Tiny Partial Shoulder Girdle Bone Fills 15 Million-year Fossil Gap
A tiny, partial bone from the left shoulder girdle of an ancient bird discovered in Utah, has helped fill a gap in the fossil record of the early relatives of chickens and turkeys (Galliformes). In addition, the fossil specimen named UMNH.VP.30891, from the Eocene Uinta Formation shares a number of anatomical traits with fossils found in Uzbekistan and Namibia which suggests the ancestors of chickens, turkeys, quail, pheasants and guineafowl, were widespread.
A Tiny Bone from a Bird
This fossil bird has been assigned to the Paraortygidae, an extinct group of birds that were the ancestors of modern game birds. The tiny fossil fits in a nearly 15-million-year gap in the fossil record of the galliform lineage in North America.
The Tiny Fossil Bone from the Left Shoulder Girdle of an Unnamed Member of the Paraortygidae
The coracoid of the newly described Uintan paraortygid.
Picture credit: Patricia Holroyd (University of California)
Bird Fossil from Utah
Writing in the academic journal Diversity, the researchers, which included scientists from the Chinese Academy of Sciences along with colleagues from Midwestern University (Arizona) and the Museum of Paleontology (University of California), describe the tiny fossil bone which was found in 44-million-year-old fluvial deposits in north-eastern Utah.
Commenting on the importance of this tiny fossil, which measures less than one centimetre in length, one of the co-authors of the paper, Dr Beth Townsend (Midwestern University), stated:
“The new Uinta bird fills not only a time gap, but also helps us better understand the animal community at this time. The Uinta Basin is important for understanding ecosystems during times of global warm temperatures, when forests, primates and early horses were spread across an area that is now desert.”
A Life Reconstruction of the Uinta Bird
Newly described Uintan paraortygid life reconstruction.
Picture credit: Thomas Stidham (Chinese Academy of Sciences)
Fossil Coracoid Representing the “Uintan paraortygid”
The fossil coracoid represents a new species, but it has yet to be named. It has been informally termed the “Uintan paraortygid”. This quail-sized bird from Utah is the oldest known member of the Paraortygidae. It is approximately the same body size and shape of other early paraortygids and given their widespread distribution in the fossil record (Namibia, Uzbekistan and the United States), it suggests that these little birds were confident, capable fliers. In addition, it seems likely that these birds had a flexible biology or diet that allowed them to occupy a diversity of habitats from forests and coasts to semi-arid savannahs.
The scientific paper: “Evidence for Wide Dispersal in a Stem Galliform Clade from a New Small-sized Middle Eocene Pangalliform (Aves: Paraortygidae) from the Uinta Basin of Utah (USA)” by Thomas A. Stidham, K. E. Beth Townsend, and Patricia A. Holroyd published in Diversity.
A Review of “Fossil Collecting on the South Dorset Coast”
The revered UNESCO World Heritage Site known as the “Jurassic Coast” has far more to offer fossil enthusiasts than just the congested beaches associated with Lyme Regis and Charmouth. Head east towards Weymouth, travelling forward in deep geological time through the Jurassic and into the Cretaceous and the visitor to such places as Redcliffe Point, Bowleaze Cove and West Weare Cliff can be rewarded with some fantastic fossil discoveries. In addition, intrepid explorers can enjoy some of the most spectacular and picturesque parts of the coast of southern England.
Providing a guide to this beautiful part of the world, is a new book written by dedicated fossil collectors Steve Snowball and Craig Chivers. Entitled “A Guide to Fossil Collecting on the South Dorset Coast”, this is one book that does exactly what it claims to do in the title and what an excellent read it is too!
Fossil Hunting Guide with a Focus on the South Dorset Coast
Fossil Collecting on the South Dorset Coast by Steve Snowball and Craig Chivers. The front cover features a theropod dinosaur, a pliosaur Pliosaurus kevani and an example of an ammonite fossil.Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.
Aimed at amateur fossil collectors as well as general visitors to the Dorset coast, this, the second volume in the series, takes the reader eastwards along the Dorset coast heading in the direction of Weymouth, the Isle of Portland and beyond. The western part of the Dorset coast, covered in the first book, dealt with the fossils that can be found in the marine deposits associated with Lyme Regis, Seatown and the coastline eastwards towards Burton Bradstock.
In this guide, the reader is given the opportunity to explore different ancient environments as the rocks along the shoreline provide clues to ancient lagoons, dinosaur dominated floodplains as well as ancient seas populated by ammonites, corals, dense beds of oysters and exotic sea urchins.
An Example of a Sea Urchin (Holaster spp.) from the Cretaceous Upper Greensand Exposures of Ringstead Bay
A beautifully preserved sea urchin (Holaster spp.) from the Cretaceous Upper Greensand of Ringstead Bay.
Picture credit: Snowball and Chivers
Fossil Collecting on the “Jurassic Coast”
Following a general introduction section, outlining the importance of the “Jurassic Coast”, the reader is provided with information regarding the fossil collecting code and then schooled in the geology of the region. The brief guide to the geology and landscapes of south Dorset then leads onto a series of chapters that provide details on excursions that can be undertaken to prospect for fossils. Each location is beautifully illustrated with stunning photographs of the fossils that can be found and the ancient prehistoric landscapes are brought to life by Andreas Kurpisz, from a shallow sea with an oyster reef to a herd of brachiosaurs wandering across what would eventually become part of the Purbeck Formation.
