Single Bone Suggests Large Pterosaurs Across Both North and South Laramidia
A single bone from a large pterosaur tentatively described as an ulna found in 2016 has confirmed the presence of large flying reptiles in terrestrial ecosystems in both north and south Laramidia during the Late Cretaceous.
Writing in the on-line, academic journal “PeerJ”, Dr Andrew Farke of the Raymond M. Alf Museum of Palaeontology (Claremont, California), reports that the 36 cm long bone from a bonebed within the middle unit of the Kaiparowits Formation (Utah), extends the distribution of large pterosaurs across terrestrial environments during the Campanian of western North America.
Views of the Single Pterosaur Bone with Accompanying Line Drawings
Views of the pterosaur limb bone with accompanying line drawings. Note scale bar = 10 cm.
Picture credit: Farke (PeerJ)
The picture above shows various views of the single pterosaur limb bone (specimen number RAM 22574). Dorsal (A), proximal (B) with anterior (C) and dorsal (D) views, whilst E and F represent ventral and posterior views. Line drawing (G) shows an interpretation of the posterior view with missing parts shaded and line drawing H shows a posterior view of the complete and restored bone. The large size of the bone has permitted Dr Farke to make an estimate of the wingspan of the pterosaur. He estimates that this bone came from an individual with a wingspan between 4.3 and 5.9 metres. This bone is the largest pterosaur fossil reported to date from the Kaiparowits Formation.
Based on these estimates, the Kaiparowits Formation specimen is roughly comparable in size to Cryodrakon boreas an azhdarchid pterosaur known from the Dinosaur Park Formation of southern Alberta, Canada which was formally named and described in 2019: The First Pterosaur Unique to Canada is Described Cryodrakon boreas.
Significant Pterosaur Fossil Finds Associated with Terrestrial Environments in Late Cretaceous North America
Major pterosaur fossil finds from late Campanian-aged terrestrial depositional environments in western North America.
Picture credit: Farke (PeerJ) with additional annotation from Everything Dinosaur (silhouettes based on work from Naish and Witton)
Silhouettes are scaled to maximum estimates of wingspan for individual specimens. The silhouette for RAM 22574 shows the minimum (black) and maximum (green) size estimates for the specimen (4.3 to 5.9 metre wingspan).
The strata in southern Alberta (Dinosaur Park Formation) from which C. boreas comes from was laid down shortly after the portion of the Kaiparowits Formation associated with this single pterosaur bone. Thus, Dr Farke concludes that relatively large pterosaurs occurred in terrestrial ecosystems in both the northern and southern parts of Laramidia (western North America), during the late Campanian.
The scientific paper: “A large pterosaur limb bone from the Kaiparowits Formation (late Campanian) of Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument, Utah, USA” by Andrew A. Farke published in PeerJ.
Over 240 Fossilised Dinosaur Prints Discovered in South-eastern China
Everything Dinosaur team members have received several media reports from Chinese news agencies about the discovery of an extensive series of dinosaur tracks in Fujian Province (south-eastern China). The dinosaur track site was uncovered in Shanghang County and covers approximately 1,600 square metres. The tracks and individual prints were made around 80 million years ago (Campanian faunal stage of the Late Cretaceous) and they represent the first dinosaur trace fossils to have been found in Fujian Province.
Field Team Members Examine and Map the Dinosaur Tracks
Chinese field team members examine and map the numerous dinosaur tracks and prints uncovered in Fujian Province.
Picture credit: CFP
The Tracks of at Least Eight Different Types of Dinosaur
Extensive track sites such as this are exceptionally rare, early indications from the field team mapping the prints are that at least eight different types of dinosaur are represented. The three-toed prints of ornithopods and the large, more rounded prints of sauropods have been identified. The various media channels have also reported both large and small theropod prints including prints around thirty centimetres in length made by a large, bird-like member of the Deinonychosauria, a raptor that has left distinctive two-toed prints, as the second toe was raised off the ground as it possessed a large, curved sickle-like claw.
Running with Second Toe Raised Off the Ground
A model showing the raised second toe held off the ground as a member of the Deinonychosauria (Velociraptor) runs. Picture credit: Everything Dinosaur.
Xing Lida, from the China University of Geosciences and a member of the research team has stated:
“Judging from the size of the footprints, which were eight to fifty-five centimetres long, lengths of the dinosaurs range from one metre to ten metres.”
The site is under the stewardship of the local authorities in order to protect this important discovery and to deter any would-be fossil hunters who might be tempted to remove any prints for sale on the black market. The site contains at least 240 individual dinosaur prints.
Two of the Dinosaur Prints from the Shanghang County Site
Two dinosaur prints from the Fujian Province site. The research team estimate that the tracks represent lakeside activity from around 80 million years ago.
