A fossilised brain case identified as C.wortheni was excavated in 2007 from Upper Mississippian aged rocks in Arkansas (Fayetteville Shale). The fossil was found by Royal Mapes, a retired Ohio University professor and a research associate at the Museum. State-of-the-art imaging techniques were used to provide a unique insight into this important apex predator that lived some 320 million years ago.
The Fossil Cranium (Brain Case) of Carcharopsis wortheni
The brain case of Carcharopsis wortheni. A Carboniferous shark study.
Picture credit: American Museum of Natural History/Allison Bronson
Insight into Shark Evolution
The shark lived at a critical point in the evolutionary history of our planet, part of a marine fauna that survived the end Devonian mass extinction event which decimated vertebrate species. This ancient Palaeozoic shark, was originally described in 1843 based on its distinctive serrated teeth, a feature that is common in extant sharks such as the formidable Great White (Carcharodon carcharias), an apex marine predator with a frightening reputation, thanks in the main to the film “Jaws” directed by Steven Spielberg, which was based on Peter Benchley’s book. However, serrated teeth are rarely found in Palaeozoic sharks.
A CT Scan Showing the Unique Serrations on a Tooth from Carcharopsis (C. wortheni)
Carcharopsis fossil tooth. Scale bar = 1 mm.
Picture credit: American Museum of Natural History/Allison Bronson
The picture above shows a computer tomography generated image of a Carcharopsis tooth, measuring around five millimetres in length. The blue lines are canals identified within the tooth.
Commenting on the fossil, lead author of the study Allison Bronson, a PhD student at the American Museum of Natural History stated:
“They [the teeth] look a little like what you’d see in a Great White, but are 320 million years old and with different enamel. This is really early to see serrated teeth.”
Carboniferous Shark Fossil Study
Royal Mapes donated the brain case specimen to the New York-based natural history museum, along with a remarkable 540,000 other fossils. Mapes co-authored the Carcharopsis study, which has been published in the journal “Papers in Palaeontology”, American Museum of Natural History curator John Maisey also contributed to the paper.
The scientists used high-resolution computed tomography (CT) imaging to examine the cranium, a tooth, and an isolated portion of a tooth base. Using the scans, they were able to reconstruct the internal canals of the teeth for the first time and found that these are similar to the canals found in today’s sharks.
The arrangement of the shark’s blood vessels—also revealed through CT scans—suggests that Carcharopsis was probably closely related to the group of ancient cartilaginous fish from which today’s sharks and rays evolved. However, more complete fossils are needed to firmly position it in the tree of life.
Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the help of the American Museum of Natural History in the compilation of this article.
Under the Noses of Dinosaurs, a New Species of Early Cretaceous Amphibian is Described
A small, fragmentary fossil found in an outcrop of the Kuwajima Formation, in western Central Japan has been identified as a new species of albanerpetontid amphibian. This tiny animal, measuring just six centimetres in length inhabited a wide floodplain, that was crossed by meandering rivers in a humid environment some 130 million years ago. The fossils represent the oldest example of this type of tetrapod found in Asia, they predate the only other specimens known from Asia (Uzbekistan), by tens of millions of years.
An Early Cretaceous Amphibian
A Life Reconstruction of the Little Albanerpetontid Amphibian (S. isajii)
An illustration of Shirerpeton – an Early Cretaceous amphibian.
Picture credit: Takumi Yamamoto
The Ancient Albanerpetontidae Family
Superficially resembling modern-day Salamanders, these ancient amphibians are only distantly related to their modern counterparts. They evolved in the Middle Jurassic and persisted until very recently, finally becoming extinct during the Pleistocene Epoch. Several genera are known and they are characterised by their unique skulls and the presence of bony scales on their skin. The tiny specimen consists of a partial skull, vertebrae and elements from a hind limb, a total of forty-three bones. The only Asian examples of this clade of amphibian have been found in Uzbekistan. These fossils date from the very end of the Cretaceous, so the Japanese specimen is some sixty million years older.
High resolution X-ray computed microtomography was used to identify the shape of the bones which remain partially buried in the part-prepared fossil.
The Rock Containing the Partially Exposed Fossil Bones Along with a Computer Image Tracing the Outline of the Individual Bones
A new Early Cretaceous amphibian from Japan (Shirerpeton).