A View of Bowleaze Cove from Redcliff Point
The rugged and beautiful Bowleaze Cove (south Dorset). The book provides details of numerous excursions to some of the more secluded areas of the “Jurassic Coast”.
Picture credit: Snowball and Chivers
Detailed Information About Fossil Collecting on the Isle of Portland is Provided
West Weare Cliff at the end of Chesil Beach in Dorset. The Kimmeridge Clay exposures can provide a wealth of fossils including ichthyosaur and plesiosaur remains.
Picture credit: Snowball and Chivers
“A Guide to Fossil Collecting on the South Dorset Coast” provides a comprehensive overview on fossil collecting opportunities along the coast of southern Dorset, it is essential reading for fossil collectors and for those wishing to explore eastwards along the “Jurassic Coast” from Burton Bradstock.
Published by Siri Scientific Press, “A Guide to Fossil Collecting on the South Dorset Coast” can be found here: Purchase the Book Here.
Cartilage, Proteins, Potential DNA Preserved in Juvenile Duck-billed Dinosaur
Whisper it quietly, but the debate about how long organic materials such as DNA can remain preserved with fossils without complete destruction and decay is about to be reignited. An international team of researchers have identified possible evidence of fossilised cell nuclei, chromosomes with indications of DNA within the preserved, calcified cartilage of a baby duck-billed dinosaur that roamed Montana around 75 million years ago.
This discovery does not take us one step nearer to a “Jurassic Park” scenario, but it does challenge current thinking about how long delicate organic material such as DNA can persist.
A View of the Skull Bone (Supraoccipital) of the Juvenile Hypacrosaurus
An isolated supraoccipital (So) of Hypacrosaurus in dorsal view. Note the scale bar equals 2 cm.
Picture credit: A. Bailleul et al (National Science Review)
Dinosaur DNA
Writing in the journal “National Science Review”, researchers from the Institute of Vertebrate Palaeontology and Palaeoanthropology (Chinese Academy of Sciences), report their findings in collaboration with Mary Schweitzer of North Carolina State University, a pioneer in dinosaur soft tissue research.
The fossil material was collected in 1988 by American palaeontologist Jack (John) Horner. It heralds from the Two Medicine Formation (Campanian faunal stage of the Late Cretaceous), in north-western Montana. The fossilised bone comes from a genus of the lambeosaurine hadrosaur Hypacrosaurus (H. stebingeri).
The scientists conducted a microscopic analysis of fragmentary skull bones (supraoccipital bone – located towards the back of the skull), associated with very young animals (skull length about 20 cm and total body length less than 2 metres). Corresponding author of the scientific paper, Alida Bailleul (Institute of Vertebrate Palaeontology and Palaeoanthropology), noticed a handful of beautifully preserved cell-like structures within the calcified cartilage on the edges of the skull bone. Two cartilage cells were still linked together by an intercellular bridge, morphologically consistent with the end of cell division.
Hypacrosaurus DNA Study
Caudal view of a juvenile emu skull (∼8–10 months old) showing the So and exoccipitals (Exo) in articulation. (F, G) Ground section (stained with Toluidine blue) of calcified cartilage from this emu skull showing cell doublets (pink arrows) with remnants of nuclei (white arrows) and others without intracellular content (green arrow).
Picture credit: A. Bailleul et al (National Science Review)
Dark Elongated Structures Within the Cells
Inside the cells, dark material resembling the cell nucleus was identified. One cartilage cell preserved dark, elongated thread-like structures morphologically consistent with chromosomes.
Bailleul and Schweitzer, in collaboration with Zheng Wenxia (North Carolina State University), then set out to determine whether original molecules were also preserved in the dinosaur cartilage. The researchers performed immunological and histochemical analyses on the skull of another nestling Hypacrosaurus from the same nesting ground. The immunological test supports the presence of remnants of original cartilaginous proteins in this dinosaur.
The researchers also isolated individual Hypacrosaurusstebingeri cartilage cells and applied two DNA stains, DAPI and PI. These bind specifically to DNA fragments in extant material and some of the isolated dinosaur cells showed internal, positive binding in the same pattern seen in modern cells. In essence, the fragments reacted positively to the staining suggesting some original dinosaur DNA may be preserved.
Commenting on the significance of this study, Alida Bailleul stated:
“These new, exciting results add to growing evidence that cells and some of their biomolecules can persist for a long time. They suggest DNA can be preserved for tens of millions of years and we hope this study will encourage scientists working on ancient DNA to push current limits and use new methodology in order to reveal all the unknown molecular secrets that ancient tissues have.”
Can DNA Survive for Millions of Years?
This research is likely to court controversy. The possibility that DNA can survive for seventy-five million years is not widely accepted by the scientific community. It is generally believed that the half-life of DNA is around five hundred years and that it does not persist in any form after several hundred thousand years.
For example, in 2013, Everything Dinosaur reported upon the discovery of a DNA sequence preserved in the fossil leg bone of an ancient horse that roamed Canada around 700,000 years ago. To read more about this research: Ancient Fossil Helps to Decode Horse Evolution.
If these results can be replicated and the data verified, then this would indicate that DNA, in some form, although highly degraded, might persist in the fossil record for tens of millions of years. It might be possible to recover and sequence other samples of DNA from long extinct creatures.