Picture credit: CFP
Dinosaur Tracks Alongside an Ancient Lake
The tracks were made as dinosaurs visited an ancient lake, the various prints and trackways being preserved in the soft mud on the lake margins.
Senior palaeontologist and former curator at the Zigong Dinosaur Museum (Sichuan Province) Peng Guangzhao, explained that the researchers were optimistic about finding more fossils. The team are hopeful that more tracks, bones or even dinosaur eggs could be discovered in Fujian Province in the future.
Fossil of Dinosaur Sitting on Eggs (Late Stage Incubation)
Fossils of dinosaurs are rare, fossils of articulated dinosaur skeletons rarer still and any fossils that preserve evidence of behaviour, these are amongst the rarest of all, truly scientific treasures. A newly published paper describes the fossilised remains of a Late Cretaceous oviraptorid from east China’s south-eastern Jiangxi Province, a specimen that ticks all these boxes. The fossils represent the partial, articulated remains of oviraptorosaur preserved sitting on a clutch of eggs in a brooding position. Such fossils have been found before, but uniquely these 70-million-year-old remains include fossils of baby dinosaurs preserved inside the eggs, the first time this has been recorded in the non-avian dinosaur fossil record.
The Partially Preserved Adult Oviraptorid On the Nest
The fossilised remains of an oviraptorid with preserved eggs that contain the remains of baby dinosaurs. Note scale bar = 10 cm.
Picture credit: Shundong Bi et al (Science Bulletin)
Sitting Atop a Dinosaur Nest
The multinational team of researchers includes Dr Shundong Bi (Indiana University of Pennsylvania) and Xing Xu (Institute of Vertebrate Palaeontology – Beijing) along with Dr Matt Lamanna (Carnegie Museum of Natural History) and scientific illustrator Andrew McAfee.
Commenting on the significance of this discovery, Dr Bi stated:
“Dinosaurs preserved on their nests are rare, and so are fossil embryos. This is the first time a non-avian dinosaur has been found, sitting on a nest of eggs that preserve embryos, in a single spectacular specimen.”
Fossils of brooding dinosaurs have been found before, perhaps the most famous is “Big Mamma” the fossilised remains of an adult Citipati osmolskae (also an oviraptorid) on display at the American Museum of Natural History (New York).
Citipati osmolskae Fossil Sitting Atop a Nest of Eggs
The Citipati fossil sitting on a nest “Big Mamma”.
Picture credit: The American Museum of Natural History
An Oviraptorid – A Very Bird-like Dinosaur
The Chinese fossil material has been assigned to the Oviraptoridae, although Everything Dinosaur are not aware of any new taxon being announced. Oviraptorid dinosaurs are mainly associated with Asia, but the closely related Caenagnathidae are also known from North America. The bones of these dinosaurs are very bird-like and they do belong to a great linage of theropods that are related to modern birds (the Maniraptora).
The specimen represents an incomplete, articulated skeleton of a large, (presumably adult) oviraptorid crouched in a bird-like brooding posture over a clutch of at least twenty-four eggs. The adult appears to have perished whilst brooding the clutch. The researchers identified the preserved remains of seven unhatched dinosaurs entombed inside the eggs. The late stage of development of the embryos suggests that, just like modern birds, oviraptorids brooded their eggs, rather than simply guarding them as observed in extant crocodilians.
A Caring Parent
Dr Lamanna explained:
“This kind of discovery, in essence, fossilised behaviour, is the rarest of the rare in dinosaurs. Though a few adult oviraptorids have been found on nests of their eggs before, no embryos have ever been found inside those eggs. In the new specimen, the babies were almost ready to hatch, which tells us beyond a doubt that this oviraptorid had tended its nest for quite a long time. This dinosaur was a caring parent that ultimately gave its life while nurturing its young.”
As part of their research, the scientists conducted an oxygen isotope study that demonstrated that the eggs were incubated at high bird-like temperatures, further evidence to support the idea that the adult died whilst brooding its clutch of eggs. Analysis of the tiny baby dinosaur bones preserved inside their eggs indicate that some babies were more fully developed than others, this suggests that the eggs might have hatched at different intervals, a hatching strategy known as asynchronous hatching. This strategy is found in many types of birds today such as Shoebill storks and numerous species of birds of prey such as raptors and owls.
Oviraptorids – Evidence that they were Caring Parents
A pair of oviraptorosaurs. Scientists suggest that these dinosaurs incubated their eggs and that they were caring parents.
Picture credit: Mike Skrepnick
Asynchronous hatching appears to have evolved independently in oviraptorids and modern avians.