Picture credit: The Education Board of the city of Hakusan, (Ishikawa Prefecture, Japan)
A Tiny Fossil
The picture (above) shows the holotype fossil of the new albanerpetontid amphibian, which has been named Shirerpeton isajii. Image (A) shows the fossils in the 2.5 by 1.5 cm square slab of rock, whilst image (B), is a digital photograph with various bones from the skull highlighted. Abbreviations: Br, braincase elements; Fr, frontal; L.La, left lacrimal; L.Mx, left maxilla; L.N, left nasal; L.Pa, left parietal; LPf, left prefrontal; L.Sm, left septomaxilla; L.Sq, left squamosal; R.La, right lacrimal; R.Pa, right parietal; R.Pf, right prefrontal; R.Sq, right squamosal; ?, unidentified element. Scale bars in both images = 5 mm.
Writing in the open-access academic journal PLOS One, the researchers, Susan Evans, a professor of vertebrate morphology and palaeontology (University College London) and Ryoko Matsumoto, a curator with the Kanagawa Prefectural Museum of Natural History were able to identify the specimen as a member of the Albanerpetontidae from the shape of the lower jaw. The distinctive frontal bone of the skull, along with several other identified autapomorphies (unique traits), enabled the scientists to erect a new species.
Shirerpeton isajii
The scientists named the species in honour of Shinji Isaji, the head of the Tetori Group fossil investigation commission, a body under the Hakusan city government in charge of studying the Kuwajima fossil location where the fossil was found.
A spokesperson from Everything Dinosaur commented:
“There are about twenty of these amphibians known in the fossil record, currently assigned to five genera. They were globally widespread during the Mesozoic, but this is the first time an albanerpetontid has been recorded from East Asia. Their fragmentary record makes understanding their evolution and their phylogeny very difficult, scientists are not even sure how closely related these ancient lissamphibians are to extant amphibians.”
The spokesperson continued:
“Small animals like Shirerpeton are just as important as larger animals like dinosaurs when it comes to considering ancient environments and habitats. In fact, this amphibian is probably more important than larger vertebrates in helping scientists to understand the localised climate in the Barremian of Japan.”
An analysis of a 200 million-year-old bite-mark has provided scientists with a detailed picture of a dinosaur’s life. The bite-mark, preserved on the fossilised rib of a Lufengosaurus (L. huenei) may also provide a clue to how this member of the Sauropodomorpha met its end. The specimen preserves evidence of an attack on a plant-eating dinosaur, probably from a theropod and although the attack initially was not fatal, the resulting infection that occurred in the bone may have contributed to the unfortunate dinosaur’s death.
A Life Reconstruction of the Lufengosaurus Showing the Bitemark
A life reconstruction of L. huenei in its natural environment and demonstrating the bite wound affecting the shoulder of the herbivorous dinosaur.
Picture credit: Zongda Zhang
Studying Lufengosaurus
Employing an advanced X-ray technique, an international team of scientists from the UK, China, the United States and South Africa, have published evidence for an unsuccessful attack on a Jurassic dinosaur, a member of the Suborder Sauropodomorpha from China known as Lufengosaurus (L. huenei). Everything Dinosaur was contacted by one of the authors of the scientific paper, published in the academic journal “Nature Scientific Reports”, a PNSO Lufengosaurus replica was purchased so that the model could be used to help explain the pathology and inferred animal behaviour from the scientific research.
The study provides a detailed report of the first recognised case of an abscess in a long-necked dinosaur from the Lower Jurassic of China, (Yunnan Province), which was caused by infection brought on from the bite of a large predatory dinosaur. The infection may have weakened the animal, ultimately resulting in its death.
Scientist Lida Xing Holding the Damaged Rib Bone
The pathological fossilised rib of Lufengosaurus huenei.
Picture credit: Lida Xing
Micro-computed X-ray Tomography
The pathology, was discovered in the skeleton of a L. huenei, which is part of the vertebrate fossil collection at the Yuxi Museum (Yunnan Province). The fossil rib bone was subjected to micro-computed x-ray tomography (micro-CT). This permits high-resolution slices and three-dimensional images to be built up of internal structures of bone without damaging the fossil material.
It is a non-destructive research technique. As well as providing detailed evidence of interactions between big, herbivorous dinosaurs and carnivorous theropods, the successful identification of this abscess using this technique could point to a new understanding of where certain species lived, and the impact of the diseases that they suffered from.