A Life Reconstruction of the Hypacrosaurus stebingeri Nursery
A life reconstruction of the Hypacrosaurus nesting site. A young dinosaur has died and is lying in a pool, whilst the mother investigates the corpse.
Picture credit: Michael Rothman/Science China Press
No “Jurassic Park”
However, this study does not mean that a dinosaur-themed safari park as depicted in the “Jurassic Park” franchise is just around the corner.
Bailleul explained:
“Here we have probably fossilised remnants, very minute amounts of fossilised dinosaur DNA, but that is a hypothesis at this stage. The original dinosaur DNA might be transformed chemically during fossilisation. No one really understands what happens to DNA in material so old, but our study encourages more research in ancient DNA to understand the processes of DNA fossilisation. Our data suggest some DNA may still be preserved in these dinosaur cells, but it will never be possible to recreate a dinosaur. Once a species goes extinct, it’s extinct forever.”
The research team conclude that the identification of chemical markers of DNA in Hypacrosaurus suggest DNA may preserve much longer than originally proposed. Even though it is clear that contamination does exist in fossil material and complicates identifications of original organic molecules, it can be accounted for with proper controls.
This research does not suggest that dinosaurs can be resurrected and brought back from extinction, but this study might represent a significant landmark in how ancient DNA could be identified and used to trace the evolution of life.
Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the assistance of a media release from North Carolina State University in the compilation of this article.
The scientific paper: “Evidence of proteins, chromosomes and chemical markers of DNA in exceptionally preserved dinosaur cartilage” by Alida M Bailleul, Wenxia Zheng, John R Horner, Brian K Hall, Casey M Holliday and Mary H Schweitzer published in National Science Review.
In celebration of St David’s Day (St David being the patron saint of Wales, a country with a red dragon on its national flag), Everything Dinosaur team members explored their huge weblog database to see how many of our thousands of articles mention the word “dragon”, a term regarded by many as synonymous with the Dinosauria.
To our surprise, we discovered 155 articles that are associated with “dragon”. The number of posts has increased recently with the naming of several new, Chinese dinosaur discoveries which tend to use the word “long” rather than “saurus” in their scientific name. The term “long” means dragon in Chinese, a suffix frequently used to name Chinese dinosaurs whereas the Greek term “saurus” is preferred in the West.
Dragons and the Dinosauria
For example, earlier this year we put together a blog post about the newly named microraptorine Wulong bohaiensis, the genus name translates as “dancing dragon”, a reference to the posture of the preserved specimen.
A Little Dragon for St David’s Day
The beautifully preserved and almost complete W. bohaiensis fossil specimen. The genus name translates from the Chinese as “dancing dragon” – a reference to the preserved posture of the fossil specimen. A red dragon is a heraldic symbol used on the national flag of Wales.
Picture credit: Ashley W. Poust (University of California)
Another reason why the Everything Dinosaur blog may have a lot of references to dragons is that back in the autumn of 2019, the eagerly awaited Rebor GrabNGo 1:6 scale Komodo dragon replica came into stock. This was the first model in the Rebor GrabNGo line and the first commercial model of an extant (not extinct) animal that Rebor had produced. Measuring nearly half a metre in length, this super-sized replica of a super-sized lizard earned rave reviews from model collectors.
Rebor Komodo Dragon (1:6 Scale Replica)
Komodo dragon or Megalania? You decide. Many collectors used the Komodo dragon replica to represent the extinct Australian Megalania.Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.
This popular Rebor figure not only occupies space on our blog, we get lots of emails about this model too. For instance, an email was received last week from a model maker who wanted to use this figure in a diorama. Everything Dinosaur was contacted after the purchase was made and we were asked for our advice on how best to depict the figure and what sort of prey items were suitable for including in the intended diorama.
To purchase the Rebor Komodo dragon and the rest of the replicas in the Rebor range: Rebor Dinosaurs and Models.
With the very strong possibility of more Chinese dinosaurs being scientifically described in 2020 and with the ever increasing popularity of Rebor models, team members at Everything Dinosaur are likely to be writing about “dragons” for some time to come.
Thanks to a dedicated geologist and the careful conservation of his materials and notes a sixty-six-year-old mystery about dinosaur footprints on a cave ceiling in Queensland (Australia), has been solved. Palaeontologist Dr Anthony Romilio (University of Queensland), was able to decipher and interpret a series of dinosaur trackways preserved in Lower Jurassic strata, now exposed on a cave ceiling with the help of notes, photographs and casts of the prints stored in a cupboard under the stairs of a house in Sydney.
Dinosaur Footprints on the Ceiling
The Dinosaur Tracks from the Cave Ceiling (Insert Shows Estimated Size of Track Makers)
Dinosaur tracks from the Mount Morgan site, with (insert), a line drawing showing the estimated size of the two track makers. The photograph is circa 1954.
Picture credit: Historical Biology
Dr Romilio, of the School of Chemistry and Molecular Sciences (University of Queensland) explained:
“The town of Mount Morgan near Rockhampton has hundreds of fossil footprints and has the highest dinosaur track diversity for the entire eastern half of Australia. Earlier examinations of the ceiling footprints suggested some very curious dinosaur behaviour; that a carnivorous theropod walked on all four legs.”