The Evolutionary Benefits of Asynchronous Hatching
If the eggs of oviraptorids did hatch at different intervals, then this too can provide an insight into the behaviour of these Late Cretaceous dinosaurs. Biologists have identified a number of reasons why some kinds of bird alive today have evolved asynchronous hatching.
The evolutionary benefits of asynchronous hatching:
To reduce the losses from predators due to the whole brood not being present in the nest at the same time.
The younger animals are a back-up plan in case earlier hatched animals die.
When food resources are scarce the adults can dedicate the bulk of these scarce resources to the older babies and let the younger siblings perish.
Reduces the demands on the parents as they do not have to care for all the babies at the same time.
Gastroliths Identified
The researchers also noted the presence of gastroliths (stomach stones). A cluster of tiny pebbles had accumulated in the body cavity of the adult dinosaur. Gastroliths are associated with many different types of dinosaur, but this is the first time that undoubted gastroliths have been found in an oviraptorid. As such, these stones may provide new insights into the diets of these very bird-like dinosaurs.
Dr Xu concluded:
“It’s extraordinary to think how much biological information is captured in just this single fossil. We’re going to be learning from this specimen for many years to come.”
Everything Dinosaur acknowledges the assistance of a press release from the Carnegie Museum of Natural History (Pennsylvania).
The scientific paper: “An oviraptorid preserved atop an embryo-bearing egg clutch sheds light on the reproductive biology of non-avialan theropod dinosaurs” by Shundong Bi, Romain Amiot, Claire Peyre de Fabrègues, Michael Pittman, Matthew C. Lamanna, Yilun Yu, Congyu Yu, Tzuruei Yang, Shukang Zhang, Qi Zhao and Xing Xu published in Science Bulletin.
Study Suggests Ziphodont Dentition Appeared First in Synapsids
If we ever get back into cinemas (the ravages of COVID-19 notwithstanding), if the latest instalment of the “Jurassic Park/Jurassic World” franchise ever gets released, then movie goers will be treated to lots of scenes of scary-looking meat-eating dinosaurs flashing their huge teeth in their cavernous mouths at their luckless human victims.
Huge theropod dinosaurs such as Acrocanthosaurus, Giganotosaurus and T. rex might be famous for their big teeth, with serrations running along the edges, after all, we have all heard and probably used the term “steak knives” to describe the shape of tyrannosaur teeth, but new research published in Biology Letters suggest that it was those tetrapods that were eventually to lead to the mammalian lineage that evolved such specialised tearing and cutting teeth first.
Theropod Dinosaurs Are Famous for Their Teeth Adapted to Cutting and Tearing Flesh
The PNSO A-shu the Qianzhousaurus dinosaur model has an articulated jaw. The tyrannosaurid Qianzhousaurus has the typical serrated and blade-like teeth of a carnivorous dinosaur (ziphodont dentition).
The picture (above) shows a replica of a PNSO theropod dinosaur (Qianzhousaurus).
Teeth that are laterally compressed, pointed and have serrated edges are known as ziphodont teeth (ziphodont dentition). The teeth of Theropoda, the only clade of predominantly predatory dinosaurs, are characterised by ziphodonty, the presence of serrations (denticles) on their cutting edges (carinae). Today, such dentition is only found in monitor lizards (varanids) but the fossil record reveals that this condition was much more pervasive in the past.
A team of researchers from Harvard University (USA), in collaboration with colleagues based at the universities of Manitoba, Alberta and Ontario (Canada), examined and compared the teeth from four types of extinct prehistoric hypercarnivore (an animal that gets at least 70% of its nutrition from the consumption of the flesh of other animals).
The teeth studied were:
Tyrannosaurid tooth from the Dinosaur Provincial Park (Alberta, Canada) – a Late Cretaceous tyrannosaur tooth which is approximately 75 million years old.
Dimetrodon grandis tooth (synapsid, pelycosaur) from the Arroyo Formation Texas, USA) which is approximately 275 million years old.
A tooth from the Permian gorgonopsid Lycaenops ornatus from the Upper Permian Madumabisa Mudstone Formation of Zambia. A synapsid (Therapsida) that lived approximately 265 million years ago.
An upper canine tooth from Smilodon fatalis a member of the Felidae (cat family). The tooth comes from the Talara “tar pits” of Peru. The youngest tooth in the research circa 13,000 years old.
The scientists identified the same denticles and interdental folds forming the cutting edges in the teeth of the Permian gorgonopsid (L. ornatus), as those seen in members of the Theropoda.
Non-mammalian Synapsid Teeth
The researchers conclude that these tooth features, specifically adaptations to assist with the processing of meat, first appeared in the non-mammalian synapsids. Comparisons of tooth serrations in gorgonopsians with those of earlier synapsids and hyper carnivorous mammals reveal that some gorgonopsians acquired a complex tissue arrangement that differed from other synapsids,
Plotting the Serrations in Non-mammalian Synapsids
The skull of the gorgonopsid Lycaenops ornatus (a), serrations on the canine (b) and (c) serrations on the incisors in the premaxilla.