Studying Fossil Rib Pathology
Commenting on the significance of the research, one of the authors of the scientific paper, Dr Patrick Randolph-Quinney (University of Central Lancashire in the UK and the University of the Witwatersrand in South Africa), stated:
“We were able to use micro-CT to look deep inside the structure of the rib and visualise the precise changes that bacterial infection had caused, as well as to see the region of bone that had been bitten out of the rib. What micro-CT is allowing us to do is understand processes such as trauma and infection in the fossil record at the cellular level, as well as looking at the whole bone.”
Dr Randolph-Quinney continued:
“This gives us advantages over traditional histology – which slices up bone for magnification under a microscope – in that it doesn’t require us to damage precious fossils and it also allows us to build 3-D reconstructions of the whole region of disease. In this case, this has allowed us to model and study the whole wound track, not just a single portion of it.”
Images of the Rib Pathology
A 3-D and 3-D slice reconstruction of the Lufengosaurus rib pathology.
Picture credit: Patrick Randolph-Quinney (University of Central Lancashire)
The picture (above), shows a 3-D and 3-D slice reconstruction of the Lufengosaurus rib pathology. Micro-computed tomography allowed the scientists to produce surface renderings of the fossil in 3-D (top row) and 2-D X-ray slices through the rib (bottom row). These images show areas of cellular reorganisation, bone destruction and bone formation indicative of ostemyelitis (bone infection).
Lufengosaurus (L. huenei)
Lufengosaurus grew to about six metres in length. It is estimated to have weighed around two tonnes. More than two dozen specimens of this prosauropod have been discovered to date, adults as well as fossil material from juveniles. All the fossils ascribed to this genus have been discovered in the Lufeng Formation of south-western China (Yunnan Province). Yang Zhongjian, known in western literature as Chung Chien Young, formally named and described Lufengosaurus in 1941. Lufengosaurus was the first dinosaur from China to have been discovered, studied and displayed by Chinese scientists.
The PNSO Lufengosaurus Dinosaur Model Supplied to the Researchers by Everything Dinosaur
The PNSO Lufengosaurus dinosaur model.
Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur
The image (above) shows a PNSO Lufengosaurus dinosaur model.
Lead author of the study, Dr Lida Xing (China University of Geosciences) added:
“This case is really exciting as it gives us evidence of interactions between large plant-eating dinosaur species and one of the large aggressive predators preying on them at that time. Using the latest X-ray imaging we were able to track the changes in the bone caused by an infected bite on the Lufengosaurus, probably from a big carnivorous dinosaur. We don’t just have evidence of disease but of behaviour between animals – between predator and prey at this deep period in prehistory.”
An International Team of Researchers
This study was carried out by researchers at the University of Central Lancashire (UCLan), China University of Geosciences, the University of the Witwatersrand in South Africa, the Carnegie Museum of Natural History in the USA, the State Key Laboratory of Genetic Resources and Evolution, Kunming Institute of Zoology, and the Yuxi Museum, Yunnan, China.
The team were able to identify an infection in the bone called osteomyelitis which produces a pus-filled abscess inside the bone. This is only the second time that a case of osteomyelitis has been recorded in the Sauropodomorpha, the other instance came from a giant titanosaur from Argentina, the Lufengosaurus example pre-dates the Argentinian example by tens of millions of years. It is the earliest recorded case of a bony abscess caused by osteomyelitis disease in the fossil record.
Views of the Damaged Lufengosaurus Rib Bone
The pathological fossil rib (two views).
Picture credit: Lida Xing
Clinical Science and Palaeontology
Hao Ran from the Kunming Institute of Zoology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, commented:
“This is a great example of how the clinical sciences and the science of palaeontology are working together with fossils from the Chinese fossil record. Together with international collaborators we are able to advance our understanding of diseases in both the past and the present. We don’t know which predator caused the bite, but we do have a smoking gun of the attack with the bite wound it left.”
The scientific paper: “Possible Bite-induced Abscess and Osteomyelitis in Lufengosaurus (Dinosauria: Sauropodomorph) from the Lower Jurassic of the Yimen Basin, China” by Lida Xing, Bruce M. Rothschild, Patrick S. Randolph-Quinney, Yi Wang, Alexander H. Parkinson and Hao Ran published in Nature Scientific Reports.