There have been hundreds of dinosaur tracks reported from the so-called “fireclay caverns” in Mount Morgan. Five prints first described by Ross Staines, the geologist who made such careful notes (1954), purportedly represent a theropod dinosaur that had left a handprint (manus), the interpretation was that this theropod had been walking on all fours. Most theropods are characterised by their obligate bipedal stance. Dr Romilio set out to determine whether this particular track did indeed preserve this very untypical theropod dinosaur behaviour. Unfortunately, it was not possible to access the trace fossils “in situ”, the caverns have been closed since 2011 due to concerns about public safety.
A Line Drawing Showing the Five Tracks Studied
A line drawing showing the five tracks in the study.
Picture credit: Historical Biology
Unable to view the fossils in the cave, it would have been difficult to determine what the tracks represented.
A Stroke of Good Fortune
However, Dr Romilio had a chance meeting with local dentist Dr Roslyn Dick, whose geologist father found many dinosaur fossils over the years.
Ms Dick commented:
“I’m sure Anthony didn’t believe me until I mentioned my father’s name – Ross Staines. Our father was a geologist and reported on the Mount Morgan caves containing the dinosaur tracks in 1954. Besides his published account, he had high-resolution photographs and detailed notebooks, and my sisters and I had kept it all. We even have his dinosaur footprint plaster cast stored under my sister’s Harry Potter cupboard in Sydney.”
A Digitally Reconstructed Dinosaur Track Created from the Archive Material Compiled by Ross Staines
A digital reconstruction of one of the prints studied by Ross Staines.
Picture Credit: Dr Romilio (University of Queensland)
Extensive Notes and Meticulous Records
The extensive information archived by Ross Staines and carefully stored by Ms Dick and her sisters Heather Skinner and Janice Millar, permitted Dr Romilio to conduct a thorough analysis of the trace fossils. He was able to digitise the original analogue photographs and to make a virtual, computer-generated model of the dinosaur track that had been stored under the stairs. As a result, it was concluded that the five tracks were all foot (pes) impressions and that no handprint was present.
It turns out that these tracks do not represent the prints of a single dinosaur, but actually two dinosaurs produced the five tracks, one slightly smaller than the other, which led to the misinterpretation of one of the footprints as being the preserved impression of a dinosaur hand. The splayed toes and moderately long middle digit of the footprints permitted the researcher to determine that these were probably not the footprints of a theropod, but that the tracks represent the progress of a pair of ornithopods.
Dr Romilio commented:
“Rather than one dinosaur walking on four legs, it seems as though we got two dinosaurs for the price of one – both plant-eaters that walked bipedally along the shore of an ancient lake.”
Dinosaur Footprints Mystery Solved
Thanks to the careful conservation of their father’s work, this is one Australian dinosaur trackway mystery that has been solved. These tracks do not represent a theropod dinosaur walking in an uncharacteristic quadrupedal gait, as Dr Romilio explained:
“You don’t assume T. rex used its arms to walk, and we didn’t expect one of its earlier predatory relatives of 200 million years ago did either.”
The contribution of the ladies has been recognised, they are all cited as co-authors/contributors to the scientific paper. We are sure their father would have been very proud.
A Life Reconstruction of the Larger of the Two Ornithopod Dinosaurs Believed to Have Made the Tracks
A reconstruction of the Lower Jurassic ornithopod, the type of dinosaur that probably made the tracks.
Picture credit: Dr Anthony Romilio
Dinosaurs Walking on the Ceiling?
How did the trace fossil end up on the ceiling of a cave? The dinosaurs were not defying gravity, the explanation is very straight-forward. The dinosaurs were walking on the soft sediment associated with a lake around 195 million years ago (Sinemurian faunal stage of the Lower Jurassic), the impressions they made in the soft sediments were infilled with sand. Over time, the softer mudstone and shales were eroded away to expose the imprints as natural casts.
A Photograph of Ross Staines Measuring the Dinosaur Tracks
Ross Staines measuring the footprints 4.5 metres above the cave floor (circa 1954).
Picture credit: University of Queensland
Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the assistance of a media release from the University of Queensland in the compilation of this article.
The scientific paper: “Archival data provides insights into the ambiguous track-maker gait from the Lower Jurassic (Sinemurian) Razorback beds, Queensland, Australia: evidence of theropod quadrupedalism?” by Anthony Romilio, Roslyn Dick, Heather Skinner and Janice Millar published in the journal Historical Biology.
This week has seen the publication of a remarkable paper that documents the discovery of tiny one-billion-year-old fossils of green seaweeds that could be the ancestor of the first land plants.
Writing in the academic journal “Nature Ecology and Evolution”, the researchers from Virginia Tech (USA) and the Chinese Academy of Sciences, describe abundant millimetre-sized, multicellular fossils that were preserved in ancient marine sediments close to the city of Dalian in Liaoning Province (northern China).
Evidence of Ancient Green Seaweed
Proterocladus antiquus fossil material. A photograph of a green seaweed fossil preserved in rocks around 1,000 million years old. The dark colour of this fossil was created by adding a drop of mineral oil to the rock in which it’s embedded, to create contrast.
Picture credit: Virginia Tech
Proterocladus antiquus
The microscopic fossils, measuring around two millimetres in length are described as a new species of green algae (Proterocladus antiquus). The fossil material is interpreted as benthic (living on the sea floor) and members of the Chlorophyta Phylum, which means that these ancient marine plants were photosynthesising 1,000 million years ago and that the fossils are the oldest evidence of green seaweeds known to science.