Picture credit: Whitney et al (Biology Letters)
In 2015, Everything Dinosaur published an article on research into the Theropoda that looked specifically at the interdental folds associated with their teeth.
This new study demonstrates that similar types of teeth evolved in different types of hypercarnivores that were not closely related. This is an example of convergent evolution and the ziphodont teeth of the non-mammalian synapsids represent the earliest record of this adaptation and indicate that the first iteration of this morphological feature appeared long before the Dinosauria evolved.
High Magnification Images Showing the Morphology of the Carinae (Cutting Edges)
Thin section through distal serrations of NHCC LB334 displaying both interdental folds and denticles (d). Dashed box indicates location of high magnification images in both plain (e) and cross polarized light (f). Both (e) and (f) highlight features of the denticles and interdental folds including the enamel spindles that cross the enamel.
Picture credit: Whitney et al (Biology Letters)
The scientific paper: “Convergent dental adaptations in the serrations of hypercarnivorous synapsids and dinosaurs” by M. R. Whitney, A. R. H. LeBlanc, A. R. Reynolds and K. S. Brink published in Biology Letters.
Everything Dinosaur team members conclude their review of their favourite blog articles of 2020 by looking at articles and news stories that were posted up between July and December. With the best part of 180 posts to choose from selecting our favourite six for this period was quite tricky. The ones we have selected demonstrate the broad range of topics we cover on the Everything Dinosaur weblog.
We might have been in the middle of a global pandemic but Everything Dinosaur team members kept up their blogging reporting upon tiny theropod eggs from Japan, a revision of Dilophosaurus and a number of new dinosaurs. Our favourite post of the month concerned the scientific description of Aratasaurus museunacionali, a basal member of the Coelurosauria from Brazil. The genus name translates as “lizard born of fire”, a reference to the terrible fire that ripped through the National Museum of Brazil where the fossil specimen was kept.
A Life Reconstruction of the Basal Member of the Coelurosauria Aratasaurus museunacionali
The controversy over the naming of the smallest dinosaur based on a skull preserved in amber from northern Myanmar rumbled on. In August, a paper was published that refuted claims that the tiny skull of the animal named Oculudentavis khaungraae was that of an archosaur. A month earlier (July 2020), the original scientific paper describing this remarkable fossil was retracted.
The Tiny Fossil Skull Preserved in Amber from Myanmar – But is it a Dinosaur?
Tiny fossil skull preserved in amber (Oculudentavis khaungraae).
The Oxford University Museum of Natural History celebrated its 160th birthday, the Monsters of the Deep exhibition opened in the midst of the chaos caused by COVID-19 and Euparkeria got a makeover. Our favourite post of September concerned a new species of trilobite (Gravicalymene bakeri) from Tasmanian that was named after Doctor Who actor Tom Baker.
A Photograph of a Gravicalymene bakeri Trilobite Fossil with Line Drawing
Gravicalymene bakeri trilobite fossil with line drawing.
In October we reported on the mapping of the genome of the Scimitar-toothed cat Homotherium latidens, discussed a new species of mosasaur from Morocco and the diet of pterosaurs, but our favourite article concerned the research into ancient dog DNA. The study suggested that the diversity observed between dogs in different parts of the world today originated when all of mankind were hunters and gatherers.
Mapping Ancient Doggy DNA
Mesolithic dog skull (left) compared to wolf skull (right).
Picture credit: E. E. Antipina (Institute of Archaeology of the Russian Academy of Sciences)
In November, Everything Dinosaur celebrated publishing its 5,000 blog post, discussed Kholumolumo a dinosaur from an African rubbish dump, looked at seal evolution and got to grips with the earliest Paranthropus robustus skull described to date.
Our favourite post concerned the first dinosaur remains reported from Ireland, not just one dinosaur but two!
First Evidence of Dinosaurs from Ireland
Dr Mike Simms (National Museums Northern Ireland) holds the theropod tibia on the left and the thyreophoran femur on the right.
As the year closed, in the final month of 2020 we looked at how interactive “I-books” were helping to explain archaeology, examined a very flashy new dinosaur (U. jubatus), the first sauropod dinosaur from Switzerland (Amanzia greppini) and studied Parasaurolophus pathology.
Our favourite post concerned the establishment of a new species of Late Jurassic ichthyosaur after the discovery of fossil bones by the wonderful Dr Steve Etches MBE, the founder of the amazing Etches Collection museum in Dorset.
A Life Reconstruction of the Newly Described Thalassodraco etchesi
A life reconstruction of the newly described Late Jurassic ichthyosaur Thalassodraco etchesi.
Picture credit: Megan Jacobs/University of Portsmouth
At Everything Dinosaur, we try and post up an article on this blog site every single day. This can be quite a challenge considering all our other activities and projects. However, as a result of our work on this weblog we have managed to compile a huge amount of information, articles and features chronicling (for the most part), advances in the Earth sciences and new fossil discoveries along with research into the Dinosauria.
This year, Everything Dinosaur’s blog has passed the 5,000 articles benchmark. Here is a selection of our own favourite news stories that we have covered in the first six months of 2020 (January to June).
January – A New Allosaurus Taxon
In January, a new species of North American Allosaurus was added to the pantheon of dinosaurs known from the famous Morrison Formation of the western United States. Allosaurus jimmadseni honours the sadly departed James H. Madsen Jr. Utah’s inaugural state palaeontologist. The famous Allosaurus specimen MOR 693 “Big Al” was reassigned to this new species.
A Pack of Allosaurus (A. jimmadseni) Attack a Luckless Juvenile Sauropod
A pack of allosaurs (A. jimmadseni) attacking a juvenile sauropod.
February – The “Father of Argentinian Palaeontology” – José Bonaparte
On the 18th February José Bonaparte, regarded by many as the most influential vertebrate palaeontologist of the 20th century passed away. Respected and admired, José helped to develop and train a whole new generation of Earth scientists. He was also responsible for naming and describing a large number of new dinosaurs including Abelisaurus, hence our illustration of that South American theropod (below).
José Bonaparte and a Drawing of One of the Many Dinosaurs He Named and Described (Abelisaurus comahuensis)
José Bonaparte (inset) and a drawing of one of the dinosaurs he named in his long and distinguished career Abelisaurus (A. comahuensis).
As the COVID-19 pandemic took hold, team members at Everything Dinosaur were distracted by some remarkable research undertaken by scientists from the University of Ghent and the Vrije Universiteit Brussel.
A study of the growth rings preserved on the fossilised shells of Cretaceous bivalves permitted the researchers to calculate that 70 million years ago, the day length was approximately thirty minutes shorter and a year on Earth was around a week longer than it is today.
The remarkable Drimolen fossil hominin site in South Africa, provided palaeoanthropologists with likely confirmation that the hominin H. erectus did indeed evolve in Africa and not Asia. A carefully and painstakingly reconstructed fossil skull (DNH 134), found in this area – regarded as the “Cradle of Humankind”, suggests that Homo erectus existed some 100,000 to 200,000 years earlier than previously realised.
We still have a lot to learn about our own evolution.
Homo erectus Evolved in Africa
The partial H. erectus cranium from the Drimolen Fossil Hominin site.
A jawbone found on the Isle of Wight was identified as a new species of tapejarid pterosaur. The flying reptile, named Wightia declivirostris which translates as “slanting beak from the Isle of Wight” was one of several new pterosaur species described in 2020.
A Life Reconstruction of the Early Cretaceous Pterosaur Wightia declivirostris
A life reconstruction of the newly described tapejarid from the Lower Cretaceous of the Isle of Wight (Wightia declivirostris).
Picture credit: Megan Jacobs (University of Portsmouth)
A fossil discovered more than fifty years ago and regarded as little more than a “fossilised stick” has proved to be a new species of Late Devonian plant and it will help scientists to better understand the flora of the ancient landmass of Gondwana.
The specimen was found by amateur geologist John Irving whilst exploring the banks of the Manilla River in Barraba (New South Wales, Australia). A study in the open-access journal PeerJ identifies the newly named Keraphyton mawsoniae and proposes that it has a similar structure to primitive horsetails and ferns. The fossil which looks so unremarkable on the outside, once studied in cross-section, has provided a unique window into the plant life on Earth around 360 million years ago.
Not Much to Look at on the Outside but Inside a Treasure Trove of Information for Palaeobotanists
The newly described Keraphyton mawsoniae a fern-like land plant from the Late Devonian of Australia.
A new genus of feathered dinosaur Ubirajara jubatus has been described.
News about the discovery of a species of feathered dinosaur has now become relatively commonplace. Yet, it is worth remembering that it was just twenty-four years ago, back in 1996, that the first, non-avian dinosaur species with evidence of fuzzy feathers was described. Named Sinosauropteryx this lithe meat-eater literally “rocked” scientists as the long-awaited proof of feathered dinosaurs was revealed to the world. Sinosauropteryx was a compsognathid, a team of researchers, including scientists from the University of Portsmouth have described another feathered dinosaur, this new feathered theropod is a compsognathid too, but with a more elaborate and spectacular integumentary covering.