Shuhai Xiao (Geosciences and Global Change Centre at Virginia Tech), one of the co-authors of the scientific paper commented:
“These new fossils suggest that green seaweeds were important players in the ocean long before their land-plant descendants moved and took control of dry land. The entire biosphere is largely dependent on plants and algae for food and oxygen, yet land plants did not evolve until about 450 million years ago. Our study shows that green seaweeds evolved no later than 1 billion years ago, pushing back the record of green seaweeds by about 200 million years. What kind of seaweeds supplied food to the marine ecosystem?”
Land Plants Evolved from Green Seaweeds
One of the theories proposed for the evolution of land plants is that they originated from marine chlorophytes. These plants adapted to a life on dry land, the scientists propose that these Chinese fossils represent the ancestors of modern land plants that we see today.
However, Xiao added that not all geobiologists agree with this hypothesis, the debate as to how land plants originated goes on. For example, some scientists think that green plants first evolved in freshwater environments before adapting to a terrestrial existence.
A Life Reconstruction of the Ancient Green Seaweed P. antiquus
A digital reconstruction of the ancient green algae (Proterocladus antiquus).
Picture credit: Dinghua Yang/Virginia Tech
Different Types of Seaweed
Scientists have classified three main kinds of seaweed, commonly referred to by their predominant colour. There is brown (Phaeophyceae), green (Chlorophyta) and red (Rhodophyta). There are thousands of species of each kind. Rhodophyta (red seaweed), have a fossil record that also dates back to more than a billion years ago.
Xiao added:
“There are some modern green seaweeds that look very similar to the fossils that we found. A group of modern green seaweeds, known as siphonocladaleans, are particularly similar in shape and size to the fossils we found.”
Early Plant Fossils
The discovery of such an early photosynthetic plant represents a significant landmark in helping scientists to better understand the evolution and development of planetary ecosystems. Plants that photosynthesise are essential to the ecological balance of our planet. They produce carbon and oxygen through the process of photosynthesis and they are regarded as primary producers and comprise the basic components of most food chains.
It was Qing Tang of Virginia Tech, who discovered the micro-fossils of the ancient seaweeds, electron microscopy was used to spot the tiny specimens. To more easily see the fossils, mineral oil was dripped onto the fossil to create a strong contrast.
Tang commented:
“These seaweeds display multiple branches, upright growths, and specialised cells known as akinetes that are very common in this type of fossil. Taken together, these features strongly suggest that the fossil is a green seaweed with complex multicellularity that is circa 1 billion years old. These likely represent the earliest fossil of green seaweeds. In short, our study tells us that the ubiquitous green plants we see today can be traced back to at least 1 billion years.”
Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the assistance of a press release from Virginia Tech in the compilation of this article.
The scientific paper: “A one-billion-year-old multicellular chlorophyte” by Qing Tang, Ke Pang, Xunlai Yuan and Shuhai Xiao published in Nature Ecology and Evolution.
Tiny Fossil Sheds Light on Reptile Diversification in the Triassic
Scientists writing in the on-line, open access journal “Scientific Reports”, have published details of a remarkable fossil discovery from a limestone quarry located close to the town of Vellberg in Baden-Württemberg (Germany). The tiny fossilised remains of juvenile lizard-like reptile are helping palaeontologists to better understand the evolution of modern-day lizards and snakes as well as their taxonomic relationship with a “living fossil” – the tuatara of New Zealand.
A Tiny, Partially Articulated Fossil
The partially articulated fossil, including a beautifully preserved skull, is approximately 240 million-years-old (Middle Triassic – Ladinian faunal stage). The entire specimen is around ten centimetres long and it has been named Vellbergia bartholomaei and classified as a stem-lepidosauromorph.
The Tiny Preserved Skull of Vellbergia bartholomaei
Vellbergia bartholomaei – photograph of fossil skull and interpretative line drawing. The holotype material, note scale bar equals 5 mm approximately.
Picture credit: Scientific Reports
A Decisive Contribution to a Better Understanding of the Evolution of the Reptilia
The Middle Triassic represents a period in Earth’s history where tetrapod faunas were recovering from the global devastation caused by the end Permian extinction event. However, the paucity of terrestrial vertebrate fossils has limited how much scientists can learn about how the fauna changed and developed during this time, prior to the emergence and eventual dominance of the Dinosauria.
Researchers from the Natural History Museum Stuttgart in collaboration with a colleague from Harvard University (USA), noted that the skeleton of V. bartholomaei showed anatomical traits that link it to both the Order Squamata (lizards and snakes) and the Rhynchocephalia, ancient lizard-like reptiles that includes only one living species, the tuatara (Sphenodon punctatus).
Co-author of the Scientific Paper Dr. Rainer Schoch Holding the Tiny Specimen of Vellbergia bartholomaei
Dr. Rainer Schoch (Staatliches Museum für Naturkunde Stuttgart), holding the tiny V. bartholomaei fossil. The skull of the unrelated but contemporary archosaur Batrachotomus can be seen on the right.
Picture credit: Stuttgart Natural History Museum (Staatliches Museum für Naturkunde Stuttgart)
Vellbergia bartholomaei
Vellbergia is named after the nearby town, whilst the species name honours Alfred Bartholomä of Neuenstein, who was responsible for many of the significant fossil finds associated with rocks of the Middle Triassic age from Germany. The new species described here falls into the smallest size cluster so far collected from the Vellberg location, and likely represents the first juvenile individual from the site. This new taxon depicts a mosaic of features that are generally observed in both early evolving rhynchocephalians and squamates, providing a link between the two and suggesting stem-lepidosauromorphs may have survived up to the Middle Triassic.