Ubirajara jubatus
The newly described Ubirajara jubatus is the first Gondwanan non-avian theropod with preserved filamentous integumentary structures. It is also the first non-maniraptoran possessing elaborate integumentary structures that were most likely used for display.
A Life Reconstruction of the Newly Described Brazilian Compsognathid Ubirajara jubatus
Ubirajara jubatus life reconstruction by the very talented palaeoartist Bob Nicholls.
Picture credit: Bob Nicholls/Paleocreations
Dressed to Impress
Described as the most elaborately dressed-to-impress dinosaur described to date, the research team co-led by Professor David Martill and researcher Robert Smyth (University of Portsmouth), propose that U. jubatus will shed new light on how birds evolved elaborate display structures.
This chicken-sized dinosaur possessed a mane of long bristles running down its back and stiff ribbons projecting out and back from its shoulders, a combination of features never seen before in the fossil record.
The scientific paper has been published in the journal of Cretaceous research and involved a collaboration between the University of Portsmouth and the appropriately named Professor Dino Frey at the State Museum of Natural History, Karlsruhe, Germany, who discovered the new species while examining fossils in Karlsruhe´s collection and Héctor E. Rivera-Sylva of the Departamento de Paleontología, Museo del Desierto in Saltillo, Mexico. The fossil was authorised by the Brazilian authorities for export some time ago, but was only recently studied.
Bizarre Integumentary Structures
The bizarre integumentary structures must have had a purpose, whilst the body covering may have originally evolved to provide insulation, the stiff ribbons on either side of the shoulders were probably used for display, perhaps to attract a mate, deter a rival or to frighten a potential predator.
Professor Martill commented:
“We cannot prove that the specimen is a male, but given the disparity between male and female birds, it appears likely the specimen was a male, and young, too, which is surprising given most complex display abilities are reserved for mature adult males. Given its flamboyance, we can imagine that the dinosaur may have indulged in elaborate dancing to show off its display structures.”
Not Scales or Fur
The ribbons are not fur or scales, they are not feathers in the modern sense, as seen on an extant bird. They appear to be structures unique to this animal.
Mr Smyth added:
“These are such extravagant features for such a small animal and not at all what we would predict if we only had the skeleton preserved. Why adorn yourself in a way that makes you more obvious to both your prey and to potential predators? The truth is that for many animals, evolutionary success is about more than just surviving, you also have to look good if you want to pass your genes on to the next generation.”
The Holotype of Ubirajara jubatus Preserved as a Slab and Counter Slab
The holotype of Ubirajara jubatus preserved as slab and counter slab. Note scale bar = 50 mm.
Picture credit: Smyth et al /Cretaceous Research
From the Lower Cretaceous (Aptian) Crato Formation of North-eastern Brazil
Fossil discoveries starting with the ground-breaking Sinosauropteryx specimen that was described in 1996 have fundamentally changed our understanding of the phylogenetic relationships between birds and dinosaurs as well as the origin and evolution of feathers. A variety of elaborate integumentary coverings and structures are now known from the Theropoda and from ornithischian dinosaurs too. They have been linked to behaviours including egg incubation, mating displays and thermoregulation.
The Colourful PNSO Model of the Chinese Compsognathid Sinosauropteryx
PNSO Yuyan the Sinosauropteryx dinosaur model. The PNSO model of the compsognathid Sinosauropteryx.
The picture (above) shows a PNSO Sinosauropteryx dinosaur model.
Within the Theropoda, such features have only been previously recorded within the Maniraptoriformes, a theropod clade which includes birds and is defined as “the most recent common ancestor of the ostrich mimic Ornithomimus and Aves (birds) and all descendants of that common ancestor.”
The majority of theropods preserving integumental structures come from the Upper Jurassic and Lower Cretaceous of China or the Upper Jurassic of southern Germany and all are of Laurasian origin. Ubirajara jubatus from the Lower Cretaceous (Aptian) Crato Formation of north-eastern Brazil, is the first non-maniraptoran possessing elaborate integumentary structures that were most likely used for display.
Ubirajara jubatus the First Non-avian Theropod with Preserved Filamentous Structures
It is also the first non-avian theropod with preserved filamentous integumentary structures to have been described from the southern hemisphere landmass of Gondwana.
The researchers compare Ubirajara to living birds stating that many modern Aves are famed for their exotic and colourful plumage along with their complex displays that are used to win mates. Male peacocks with their stunning tails and male birds of paradise are examples of this.
Ubirajara jubatus (pronounce You-bi-rah-jar-rah jew-bay-tus), lived approximately 110 million years ago (Aptian faunal stage of the Early Cretaceous). The genus name is derived from the local Tupi dialect and translates as “lord of the spear”, whilst the trivial or specific name is from the Latin for “mane” a reference to the integumentary covering on its back.