The mudstones associated with the limestone quarry have proved to be a particularly successful hunting ground for vertebrate palaeontologists. In 2015, Everything Dinosaur reported upon another discovery made by Dr. Rainer Schoch and his colleagues, the finding of the fossilised remains that provided a fresh insight into the origins of modern turtles (Chelonia).
The scientific paper: “A tiny new Middle Triassic stem-lepidosauromorph from Germany: implications for the early evolution of lepidosauromorphs and the Vellberg fauna” by Gabriela Sobral, Tiago R. Simões and Rainer R. Schoch published in Scientific Reports.
A student from Bristol University has carried out a study into the armour on the tail of an aetosaur. The study, published in the Scottish Journal of Geology, has provided fresh information on how these large, lumbering herbivores kept themselves safe from ancient predators. Emily Keeble, a recent graduate from the palaeobiology programme at Bristol University carried out the study under the supervision of Professor Mike Benton (School of Earth Sciences). CT (computerised tomography), scans were undertaken, the first time this scientific method has been employed to better understand how the armour of an aetosaur functioned.
A Model of a Typical Aetosaur.
A model of an aetosaur (ruler provides scale). Although these tetrapods looked formidable with their spikes and their body armour they were herbivores.Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.
Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur
The picture (above) depicts an aetosaur figure (Desmatosuchus haploceras) from Safari Ltd.
Aetosaurs were heavily armoured, herbivorous archosaurs that were geographically widespread during the Middle and Late Triassic. The term “aetosaur” is from the Greek and it means “eagle lizard”, when scientists first examined the skulls of these animals, their superficial resemblance to the skulls of eagles was remarked upon. The fossil specimens used in this research were collected from a sandstone quarry near the town of Elgin in north-eastern Scotland. They had been donated to the nearby Elgin Museum, where staff members Janet Trythall and Alison Wright were able to identify what they were and arrange for the scanning in Bristol.
Professor Benton explained:
“Aetosaurs were first identified from an Elgin specimen in 1844, but at that time people thought they had found a giant fish. The first specimen showed a number of rectangular scales, arranged in a closely overlapping, regular pattern, and it was called Stagonolepis, meaning drop-shaped scale.”
Dorsal and Lateral Views of the Scottish Aetosaur Stagonolepis
The Scottish aetosaur Stagonolepis (A) dorsal and (B) lateral views. Note scale bar = 1 metre.
Picture credit: Bristol University (illustration by Jeffrey Martz after work by Alick Walker)
CT Scans Provide Details on Aetosaur Osteoderm Structure
The fossilised tail bones were subjected to high resolution CT scans, this permitted the researchers to see surface details and the texture of the bones and related armour plates.
Emily Keeble added:
“What had been identified as giant fish scales are actually armour plates, or osteoderms, made of plates of bone and embedded in the skin, just like in modern crocodiles.”
Two specimens were studied, both associated with caudal vertebra and possibly from the same animal, but they do not fit together. Each fossil shows a complete circle of osteoderms around the tail, two above, two on each side, and two below.
Caudal Specimen of Stagonolepis robertsoni Used in the Fossil Study
Stagonolepis robertsoni, ELGNM 2018.6.1 one of the aetosaur caudal vertebra specimens used in the study. Scale bar = 1 cm.
Picture credit: Bristol University
Regular Rows of Osteoderms
The researchers discovered that the rows of osteoderms were very regular and in life covered the entire body from the back of the small head, over the neck, down the back and along the tail. Osteoderms also covered the flanks and underneath. There were even small osteoderms over the fleshy parts of the arms and legs.
The Second Stagonolepis robertsoni Fossil Specimen Used in the Research
Stagonolepis robertsoni ELGNM 2018.6.2 showing internal impressions of the caudal osteoderms in articulation. Note scale bar = 1 cm.
Picture credit: Bristol University
Aetosaur Armour Makes an Effective Defence Against Predators
This study suggests that the armour of these herbivores wrapped around them completely and would have made an effective defence against predators such as rauisuchians and ornithosuchids.
Emily Keeble added:
“Vertebrae of the tail are preserved inside the ring of osteoderms, and these show the specimens were only slightly squished during the preservation process. We could also see how the osteoderms overlap like roof tiles, the osteoderm in front slightly overlapping the one behind. They were linked with connective tissue so the armour overall was flexible, but tough and could probably protect the animal from the fierce predators of its day.”
A Colourised Image of Aetosaur Osteoderms and a Single Scale Shown in More Detail
Reconstructed segment of the aetosaur tail armour and a single osteoderm in more detail.
Picture credit: Emily Keeble (Bristol University)
Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the assistance of a press release from Bristol University in the compilation of this article.
The scientific paper: “Three-dimensional tomographic study of dermal armour from the tail of the Triassic aetosaur Stagonolepis robertsoni” by E. Keeble and M. Benton published in the Scottish Journal of Geology.
Eggshell Geochemistry Suggests Endothermy Deeply Rooted in the Dinosauria
The puzzle of dinosaur metabolism has been a subject of debate amongst vertebrate palaeontologists for a very long time. Numerous studies have been published, drawing on a variety of research methods and lines of enquiry to determine whether the non-avian dinosaurs were warm-blooded like their avian (bird) relatives, or whether they were cold-blooded like today’s crocodilians. A study published in the journal “Science Advances”, one that looked at the geophysical and chemical properties of dinosaur eggshell, has concluded that non-avian dinosaurs had the ability to metabolically raise their temperatures above their environment – in essence they were endothermic, that is to say “warm-blooded”.
A Thin Cross-section of Fossilised Eggshell Viewed under Cross-polarising Light to Reveal Internal Structure
A dinosaur eggshell fossil in cross-section under a microscope using cross-polarising light. Eggshell analysis has provided compelling evidence to suggest that dinosaurs were endothermic. Note scale is 500 microns.
Picture credit: Robin Dawson/University of Yale
Non-avian Dinosaurs were they Cold-blooded or Warm-blooded?
The terms cold-blooded and warm-blooded are found frequently in articles about dinosaurs. These terms are very misleading and have been disregarded for a long time by most of the scientific community. For example, most lizards, regarded as cold-blooded, actually maintain a surprisingly high body temperature in their normal environment during the daytime. Internal body temperatures around 42 degrees Celsius have been recorded in some species, much higher than the normal 37˚ Celsius associated with our own “warm-blooded” species.
In simple terms, cold-blooded animals (ectotherms), are largely unable to regulate their own body temperature without the assistance of external sources. Lizards bask in the early morning sun to warm up and then during the heat of the day, they seek shade to help them to keep cool. In contrast, “warm-blooded” organisms such as mammals and birds (endotherms), are able to maintain a body temperature that is higher than the temperature of the environment. They can generate their own body heat. This heat comes from the animal’s metabolism, the chemical reactions that take place in the body (although there are other methods of keeping cool and warming up).
The Debate over Endothermic or Ectothermic Dinosaurs
Where on the spectrum between endothermic and ectothermic are the Dinosauria? Organisms can demonstrate a range of adaptations to assist them in maintaining an optimal body temperature. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.
Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur
Understanding the Metabolism – So What?
Understanding the metabolism of a long extinct group of animals such as the non-avian members of the Dinosauria, can provide valuable insight into all sorts of areas, such as energy requirements, food consumption, behavioural traits and activity levels. It can also help scientists to understand how extinct animals adapted to a wide range of environments, such as non-avian dinosaurs being found at high latitudes. Dinosaur fossils being discovered in Antarctica for example.
In this newly published study, the researchers used a technique known as clumped isotope palaeothermometry. It is based on the fact that the ordering of oxygen and carbon atoms in a fossil eggshell are determined by temperature. Once the order of the atoms has been plotted, the scientists can calculate the internal body temperature of the egg-layer.
Based on this analysis, the research team were able to demonstrate that potentially, the three major clades of dinosaurs, Ornithischia, Sauropodomorpha and Theropoda, were characterised by warm body temperatures.
Non-avian Dinosaurs Characterised by Warm Body Temperatures
Commenting on the significance of this study, lead author of the research Robin Dawson, who conducted the research while she was a doctoral student in geology and geophysics at Yale University stated:
“Dinosaurs sit at an evolutionary point between birds, which are warm-blooded, and reptiles, which are cold-blooded. Our results suggest that all major groups of dinosaurs had warmer body temperatures than their environment.”
Eggshell ascribed to a troodontid (theropod) tested at 38˚, 27˚, and 28˚ Celsius (100.4, 80.6, and 82.4 degrees Fahrenheit). Eggshells from the large, duck-billed dinosaur Maiasaura (an ornithischian dinosaur), yielded a temperature of 44˚ Celsius (111.2 degrees Fahrenheit). Both the troodontid and Maiasaura eggshells were collected from Alberta, Canada.
Studying Fossil Eggshells
In addition, the fossilised eggs associated with the oospecies Megaloolithus from the Hateg Formation of Romania tested at 36˚ Celsius (96.8 degrees Fahrenheit). The taxonomy of the Romanian material remains uncertain. The eggshells could represent the dwarf titanosaur Magyarosaurus, the much larger titanosaur Paludititan or indeed, the dwarf hadrosauroid Telmatosaurus. If this fossil material does represent a sauropodomorph, then these results could suggest that metabolically controlled thermoregulation was the ancestral condition for the Dinosauria.
The Taxonomic Relationships of the Taxa Involved in the Study
The phylogeny of the taxa involved in the study.
Picture credit: Science Advances
The picture (above), shows living ectotherms in blue, whilst extant endotherms (birds) are shown in orange. The Maiasaura silhouette represents the major dinosaurian subclade Ornithischia. The asterisk (*) indicates the uncertainty over the taxonomy of the oospecies Megaloolithus, but the fossil eggshells could represent the dwarf sauropod Magyarosaurus. The troodontid material is assigned to the Theropoda.
Fossil Shells Compared with Fossil Eggshells
The researchers conducted the same analysis on cold-blooded invertebrate shell fossils (molluscs) from the same locations as the dinosaur eggshells. This helped the scientists determine the temperature of the local environment — and whether dinosaur body temperatures were higher or lower.
Dawson, now a postdoctoral research associate at the University of Massachusetts-Amherst, explained that the troodontid samples were as much as 10˚ Celsius (50 degrees Fahrenheit), warmer than their environment, the Maiasaura samples were 15˚ Celsius warmer (59 degrees Fahrenheit) and the Megaloolithus samples were 3 to 6˚ Celsius (37.4-42.8 degrees Fahrenheit) warmer.