Able to Raise its Hackles Like a Dog?
The mane running down its back is thought to have been controlled by muscles allowing it to be raised, in a similar way a dog raises its hackles or a porcupine raises its spines when facing a threat. Once the danger had passed, Ubirajara could lower its mane close to the skin allowing this little dinosaur to move quickly through the undergrowth without getting tangled up.
Professor Martill explained:
“Any creature with movable hair or feathers as a body coverage has a great advantage in streamlining the body contour for faster hunts or escapes but also to capture or release heat.”
The unique body plan of Ubirajara with its long, flat, stiff shoulder ribbons of keratin, each with a small sharp ridge running along the middle, described by the authors as “enigmatic” might have looked cumbersome, but in reality they were located on the body in such a way as not to impede movement allowing Ubirajara to preen, hunt, move around and display unencumbered.
The scientific paper: The scientific paper: “A maned theropod dinosaur from Gondwana with elaborate integumentary structures” by Robert S. H. Smyth, David M. Martill, Eberhard Frey, Héctor E. Rivera-Sylva and Norbert Lenz published in Cretaceous Research. This paper was withdrawn in July 2022.
The last type of sauropod to have lived were the Titanosauria, a clade consisting of a variety of taxa that were geographically widespread. Fossils of titanosaurs have been found on every continent. These long-necked herbivores seem to have been particularly successful in South America, with some of the largest tetrapods of all time – Argentinosaurus, Patagotitan and Dreadnoughtus known from this continent.
A team of scientists based in Argentina recently published a paper describing two new South American titanosaurs from the province of La Rioja located in the north-west of that country. The dinosaurs named Punatitan coughlini and Bravasaurus arrierosorum, help to fill a gap between the types of titanosaurs associated with Patagonia and south-western Brazil, the two main locations associated with Titanosauria fossil discoveries from South America.
Skeletal Drawings Punatitan coughlini (c) and (d) Bravasaurus arrierosorum
Punatitan coughlini (c) and (d) Bravasaurus arrierosorum. Known fossil material shown in red. Scale bar = 1 metre.
Picture credit: Hechenleitner et al (Communications Biology)
Dinosaurs from the Andes – Titanosaurs Demonstrate Philopatry
The fossil material representing three individuals was found in the Upper Cretaceous red beds of the Quebrada de Santo Domingo locality in the Andes of La Rioja province. In addition, a large number of titanosaurian egg clutches and eggshells were recovered. Such was the abundance of eggshell found that this location is regarded as one the largest dinosaur nesting sites known in the world. These fossils help to support the theory that these types of dinosaurs returned to the same, favoured nesting area year after year, the titanosaurs demonstrated philopatry (the tendency of an organism to habitually return to the same location, usually to breed or to nest).
Cervical and dorsal vertebrae of Punatitan coughlini
Cervical and dorsal vertebrae of Punatitan coughlini.
Picture credit: Hechenleitner et al (Communications Biology)
Limb Bones Associated with Bravasaurus arrierosorum
Limb elements of Bravasaurus arrierosorum.
Picture credit: Hechenleitner et al (Communications Biology)
Titanosauria Phylogenetic Analysis
A phylogenetic analysis undertaken by the research team suggests that both Bravasaurus and the much larger Punatitan have affinities with both Patagonian and Brazilian titanosaurs. The discovery of these two genera, both classified within the sub-clade of the Rinconsauria, supports the hypothesis of a close relationship between titanosaurian faunas in South America during the Late Cretaceous.
Titanosaur Palaeogeographical Distribution and Phylogeny
Titanosaur palaeogeographical distribution and phylogeny plotted against temporal distribution. Both Punatitan and Bravasaurus have been assigned to the sub-clade Rinconsauria and they show a link between southern and northern populations of South American titanosaurs.
Picture credit: Hechenleitner et al (Communications Biology)
The Site of the Fossil Discoveries and Plotting the Location of Titanosaurs in South America
Percentage diversity of Cretaceous titanosaurian sauropods in three main regions of South America: Patagonia (purple), north-western Argentina (green), and south-west Brazil (yellow). The yellow ring corresponds to the record of the saltasaurid titanosaurian Yamanasaurus in Ecuador. Location of the discoveries in La Rioja Province are shown in (b) and (c).
Picture credit: Hechenleitner et al (Communications Biology)
The scientific paper: “Two Late Cretaceous sauropods reveal titanosaurian dispersal across South America” by E. Martín Hechenleitner, Léa Leuzinger, Agustín G. Martinelli, Sebastián Rocher, Lucas E. Fiorelli, Jeremías R. A. Taborda, and Leonardo Salgado published in Communications Biology.