She added:
“What we found indicates that the ability to metabolically raise their temperatures above the environment was an early, evolved trait for dinosaurs.”
Other Implications
This new research may have other implications as well. For instance, the study shows that a dinosaur’s body size and growth rate may not necessarily be a good indicator of body temperature. The researchers also stated that their findings might add to the ongoing discussion about the role of feathers in early bird evolution. Dense coats of feathers may have evolved to help insulate the bodies of dinosaurs, secondary functions such as for use in visual displays or as part of adaptations towards powered flight occurred later.
Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the assistance of a press release from Yale University in the compilation of this article.
The scientific paper: “Eggshell geochemistry reveals ancestral metabolic thermoregulation in Dinosauria” by Robin R. Dawson, Daniel J. Field, Pincelli M. Hull, Darla K. Zelenitsky, François Therrien and Hagit P. Affek published in the journal Science Advances.
Rhamphorhynchids – “Good Climbers and Rare Walkers”
One of the great mysteries regarding the Pterosauria may have finally be solved. Palaeontologists are one “step” closer to better understanding how these flying reptiles moved about on the ground. Researchers studying six pterosaur trackways preserved in the sandstone that once comprised part of a Late Jurassic beach have been able to examine the locomotive abilities of non-pterodactyloid pterosaurs for the first time.
Fossilised Pterosaur Tracks
This is a big deal, tracks of pterosaurs have been known about for some time, but all the trace fossils suggesting tracks up until now were believed to have been made by pterodactyloid pterosaurs, (Pterodactyloidea), essentially flying reptiles with short tails, relatively long metacarpal bones and a fifth toe that is greatly reduced or absent. Virtually nothing was known about the terrestrial abilities of other types of pterosaur that dominated the skies of the Jurassic, the dimorphodonts, Anurognathidae and the rhamphorhynchids for example.
However, scientists from the remarkable Musée de la Plage aux Ptérosaures, writing in the academic journal “Geobios”, describe six trackways related to three non-pterodactyloid new ichnotaxa and determine that these animals moved quadrupedally and that they were quite at home on the ground.
A Life Reconstruction of a Rhamphorhynchid Pterosaur Walking Across a Beach
The long-tailed Rhamphorhynchus leaves a series of five-toed tracks on the Jurassic beach.
Picture credit: Mark Witton
“Good Climbers and Bad Walkers”
Over the last two hundred years or so, a variety of theories have been put forward by palaeontologists regarding the way in which these flying reptiles moved about on the ground. For most of that time, these ideas were based on anatomical analysis of fossil bones. Trackways preserving evidence of a flying reptile moving about on the ground were exceptionally rare. Ironically, when such evidence did come to light, such as the trackway found in Wyoming in 1952 (Sundance Formation), these trace fossils received little scientific scrutiny.
The lack of tracks from non-pterodactyloid pterosaurs preserved in the fossil record, led many palaeontologists to believe that these animals rarely left the trees or the water and moved around on land. When they did, it was thought that they would have been clumsy and slow-moving, very vulnerable to predation.
A Non-pterodactyloid Trackway from the Upper Jurassic (Plage aux Ptérosaures)
Pterosaur trackway (non-pterodactyloid) from south-western France.
Picture credit: Musée de la Plage aux Ptérosaures/Geobios
“The Pterosaur Beach of Crayssac”
The fossil finds come from the remarkable “la Plage aux Ptérosaures” (the pterosaur beach), located close to the village of Crayssac in the Occitanie region of south-western France. The site provides a trace fossil record of activity on a Late Jurassic beach around 150 million years ago (lower Tithonian faunal stage). Both dinosaur and pterosaur trackways are preserved.
The authors of the scientific paper, conclude that the tracks may have been made by rhamphorhynchids and they propose that non-pterodactyloids, at least during the Late Jurassic, were quadrupedal with digitigrade hands and plantigrade to digitigrade feet. Analysis of the tracks indicates that these animals were good walkers, even if their hind legs were hampered by the uropatagium (the membrane of skin that spanned the back legs). The idea that these types of flying reptiles were “good climbers but bad walkers”, seems to have been refuted.
Studying the Pterosaur Tracks
The authors state that based on this new study and contrary to current hypotheses, non-pterodactyloid pterosaurs seem to have been good walkers even though their trackways are very rare or unidentified to date. Each of the trackways is around a metre in length, the individual prints measuring approximately three centimetres long. Jean-Michel Mazin and his co-author Joane Pouech (from the museum at la Plage aux Ptérosaures), were aware of the significance of these trace fossils as pterodactyloids tracks tend to produce four toe marks in the trace fossil, whereas, non-pterodactyloids had five toes, so five toe marks would be expected in the majority of the hind prints.
Pterosaur expert Mark Witton provides a well-written and comprehensive overview of pterosaur anatomy and discusses the theories associated with their terrestrial locomotion in his excellent book simply entitled “Pterosaurs”.
The Front Cover of the Comprehensive Book on Pterosaurs by Mark Witton
A very well researched and documented publication from an authority on the Pterosauria.
The scientific paper: “The first non-pterodactyloid pterosaurian trackways and the terrestrial ability of non-pterodactyloid pterosaurs” by Jean-Michel Mazin and Joane Pouech published in Geobios.