A New Tyrannosauroid from Northern China – Jinbeisaurus wangi
Over the last two years or so, there have been a number of exciting dinosaur discoveries. Some amazing dinosaur fossils have been found and scientifically described, but sometimes mere scraps of bone, just fragmentary remains can be enough to set the pulses of vertebrate palaeontologists racing. Take for example, the new genus of Late Cretaceous tyrannosaur from northern China that was formally described back in April. At around 5-6 metres in length Jinbeisaurus wangi, may not be the largest carnivorous dinosaur known from Upper Cretaceous deposits from Asia, but it does represent the first theropod to be described from the Chinese province of Shanxi.
Jinbeisaurus wangi
An initial assessment led to the jaw bones, partial pubis (bone from the hip) and incomplete dorsal and cervical vertebrae, being assigned to the Tarbosaurus genus, but unique characteristics associated with the shape and proportion of the maxilla led to erection of a new species.
The Genus Has Been Erected Based on Autapomorphies Identified in the Jaws
Views of J. wangi maxillae and accompanying line drawings. The photograph (above) shows photographs of the upper jaw bones (maxillae), plus a close-up view of a single tooth.
Picture credit: Xiao-Chun Wu et al (Cretaceous Research)
Not a Juvenile Tarbosaurus
The scientific paper describing Jinbeisaurus (pronounced jin-bay-sore-us), was published in late 2019 in the journal “Cretaceous Research”, although it had originally been submitted in the spring, only to be revised before final publication. When the fossil material was found near the city of Yangjiayao, Tianzhen County, Shanxi Province, in northern China, it was suggested that the bones could represent a juvenile Tarbosaurus. This new dinosaur, J. wangi adds to the known diversity of tyrannosauroids in Asia and represents the first theropod to have been discovered in Shanxi Province, although isolated teeth representing carnivorous dinosaurs are known from the area.
Views of the Upper and Lower Jaw Bones of J. wangi
Views of the upper and lower Jaw of J. wangi with accompanying line drawings.
Picture credit: Xiao-Chun Wu et al (Cretaceous Research)
Estimated to have measured around 5-6 metres long, Jinbeisaurus wangi is regarded as more derived than Suskityrannus (S. hazelae) a tyrannosauroid from New Mexico named earlier in 2019.
The scientific paper: “A new tyrannosauroid from the Upper Cretaceous of Shanxi, China” by Xiao-Chun Wu, Jian-Ru Shi, Li-Yang Dong, Thomas D. Carr, Jian Yi and Shi-Chao Xu published in Cretaceous Research.
Aware of the hastag “#FossilFriday”, it seems appropriate that we should post up a picture of a fossil on Friday, as we approach the busiest time of year for the packing and despatching of models and figures that have been inspired by the fossil record. Team members at Everything Dinosaur have chosen to post up a photograph of the bizarre, marine reptile, known from the Middle Triassic of south-western China called Atopodentatus. It seems appropriate that with all the amazing fossils that are in museum collections around the world, we should post a photograph of one of the strangest Mesozoic vertebrates known to science.
The Fossilised Remains of Atopodentatus unicus
Bizarre Triassic marine reptile! The beautifully preserved and articulated remains of Atopodentatus unicus from Yunnan Province in south-western China. Note the close-up view of the strange skull and jaws, that were originally interpretated as being a zipper-like feeding apparatus. Further fossil discoveries made two years after the initial description of this marine reptile, revealed that Atopodentatus had jaws shaped like a hammerhead.
Picture credit: Long Cheng/Wuhan Institute of Geology and Mineral Resources
Note
Scale bar in main photograph equals 20 centimetres, scale bar for close-up of skull equals 3 centimetres.
Named in 2014 (Long Cheng et al), Atopodentatus had jaws shaped like a hammerhead, superficially similar to that seen in an extant Hammerhead shark. Unlike the shark, Atopodentatus is believed to have been herbivorous. It used its comb-like teeth to rasp away at rocks, feeding on algae and seaweed.
When the scientific paper was published, it was noted that Atopodentatus represents the oldest known record of herbivory within marine reptiles.
Chinese model and figure manufacturers PNSO will be introducing a mid-size replica of this strange animal. This figure will be in stock at Everything Dinosaur in a few weeks (estimated to be in stock by the end of December 2020). It is great to see PNSO adding a second replica of the bizarre Atopodentatus to their model range.
PNSO Have Made Another Model of the Strange Chinese Marine Reptile Atopodentatus (A. unicus)
PNSO Zewail the Atopodentatus marine reptile model. This figure, along with numerous other PNSO mid-size models will be in stock at Everything Dinosaur very soon (late December 2020). The model displays that unique jaw structure which is unknown in any other reptile.
It therefore seems appropriate to post up pictures of the Middle Triassic record-breaker Atopodentatus unicus for Fossil Friday.